HomeMy WebLinkAbout2011 HRRC MinutesEDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
TUESDAY, JANUARY 25, 2011
7:00 PM – MAYOR'S CONFERENCE ROOM
Members Present Members Absent
Zack Antar John Cashmore
Arnie Bigbee Bob Mayer
Daria Brosius
Lisa Finsness
Jessi Kingston
Meg Newell
Russ Stanton
Staff
Susan Howl
Guest
Janet Seidman
Guest Introduced and Welcomed
Janet Seidman, recently appointed to the Commission, was introduced and welcomed. She will
participate as an official member at the February meeting.
Commission Minutes Approved
It was noted that Member Kingston was incorrectly listed as absent at the December, 2010, meeting.
Member Finsness seconded the motion Member Stanton to approve the Commission minutes as
amended for December 14, 2010. The motion carried.
2011 CDBG Budget for Public Services Approved
Member Kingston seconded the motion of Member Stanton to approve the Public Services portion of
the 2011 CDBG budget as submitted by the Planning Department staff in the amount of $26,067:
H.O.M.E. $17,789, C.A.P.S.H. $5,624, and HomeLine $2,654. The motion carried.
Edina Community Council Report Shared
Member Finsness reported that HRRC was featured at the last Community Council meeting with an
overview of the Commission presented by Chair Bigbee. The goal is for the Commissioners to take this
PowerPoint into the community to educate and share the mission of the Commission. The 2011 budget
of the Edina Resource Center will be forwarded to the Commissioners.
Anti-Bullying/Cyber Bullying Subcommittee Update Presented
Member Newell updated the Commission regarding the work of the Subcommittee in its preparations
for the community event on April 26`n
• Member Finsness has been actively seeking partners.
• It is hoped that showing the movie "Bullied" will help to build awareness within the community.
• The event will be participatory—with art work and reflections from Edinans.
• It will be a festival of celebrating what is good.
• Dick Crockett, Executive Director of the Edina Community Foundation, will be a partner, and he
is working to get others interested and on board.
• Rachael Pream Grenier has signed on as a voice in the High School, as well as Tony of the High
School Theater, who is the artistic director and drama teacher.
• This will be a City-wide event held at the High School Fick Auditorium and will be called
"Reflections on Bullying."
• The Mayor will open the event, and a person who has been bullied will be a part of the program.
• This will be an opportunity to come together and explore a healthy community—looking at
issues in the context of civil rights for everyone.
• Adrian Peterson, Vikings football player, will assist in lining up a celebrity speaker.
• Keith Ellison could wrap up the event with an address for combating bullying.
• Incentives are needed for people to attend the event. Perhaps there could be extra credit for
students.
• "Hold -the -date" flyers will be circulated at the High School's event "Bang Bang You're Dead."
• A press release will be created for viewing on the City's HRRC web page.
2011 Draft Work Plan Approved
Member Newell seconded the motion of Member Stanton to approve the 2011 Work Plan as updated
from the last meeting. The motion carried.
Tom Oye Human Rights Award Discussed
With the recent taping of a cable show of past award recipients, the community will be able to learn
about the Tom Oye Award and propose new candidates. The information will also be distributed
throughout the City via civic organizations, the School District, the Chamber of Commerce, the Sun
Current and the City's website. The award will be given at the City's Annual Volunteer Recognition
Reception at Edinborough Park on April 28tH
Upcoming Events Noted
• "Afternoon of Conversation About Juvenile Justice in MN" — St. Cloud — February 26, 2011
• "Religious Diversity in Our Communities" — Shoreview — February 7, 2011
• "Examining Bullying in the Community" — Chaska — February 5, 2011
• "Know Your Neighbor" — New Hope — February 10, 2011
• "Regional Human Rights Forum" — Roseville — April 7, 2011
• "Beyond Diversity: A Strategy for Deinstitutionalizing Racism and Improving Student
Achievement" — Edina staff development — held in Minnetonka — March 17 and 18
Out Front Minnesota Celebration To be Announced
Member Kingston indicated that there is a reason for celebration in the community regarding the
number of newly -created Domestic Partner registries. The 2012 anti -gay marriage legislation is ahead,
and the focus will be on how to move the middle.
Adiournment
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 8:15 PM.
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 22, 2011
7:00 PM — MAYOR'S CONFERENCE ROOM
Members Present Members Absent
Arnie Bigbee Zack Antar
Daria Brosius Meg Newell
John Cashmore
Lisa Finsness
Jessi Kingston
Bob Mayer
Jan Seidman
Russ Stanton
Steve Winnick
Staff
Susan Howl
Guests
Tom Brower
Tyler Brower
New Members Introduced and Welcomed
Janet Seidman and Steve Winnick, who was just recently appointed to the Commission, were introduced
and welcomed.
Guests Introduced and Welcomed
Tyler Brower is an Edina High School junior. He and his father, Tom, were visiting to fulfill an Eagle Scout
communications project for Tyler.
Commission Minutes Approved
Member Stanton seconded the motion of Member Kingston to approve the Commission minutes for
January 25, 2011. The motion carried.
2011 Commission Officers Elected
The Chair of the Administration Team, Member Mayer, presented the slate of officers for 2011. For a
balanced approach, he recommended that the Chair of the Commission be a rotating position each year.
