HomeMy WebLinkAbout2006-04-17 Council Board Of Review & Equalization MINUTES
OF THE MEETING OF THE
EDINA BOARD OF REVIEW HELD AT CITY HALL
APRIL 17,2006, AT 5:30 P.M.
ROLLCALL Answering rollcall were Members Housh, Hulbert, Masica, Swenson, and Mayor
Hovland.
The meeting was convened pursuant to published Notice of Board of Review in the Edina Sun-
Current and notice posted on City bulletin boards for the purpose of hearing those persons who
considered themselves aggrieved by their property valuation for assessment purposes, or who were
requesting homestead classification.
Mayor Hovland stated no decision would be made at this meeting, but would take place at the
continuation meeting of the Board on May 4, 2006. He added that property owners would be notified
of the Board's decision within twenty days. Further appeal may be made to the Hennepin County
Board of Equalization beginning June 19, 2006.
The following property owners appeared personally or were represented before the Board to object to
the Assessor's estimated market value as of January 2,2006:
2006 Original Est. Owners'
Name Address PID Number Market Value Requested
Value
Kamay&Joseph Terry 5109 Ridge Road 30-117-21-42-0024 $861,900 $783,227
Franz J. Metzger 5021 Schaefer Road 30-117-21-41-0004 $756,300 Not Specified
Dan Mulvehill 5940 Walnut Drive 31-117-21-31-0026 $347,700 $310,000
Margaret K.S iesel 6620 Dovre Drive 31-117-21-24-0020 $872,300 Not Specified
Gary&Tanya Lehr 6566 France Ave S#905 30-028-24-14-0103 $291,900 $230,00
Donald&Barbara Steinkamp 4912 Payton Court 30-028-24-32-0040 $413,800 $260,560
Karen M. Gooch 5800 Olinger Boulevard 32-117-21-34-0071 $504,300 $475,000
Marshall Silberstein 5828 Dewey Hill Road 08-11-21-24-0006 $386,800 $350,000
T.C. &Marilyn Cadwell 7308 Wooddale Ave 31-028-24-24-0081 $394,400 $337,100
Alex&Margaret Zhuravel 5812 Hansen Road 32-117-21-41-0068 $349,900 $310,000
Jack Leibman 6566 France Avenue#907 30-028-24-14-0105 $291,900 $250,000
Patrick Fleetham 4300 Branson Street 07-028-24-43-0111 $278,600 Not Specified
Marcia McCormick Herman 4602 Drexel Avenue 18-028-24-12-0136 $1,126,600 $1,099,300
Elaine Murphy 5539 Village Drive 08-116-21-12-0041 $373,100 Not Specified
Dan Schleck 7408 Kellogg 31-028-24-31-0033 $571,800 Not Specified
Jeffrey&Therese Hovanec 5030 Bruce Place 18-028-24-42-0012 $1,578,500 Not Specified
Dave Thompson 5517 Valley Lane 1 05-116-21-13-0057 $517,700 Not Specified
Dino Balafas 5316 Blake Road 1 30-117-21-44-0061 $671,600 Not Specified
The Council heard the owners present their reasons for requesting reductions and in some cases,
asked questions clarifying issues.
The owners of the following properties submitted applications or letters objecting to their market
value and requested the Board's review,however,the owners did not appear personally:
2006 Original Est. Owners'
Name Address PID Number Market Value Requested
El Value
[ssociates/Jake 1pitas-Flemming 5201 W 73rd St/7350 Ohms 09-116-21-23-0012 $2,032,200 $1,500,000
Evans Lane
[Richard&Sheila Student 6417 Biscayne Boulevard 31-117-21-13-0015 $772,000 $695,000
harles&Bette Sedgwick 6517 Ryan 30-028-24-23-0081 $276,400 $265,800
Minutes/Edina Board of Review/April 17,2006
William&Colette Bednarezyk 6566 France Ave S#1004 30-028-24-14-00114 $418,300 $366,400
Loon Haven,LLC/Jim Lindsey 6996 France Ave S 30-028-24-44-0001 $499,1000 $350,000
F&M Properties 4412 Valley View Road 19-028-24-43-0077 $365,600 $100,000
F&M Properties James Shear 6133 Kellogg Avenue 19-028-24-43-0078 $490,500 $400,000
Georgios Mertikas & Fotini 7721 Marth Court 08-116-21-34-0096 $563,900 $500,000
Athanasiou
Sharon Garrison 4810 Brookside Avenue 28-117-21-24-0037 $358,000 Not Specified
Cabot Industrial Property, L.P. 7401 Cahill Road 08-116-21-41-0013 $2,052,000 To Be
Alan Heichman/Russell Cech Determined
Milpitas & Flemming Associates To Be
Jake Evans 7320 Ohms Lane 09-11621-23-0013 $2,539,4000 Determined
Shaner SPE Associates Limited 3400 Edinborough Way 32-028-24-34-0025 $6,446,000 $6,000,000
Partnership Larry Barretta
Donald Cieminski 6566 France Avenue S#605 30-028-24-14-0067 $280,500 $100,000
Christopher T. Dahl 5404 Interlachen Blvd 29-117-21-14-0023 $751,000 $735,000
Thomas W Peltola 6604 Dovre Drive 31-117-21-24-0024 $1,157,300 Not Specified
James Vose 4529 Casco Avenue 18-028-24-12-0076 $754,000 Not Specified
Main Street Partnership 4444 W 76th Street 31-028-24-41-0008 $1,708,000 Not Specified
LLPJames V Macie
Bonnie J Scott 6830 Langford Drive 31-117-21-32-0022 1 $190,100 1 Not Specified
Mayor Masica made a motion closing the public hearing at 8:15 p.m. for the 2006 Edina Board of
Review and recessing the Board of Review until May 4, 2006 at 5:00 p.m. in the Edina City Hall
Community Room. Member Swenson seconded the motion.
Ayes: Housh, Hulbert, Masica,Swenson, Hovland
Motion carried.
Respectfully submitted, h
It `
City Clerk