2011 Slate of Officers
Chair Jessi Kingston
Vice Chair Lisa Finsness
Current Chair Bigbee seconded the motion of Member Stanton to nominate Member Mayer for 2nd
Vice Chair; the motion carried.
Member Cashmore seconded the motion of Member Mayer to approve the 2011 slate of officers:
Chair, Jessi Kingston; 1" Vice Chair, Lisa Finsness; and 2"d Vice Chair, Bob Mayer. The motion carried.
Current Chair Bigbee "passed the torch" to newly -elected Chair Kingston.
2011 Administrative Processes Updated and Approved
The Chair of the Administration Team, Member Mayer, presented the update for the new year. Key
Initiatives were pointed out, showing the need to determine focal topics for each meeting and to have
specific recommendations and planned actions. The Chair and staff will prepare each agenda with key
topics and review the work plan.
Regarding student roles on the Commission, HRRC will follow up with the City Council regarding an
opportunity to change a student's appointment to two years with voting rights in the second year. In
the meantime, the Commission will make an effort to help the appointed students assume leadership
roles while serving; i. e. the Chair and 1" Vice Chair will involve the students in planning items for the
agenda.
Member Finsness seconded Member Cashmore's motion to approve the Administration Team's
Update for 2011 to serve as guidelines for the coming year. The motion carried.
Community Council Report Given
Member Finsness shared that two different organizations were showcased at the last meeting of the
Edina Community Council:
• Oasis for Youth — It is a community-based organization providing homeless and precariously -
housed youth of the south metro area with referrals to crisis intervention services, overnight
shelter and onsite support. Its operations are contained in a church in Bloomington. Oasis often
refers youth to The Bridge. It was reported that there are 550 to 650 homeless youth under the
age of 17 in the Twin Cities without shelter any given night.
• Homes Within Reach — It is a community-based program of the West Hennepin Affordable
Housing Land Trust that provides affordable homeownership in western suburban Hennepin
County by removing the market value of the land from the mortgage equation. This reduces the
cost of a home by almost 40 percent.
The Edina Resource will join in as a supporting partner of the Anti -Bullying event on April 26th
Anti -Bullying Subcommittee Report Given
Member Finsness shared the Ellen Kennedy had agreed to be on the panel at the community -wide event
on Tuesday, April 26th. Amelia Santaniello will not be available to serve as the moderator. At the
upcoming subcommittee meeting, the rest of the speakers will be determined.
Commission Updated on the Tom Oye Human Rights Award
Member Mayer shared the following regarding the Tom Oye Award to be presented at Volunteer
Recognition on April 28th:
• The application is on the website, with a deadline of March 17tH
• The on-line procedure to apply will be tested to assure that it is working.
• The application was distributed widely in a mailing to community organizations and key
contacts.
• On the City's website, one can download the "in Edina" broadcast to watch the interview with
former recipients of the Award.
• The Commission will make its decision at the March meeting regarding an award recipient for
this year.
• It would be helpful to receive the ongoing City/Communications calendar of deadlines.
• It was suggested that discussion regarding next year's award process be moved to October in
the Commission's Work Plan.
Work Session with the City Council Revisited
Member Bigbee reported that the Commission work session with the City Council on February 15th went
well, and the following took place:
• The Commission discussed changing its role in the human services funding process, and the City
Council charged HRRC with presenting a plan to consider for approval.
• The issue of comparable worth surfaced at the Work Session. It was thereafter suggested that
Ceil Smith, Human Resources Director, be invited to attend an upcoming Commission meeting.
• The Commission would like the Council to consider changing students' terms to two years with
voting rights during the second year.
• There is an ongoing responsibility for an HRRC member to serve on the Edina Community
Council. Currently, this position is held by Member Finsness.
Member Bigbee prepared the following funding procedure processes for the Commission to consider
and vote:
• Option 1— HRRC internal subcommittee of up to three members with liaison support
• Option 2 — One HRRC member overseeing group from other boards/commissions with liaison
support
• Option 3 — New working group established by the City Council from particular
boards/commission with liaison support
• Option 4 — Same as Option 3, plus up to three community members selected at large
• Option 5 — no change
• Option 6—staff's responsibility to propose a human services budget
• Option 7 — Combination of Options 1 and 3, including people at large and utilizing a staff liaison
Member Finsness seconded Member Stanton's motion that Option 7 be approved and brought to the
City Manager. The motion carried.
Annual Meeting Reminder Shared
The Commissioners were reminded that the City Council's Annual Dinner Meeting of boards and
commissions would take place on Monday, March 215`, at 5 PM in the Hughes Pavilion at Centennial
Lakes Park.
Adjournment
There being no further business of the Commission, the meeting was adjourned at 9:00 PM.
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
TUESDAY, MARCH 22, 2011
7:00 PM — MAYOR'S CONFERENCE ROOM
MEMBERS PRESENT
MEMBERS ABSENT
Zack Antar
John Cashmore
Arnie Bigbee
Meg Newell
Daria Brosius
Steve Winnick
Lisa Finsness
Jessi Kingston
Bob Mayer
Jan Seidman
Russ Stanton
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Kingston called the meeting to order at 7:00 PM.
MEETING AGENDA APPROVED
STAFF
Susan Howl
GUEST
Ashle Briggs Horton
Motion by Member Bigbee and seconded by Member Seidman approving the meeting agenda.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Seidman and Stanton
Motion carried.
MEETING MINUTES APPROVED
Motion by Member Mayer and seconded by Member Bigbee approving the meeting minutes of
February 22, 2011.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Seidman and Stanton
Motion carried.
GUEST INTRODUCED
Ashle Briggs Horton from the Edina Patch was introduced and welcomed. She was gathering
information on three events: Reflections on Bullying on April 26th, Tom Oye Human Rights Award on
April 28th, and the proposed Day of Remembrance on May 1:t
NEWLY -CREATED FUNDING PROCEDURE EXPLAINED
Having met with the City Manager, Chair Kingston shared his recommendations for a newly -created
funding procedure:
• The City Council will establish a new working group entitled the Human Services Task Force.
• This will begin with the following City Commissions appointing one of their members to serve on
the Task Force: Community Health Committee, HRRC, Planning Commission, Energy &
Environment Commission, Transportation Commission and Park Board.
• The City Manager will provide staff support to the Human Services Task Force.
• The Task Force will produce a recommendation for CDBG funding and human services funding.
• These two recommendations will be approved by the City Manager before final approval by the
City Council.
• To accomplish this work, four meetings would be scheduled for the Task Force:
- Evaluation of the RFP to be sent to providers currently funded and submitting an ad for the
Sun -Current to solicit new requests
- Hearing for the providers
- Development of a draft human services budget
- Presentation of the budget to the City Manager for evaluation
Member Stanton indicated his interest in participating on the Task Force.
"BIAS/HATE CRIME RESPONSE PLAN" REVIEWED
It was noted that the City's legal counsel had reviewed and revised the Bias/Hate Crime Response Plan
last March. After the Commission's re -scrutiny of the Plan, Chair Kingston agreed to meet with the
Police Chief for a refresher of the procedure and a view of the revisions.
"DAYS OF REMEMBRANCE" PROCLAMATION AND EVENT PLANS DEVELOPED
Due to a citizen bringing to the Mayor's attention, the designation of the Days of Remembrance from
May 1St through May 8th by the United States Holocaust Memorial Council, encouragement came to
Member Cashmore from the Mayor for HRRC to plan an event around this time. A proclamation was
prepared by the Commission for the City Council's approval, which designates May 1St through May 8th
as the Days of Remembrance of the Victims of the Holocaust. The proclamation also designates Sunday,
May ft, as the Day of Remembrance, at which time HRRC would host an open house and program at
Edina City Hall.
Motion by Member Bigbee and seconded by Member Finsness to forward the proclamation to the City
Council for approval of the designation of the Days of Remembrance from May 1St through May Stn
and for an HRRC event on May 1st designating the Day of Remembrance.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Seidman and Stanton
Motion carried.
If the resolution is approved by the City Council, Chair Kingston and Member Seidman would assist
Member Cashmore with the planning and preparation of the event on May 1St
"TOM OYE HUMAN RIGHTS AWARD" RECIPIENT SELECTED
After having reviewed the six nominations sent out to the Commissioners by Member Mayer, he asked
for each Commissioner's ranking in order to determine the 2011 recipient of the Tom Oye Human Rights
Award. Each nominee was required to have a strong interest in human rights and live or work in Edina.
After Member Mayer made the determination upon compilation of the rankings, he announced that the
2011 recipient of the Tom Oye Award would be Rev. Dan Johnson. Dan has been a tireless advocate for
human rights as he led his church toward becoming a "reconciling" church that openly welcomes and
affirms the GLBT population. The presentation will be made at the Volunteer Awards Reception at
Edinborough on April 28th. Candidates not selected in 2011 will automatically be considered again in
2012, along with new nominations.
RECOMMENDATIONS FOR MEETINGS DISCUSSED
The Commissioners agreed that there should be more time on the meeting agendas for additional items.
This topic will be discussed in May.
DETAILS SHARED REGARDING "REFLECTIONS ON BULLYING"
Member Finsness reported the following:
• More groundwork was laid at the last meeting with Heather Haen Anderson and Members
Finsness, Newell, and Brosius.
• The official confirmation form for Ellen Kennedy to be on the panel will be developed and sent
to her as soon as possible.
• There will be four people on the panel.
• The emcee will be Liz Collins from WCCO, and WCCO will cover the event.
• Dick Crockett of the Edina Community Foundation will cover the cost of the food.
• There will be a PSA on the Edina website.
• The EdinaSecrets boxes will be in a number of locations for people to submit anonymous
postcards. Member Seidman offered to help put the boxes together.
• John offered to help with publicity.
• HRRC Members are encouraged to invite their contacts to attend and to provide this
information for Heather Haen Anderson.
• Member Antar will contact Jerry's about publicity in their turnaround, and he will also talk to the
hockey coach regarding securing a Wild player as a celebrity.
• Reflections on Bullying will count as the April Commission Meeting.
• After the event, PSA's with the Police Chief could be created in order to educate the public. It
would be helpful to advertise pertinent websites regarding bullying.
"BEYOND DIVERSITY" WORKSHOP INFORMATION SHARED
Member Finsness reported that she had recently attended the two-day "Beyond Diversity' workshop for
School District personnel through WMEP. One of the themes was about raising the awareness of White
privilege. 200 people were in attendance. The workshop was a step in the right direction in the
continuum of learning. The Commission needs to be alert as to finding out what the next step will be.
CITY OF EDINA TO HOST APRIL MEETING OF THE STATE LEAGUE OF HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSIONS
Member Bigbee reminded the Commissioners that they are invited to attend the State League of Human
Rights Commissions' April meeting in the Community Room of Edina City Hall on Saturday, April 30tH
from noon to 3 PM. RSVP's are necessary, as a meal will be served. Member Bigbee is now a Board
Member of the State League.
MEETING ADJOURNED
There being no further business on the Commission agenda, Chair Kingston declared the meeting
adjourned at 8:35 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Jessi Kingston, Chair
Edina Human Rights & Relations Commission
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
"REFLECTIONS ON BULLYING" — CITY-WIDE DIALOGUE & EXHIBIT
TUESDAY, APRIL 26, 2011
6:00 PM — FICK AUDITORIUM
MEMBERS PRESENT STAFF
Zack Antar Susan Howl
Arnie Bigbee
Daria Brosius
John Cashmore
Lisa Finsness
Bob Mayer
Meg Newell
Jan Seidman
Russ Stanton
Steve Winnick
"Reflections on Bullying" Event —Tuesday, April 26, 2011— Fick Auditorium
How does a community begin to address bullying? Bullying, it happens so often, in so many
places. It causes so much pain and is all too often is ignored. To address this insidious problem,
the Human Rights and Relationship Commission (HRRC) chose bullying as their focus for 2011.
To begin the discussion and to build awareness within the Edina community, the HRRC received
support from the Edina Community Foundation to host an Edina Dialogue, "Reflections on
Bullying: Creating a World Were Bullying Does Not Happen". The HRRC also collaborated with
the Gay Straight Alliance and the 212 leadership team, both from Edina High School, the Edina
Resource Center, Connecting with Kids and the Edina Chamber of Commerce.
On April 26, 2011, more than 150 people gathered at FICK auditorium in Edina High School for a
light dinner to begin an Edina dialogue on Bullying. Citizens submitted anonymous postcards —
"Edina Secrets" and essays sharing their thoughts and experience ... their reflections about
bullying. The school library displayed books, the non-profit; "A World Without Genocide"
shared program information. The main event opened with remarks from HRRC chair, Jessi
Kingston and Mayor Jim Hovland and was moderated by Liz Collin from WCCO featured a movie
produced by the Southern Poverty Law Center, `Bullied" — a true story about Jamie Nabozny- a
teenager in Wisconsin whose bullying was ignored by school officials. Jaime took his case to
court and won a judgment against several school administrators. Julie Herzog from PACER
addressed the audience at the conclusion of the movie and EHS student, Abdisa Dawano shared
a reading. The evening concluded with a guest panel: Dr. Ellen Kennedy, Rachael Pream Grenier,
Rick Sansted, Koal Williams, and Chelese Ewart ...and powerful audience dialogue.
Respectfully submitted,
Lisa Finsness, Co -Chair
"Reflections on Bullying"
MINUTES
OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
MAY 24, 2011
7:03 PM
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Kingston called the meeting to order at 7:03 PM.
II. ROLLCALL
Answering rollcall were Members Brosius, Cashmore, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Newell, Seidman and
Winnick.
Ill. MEETING AGENDA APPROVED
Motion by Member Cashmore and seconded by Member Winnick approving the meeting agenda.
Ayes: Cashmore, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Winnick
Motion carried.
IV. CONSENT AGENDA ADOPTED
Motion by Member Seidman and seconded by Member Cashmore approving the consent agenda as
follows:
W.A. Approve regular meeting minutes of March 22, 2011 with one edit, and notes from the Anti -
Bullying Forum on April 26, 2011.
Ayes: Cashmore, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Winnick
Motion carried.
V. COMMUNITY COMMENT
There were no community comments.
VI. REPORTS/RECOMMENDATIONS
VI.A. CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION WITH COMMISSION CHAIRS
Chair Kingston shared draft minutes from the City Council Work Session with commission chairs which
was held on May 3, 2011. Items discussed by the City Council were: 1) Filming and Rebroadcasting
Meetings, suggesting that one meeting of each commission, titled the "Annual Meeting", would be
filmed annually in the Council Chambers; 2) Standardization of Agendas, Bylaws, Minutes and Meeting
Protocol; 3) Working Group, Subcommittee and Task Force Protocol, noting that such bodies must
comply with the Open Meeting Law; 4) Commissioner Orientation and Training, including the possibility
of providing opportunities for specialized training; 5) Synchronization of Work Plans and City Council
Priorities, possibly accomplished at each commission's Annual Meeting; and 6) Website Presence, with
HRRC indicating an interest in adding more information to its website.
VI.B. "NAZI PERSECUTION OF HOMOSEXUALS" TRAVELING EXHIBIT
Chair Kingston shared an outline for sponsorship of/involvement of the "Nazi Persecution of
Homosexuals" Traveling Exhibit. It had been submitted by Laura Zelle, JCRC Director of Tolerance
Minnesota & Holocaust Education. The JCRC will be coordinating a Midwest tour of the exhibit, and it
will be previewing at the University of Minnesota in the Andersen Library from April 1St through May
15th, 2012.
The following issues/comments were raised: 1) Is this serving the community of Edina? 2) There is the
need to develop criteria for this kind of decision-making. 3) HRRC would be supporting an educational
effort in the amount of $500. 4) The number one criteria for approving such opportunities is that it
should make an impact on Edina. 5) Could HRRC be misunderstood as a funding vehicle? 6) Is there a
way to tie the event into the anti -bullying initiative? 7) Is more information necessary in the nature of a
formal request or a recommendation from the Mayor? 8) The event would be a catalyst for continuing
dialogues. 9) Participate and use this event as anecdotal evidence for developing standards for
evaluating RFP's. 10) The event could be noteworthy for Edina and HRRC. 11) There were 2000 people
at the exhibit in Seattle, and it has also traveled to Norfolk, VA. 12) We should "hop on the train" and
solidify Edina standing up for human rights. 13) Because the 2012 Exhibit in Minneapolis will occur
during the time of Edina's "Days of Remembrance" event, HRRC could dovetail with the Exhibit's event
and focus on its mission. 14) An Edina dialogue could be scheduled on one of the nights during the
Exhibit, which would be a way to reach out and demonstrate HRRC's purpose and commitment. 15) This
should not be about HRRC becoming well-known and getting recognition by attaching its name to the
Exhibit.
Member Newell made a motion, seconded by Member Finsness, to create a work group to report back
to the Commission with ideas focusing on involving the youth in a dialogue in order for HRRC to be a
participator of the Exhibit and not just a sponsor.
Ayes: Finsness, Newell
Nays: Cashmore, Kingston, Mayer, Seidman, Winnick
Motion denied.
Member Mayer made a motion, seconded by Member Cashmore, to support the Exhibit in the
amount of $500, for an activity to be determined through collaboration with JCRC.
Ayes: Cashmore, Kingston, Seidman, Winnick
Nays: Finsness, Mayer, Newell
Motion carried.
VI.C. TIME OFF
Chair Kingston recommended that the Commission take a month off. The following comments were
made: 1) Summer is not opportune for time off from a meeting, as work needs to be done regarding the
next Dialogue. 2) Because Commissioners all have different schedules, it may be better to have a
flexible vacation schedule that meets personal needs. 3) The City Council does not appear to take a
meeting off; therefore, the Members must have a way to miss a meeting for a vacation. 4) The new
student members do not begin until September. Perhaps June or August could be skipped. 5) Having
time off would be an opportunity for Commissioners to "re -charge." 6) June would be an ideal month
for discussing a number of things—no action items. The June agenda should include a dialogue about
what the criteria should be regarding sponsoring events.
Chair Kingston made a motion, seconded by Member Cashmore, for HRRC to take off the month of
June this year.
Ayes: Cashmore, Kingston
Nays: Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Winnick
Motion denied.
VI.D. CITY WEBSITE—COUNTRY CLUB DISTRICT
Member Winnick reported that he has had the opportunity to peruse the City's website and history
books, focusing on the Country Club district. In doing so, he suggests that the City evaluate the website
for complete disclosure of the early covenants and private deed restrictions. He indicated that the City
should reveal its history and that the website could be improved to positively impact the future. Staff
shared the recommendation that a hyperlink to the summary of the early restrictions and covenants be
added to the Heritage Landmarks' page on the City's website.
Comments and observations were as follows: 1) Information on the website should be explicit and not
just direct the reader to another site. 2) Improving the website with additional information would be an
opportunity to educate the citizens of Edina. 3) If an expanded paragraph is developed on the website,
there could be a link to HRRC. 4) The About Town has been and could also continue to be a good source
for this information. 5) The Edina Historical Society maintains historical records regarding Edina.
Member Winnick will share an update with the Commissioners at the June meeting.
VI. E. EVENTS DEBRIEF
Due to time constraints, Chair Kingston recommended tabling the debriefing of two events—
"Reflections on Bullying" and "Days of Remembrance." The June meeting will be ideal for doing this—
posting notes with ideas, documenting resources and identifying contacts.
Vll. CORRESPONDENCE AND PETITIONS
An Edina resident, Sanford Berman, contacted Chair Kingston after the "Days of Remembrance" event
had been highlighted in the Sun -Current. Since that time, he has sent the Commission copies of letters
to the Minnesota Twins and the State of Minnesota's elected officials, referencing his concern about a
team's logo being racist and elected officials' "faith -based prejudice" regarding same-sex marriage.
The Commissioners raised various questions:
1) Mr. Berman has been an active member of the community for a long time. His reputation is
reputable among fellow librarians. 2) Does his correspondence require a response from HRRC?
3) Should HRRC acknowledge and thank him for his interest in Domestic Partnerships? 4) Should there
be any response to him, or is this considered "for information only"?
Because Mr. Berman's communication to HRRC was by "bc" (blind copy), no action was deemed
necessary.
Vlll. CHAIR AND COMMISSION MEMBER COMMENTS
Member Cashmore reported that he is now a graduate of the Police Department's Citizen's Academy, a
ten -week program led by Officer Brian Hubbard. The next class will be held in the spring of 2012. He
highly recommended the class to his fellow Commissioners.
Member Mayer reported that there has been positive publicity of the Tom Oye Award in a number of
media outlets.
IX. STAFF COMMENTS
Staff Liaison, Susan Howl, shared that the Commission is operating in full throttle with passionate and
professional people on board. All discussion within the Commission has resulted in healthy consensus
and positive outcomes.
X. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business on the Commission Agenda, Chair Kingston declared the meeting
adjourned at 9:00 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Minutes approved by HRRC, June 28, 2011.
Susan Howl, HRRC Staff Liaison
Jessi Kingston, HRRC Chair
MINUTES
OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
JUNE 28, 2011
7:03 PM
I. CALL TO ORDER
1" Vice Chair Finsness called the meeting to order at 7:03 PM.
IL ROLLCALL
Answering rollcall were Commissioners Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton
and Winnick.
W. MEETING AGENDA EDITED AND APPROVED
Commissioner Finsness requested an additional agenda item be placed under Reports &
Recommendations, becoming VI. G. Service Dogs in Condominium Associations.
Motion by Commissioner Winnick and seconded by Commissioner Stanton approving the meeting
agenda as edited.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
IV. CONSENT AGENDA ADOPTED
Motion by Commissioner Bigbee and seconded by Commissioner Seidman approving the consent
agenda as follows:
W.A. Approve regular meeting minutes of May 24, 2011.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
V. COMMUNITY COMMENT
Two visitors introduced themselves: Sue Plaster, a member of the community who is interested in
diversity and intercultural communications; and Bevlin Jennings, a student at Edina High School who is
interested in serving on HRRC.
Vl. REPORTS/RECOMMENDATIONS
VLA. MAYOR'S MEMBERSHIP ON THE COALITION REGARDING IMMIGRATION REFORM ENDORSED
The "Partnership for a New American Economy" is a coalition of mayors and business leaders who
choose to make the case that immigration reform is an economic imperative. Mayor Hovland had asked
the Commission to look into this coalition and conclude whether or not he should become a member.
There is neither financial nor time commitment for Mayor Hovland to join, and the Commissioners
opened up discussion on the matter.
Commissioners Seidman and Stanton stated that the information from New York City's Mayor was too
vague and did not provide enough detail. In addition, Commissioner Stanton pointed out that there is a
9.1% unemployment rate now and that we should be vested in "growing" our own people first. He
indicated that he is not comfortable about endorsing this coalition.
Commissioner Bigbee explained that the United States does need a different immigration policy and
that this coalition seems like a movement in the right direction. The coalition is trying to get public
conversation going. It will be a good thing to get first-hand information from the Mayor. There is
evidence that a number of immigrants work within the community.
A concern was raised that this coalition was about economics and lower pay rates for immigrants.
Commissioner Newell stated that this is not necessarily true, as the form entitled "Immigrant Petition
for Alien Workers" protects both the immigrant and the employer in the immigrant worker's process of
becoming a permanent resident in the United States. The form is filed by the employer on behalf of a
foreign worker.
Commissioner Finsness reported that this coalition is a group created to investigate and explore the
need for immigration reform by looking at the laws and raising public awareness. As a member, the
Mayor could monitor the progress and keep the Commission updated. This would be a great
opportunity for HRRC to learn about immigration.
Commissioner Bigbee made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Mayer, to recommend that Mayor
Hovland join the "Mayor's Coalition Regarding Immigration Reform" and that he provides the
Commission timely updates in his involvement.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Mayer, Newell
Nays: Cashmore, Seidman, Winnick
Abstain: Stanton
Motion carried.
VI.B. LMHRC GLBT RESOLUTION ENDORSED
An amendment to the Minnesota Constitution was proposed that would ban the legal recognition of
same-sex relationships within the State of Minnesota. As a result, the League of Minnesota Human
Rights Commissions (LMHRC) drafted a resolution to share with the press and its own membership
declaring opposition to the amendment. The Commissioners reviewed this resolution and opened up
discussion.
Commissioner Bigbee shared that the resolution had been created by the League two years ago and was
recently revised. He suggested that the Commission recommend the City Council's statement of
opposition to the constitutional amendment.
Commissioners Mayer and Stanton questioned HRRC's role and whether it could endorse something
from the League. Commissioner Stanton supported the resolution but suggested that it could be edited
for the sake of new resolutions from HRRC and the City Council.
Commissioner Finsness explained that the resolution covers HRRC because of its membership under the
League's umbrella. She indicated that the City Council could have its own resolution as well.
Commissioner Mayer made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Newell, to table the endorsement
of the League's resolution.
The motion failed with only one aye.
Commissioners Bigbee and Winnick remarked that the Commission could stand by and watch the events
or take action. Commissioner Winnick encouraged the Commissioners to make a public statement by
endorsing the League's resolution and encouraging the City Council to do the same thing.
Commissioner Stanton made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Cashmore, to endorse the
League's resolution to oppose changing the Minnesota constitution in order to ban the legal
recognition of same-sex relationships and unions, and at its July meeting the Commission will
investigate a recommendation that the City Council could also support the opposition.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick
Motion carried.
VI.C. APPOINTMENT OF COMMISSIONER TO POST UPDATES ON TWITTER TABLED
Because the Minnesota Department of Human Rights has been using Twitter to provide information to
the public, HRRC could send e-mail updates and summaries to them to be included with their human
rights related news on Twitter. If HRRC information was to be posted with the State's news, it could also
be forwarded to the City of Edina's Twitter site.
Commissioner Cashmore made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Winnick, to table the
appointment and to invite the Communication's Director, Jennifer Bennerotte, to a Commission
meeting to discuss communication tools.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick
Motion carried.
VI.D. RESOLUTION APPROVED REGARDING STAFF CHANGES TO THE CITY'S WEBSITE HISTORY
Commissioner Winnick had several meetings with Joyce Repya, Associate Planner, and Jennifer
Bennerotte, Communications Director, to draft a revision to the history of the Edina Country Club
District which would include the facts about realtors turning away potential buyers interested in the
Country Club District who were Jewish or members of certain other minorities. This revision would be
within the Heritage Landmarks section of the City's website and would also reveal the history regarding
the early covenants and private deed restrictions prohibiting non -Caucasians from ownership. Due to
the diligence of Ms. Repya, the changes were quickly made, providing accurate information of historical
value.
Commissioner Bigbee made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Cashmore, to present a resolution of
appreciation to Joyce Repya for her effort and generosity in working to update the City's website with
significant historical information.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick
Motion carried.
VI. E. CREATION OF A TASK FORCE APPROVED TO DEVELOP A PROCESS FOR THE SUBMISSION OF
SPONSORSHIP REQUESTS AND CRITERIA/GUIDELINES FOR EVALUATION
In the event that an organization comes before HRRC requesting financial support and time/services for
an educational endeavor, a process and criteria/guidelines need to be developed and in place.
Commissioner Cashmore made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Newell, to create a Commission
task force to develop a process for submission and criteria/guidelines for evaluating sponsorship
requests.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick
Motion carried.
The following Commissioners agreed to serve on the task force and submit a report to the Commission
in October: Bigbee, Finsness, Seidman. Commissioner Bigbee agreed to chair the task force.
VI.F. EVENTS DEBRIEF TABLED UNTIL THE NEXT COMMISSION MEETING
With the Commission Chair being unable to attend the meeting, it had been suggested that feedback be
sent to the staff liaison by July 18th regarding the two events—"Reflections on Bullying' and "Days of
Remembrance." The liaison would then turn these suggestions into a document for discussion at the
July Commission meeting, with all comments being confidential.
Commissioner Seidman submitted a form entitled "Event Review & Future Planning" to consider as a
tool for evaluation.
Commissioner Mayer was concerned that the timing is not good and that it is a little too late for
accurate evaluations. A constructive process would have been to ask four questions about each event
and have these as topics of discussion. He recommended that, at the very least, the chair of each event
should produce a summary. And for the future, participants could be surveyed at the events.
Commissioner Bigbee remarked that the Commission needs to get this work done as soon as possible by
figuring out how to gather quick information.
Commissioner Finsness recommended that a professional survey be created for the Commission to
analyze the information. She shared that Commissioner Seidman's form would be useful right after an
event for people who worked directly on the event and would be excellent for future planning.
Regarding a survey, Commissioner Finsness suggested that an on-line survey be created for each event
for the Commissioners to complete by July 20th for discussion at the July Commission meeting. In
addition, the survey could be sent to the task force members who are not Commissioners—Dick
Crockett, Heather Haen Anderson, Rachel Pream Grenier and the GSA student leaders. It might also be
helpful to have a survey for people who attended the events.
Commissioner Cashmore made a motion, seconded by Commissioner Mayer, to table the discussion
about events' debriefing until the next meeting.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick
Motion carried.
Commissioner Mayer offered to send out guidelines—"Personal Post Mortems"—to help prepare for
debriefing at the next Commission meeting.
VI.G. SERVICE DOGS IN CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATIONS DISCUSSED
Commissioner Finsness reported that she had learned about a condominium putting restrictions on a
resident using a service dog because there was no documentation of need. At this time, Commissioner
Finsness had received no updated information, and she felt that the bylaws of the condominium
association should be reviewed.
Vll. CORRESPONDENCE AND PETITIONS
No correspondence or petitions were received since the last Commission meeting.
Vlll. CHAIR AND COMMISSION MEMBER COMMENTS
There were no comments.
IX. STAFF COMMENTS
There were no comments.
X. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business on the Commission Agenda, 1" Vice Chair Finsness declared the
meeting adjourned at 9:15 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Minutes approved by HRRC, July 26, 2011.
Susan Howl, HRRC Staff Liaison
Lisa Finsness, HRRC 1St Vice Chair
MINUTES
OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
JULY 26, 2011
7:03 PM
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Kingston called the meeting to order at 7:03 PM.
IL ROLLCALL
Answering rollcall were Commissioners Bigbee, Cashmore, Kingston, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton
and Winnick. Guests present were Sue Plaster and Jennifer Bennerotte.
Ill. MEETING AGENDA APPROVED
Motion by Commissioner Bigbee and seconded by Commissioner Cashmore approving the meeting
agenda.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
IV. CONSENT AGENDA ADOPTED
Motion by Commissioner Cashmore and seconded by Commissioner Winnick approving the consent
agenda as follows:
W.A. Approve regular meeting minutes of June 28, 2011.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
V. PRESENTATION BYJENNIFER BENNEROTTE, DIRECTOR OF COMMUNICATIONS AND MARKETING
Ms. Bennerotte was introduced and welcomed to the Commission meeting. She had been invited to
share the following City's communication tools.
Upcoming deadlines for submitting articles to About Town, the City's quarterly publication distributed to
Edina households are: Winter Issue, 10/21/11; Spring Issue, 1/20/12; Summer Issue, 4/20/12; Fall Issue,
7/20/12; Winter Issue, 10/19/12.
Video options for communication are:
1) Cable channel 16 for government access, running with weekly segments
2) "Agenda: Edina," the news program viewed four times weekly – Deadlines for upcoming submissions
are the third Fridays of each month: August 19th, September 16th, October 21St, November 18th, and
December 16tH
3) "In Edina" is a half-hour video magazine airing five times weekly in a talk -show format. Each show's
theme is in five segments and runs for a month. Its upcoming deadlines are August 10th, September
14th, October 12th, November 9th, and December 14tH
4) Two public service announcements (PSA's) per month
City Extra is an e-mail notification service available through the City's website. It was noted that 21% of
Edina's residents do not have internet access.
The City of Edina now uses Facebook, Twitter, YouTube and Four Square (solely for the enterprise
funds). All messages must go through the Communications Department for social media posting.
The City's primary online communications tool is its website—www.cityofedina.com. HRRC can be
mindful of its own page and make it a community resource.
Ms. Bennerotte reminded the Commission that October is the deadline for submitting information
about the 2012 Tom Oye Human Rights Award. She shared that a new City website would be in place by
December 31St. Scott Neal, the City Manager, has an online blog site which is the most visited page on
the City website. Ms. Bennerotte reminded the Commissioners that he welcomes new ideas as topics
for his blog. She announced that there is now an additional blog site titled edinacitizenengagement.org.
With a free e-mail subscription to this site, one can keep up on issues such as the Southdale
redevelopment plan, the City's 2012 budget, and the Grandview small area plan.
Ms. Bennerotte concluded by reminding the Commission that the Communications Department can
submit press releases on behalf of the group to the Sun Current, the Minneapolis Star Tribune, KSTP TV
and news, Edina Patch, Edina Magazine, Edina Chamber of Commerce, the SW Journal, neighborhood
associations and the School District.
VI. COMMUNITY COMMENT
Sue Plaster was welcomed back as a visitor to Commission meetings.
Vll. REPORTS/RECOMMENDATIONS
VILA. HUMAN SERVICES TASK FORCE DISCUSSED
Because HRRC will no longer be involved in the human services budgeting process, Chair Kingston
reported that the City Manager is in the process of forming a Human Services Task Force to review
proposals and submit a 2012 budget to the City Council for approval. Members of the Task Force will
consist of one representative from each of the advisory boards and commissions. Chair Kingston shared
that $5000 will be submitted for approval to the City Council for the Commission's 2012 operating
budget.
Member Stanton indicated that the Commission should pursue means for providing a demographics
report, utilizing the latest census data. The research, planning and coordination (RPC) function of HRRC
was last utilized in 2006 with money budgeted for developing an affordable housing report. For RPC
money to be available in the future, the Commission must be deliberative in determining what is needed
and valuable for the community, and then go before the Council in a timely fashion with a justified
proposal. A 1998 demographics update from the large report prepared in 1993 will be e-mailed to the
Commissioners for their information.
VII. B. DEBRIEFING OF EVENTS
Chair Kingston invited the Commissioners to go around the table and comment about the two events
held in 2011—"Reflections on Bullying" and "Days of Remembrance."
"Reflections on Bullying"
- It was a remarkable event; however, there was a lack of clarity about the co-sponsors. The sponsors
needed to be present at the table.
- The lines of communication were somewhat unclear. There was a lack of information provided to the
schools.
- How do we get permission from the schools? Letters of introductions and approval are necessary.
- The schools have asked that there be no more soliciting of the students—i.e. EdinaSecrets postcards.
- The schools need to get involved earlier in order to figure out ways for student participation.
- The event impacted a number of people in a genuine way.
- Thank-you's were written to all the participants in the event.
- The event had a successful turnout with a good mix of people.
- The event's goal was to engage the School District in a partnership.
- The issues surrounding the event are not easy and sometimes controversial.
"Days of Remembrance"
- There could have been some sort of memento from the City for the participants.
- A sign -in with addresses would be helpful.
- It was another remarkable event; however, few young people attended.
- Having a survivor there was wonderful.
Both Events
- A chair plus one should be accountable for each event and provide a report.
- Planning schedules should be published.
- Deadlines should be set and made clear.
- Address and e-mails of all involved need to be gathered and stored.
- Be continuously looking for opportunities to educate the community; i.e. "become upstanders and not
just bystanders"; "awareness not only educates but saves lives."
- Partnership clarity is critical.
- Make sure the meeting tones and expectations are set early.
- Communicate and debrief after each meeting.
A task force consisting of Members Cashmore, Mayer and Seidman will finalize and present a check list
for organizing future events at the October Commission meeting.
VII. C. LEAGUE'S GLBT RESOLUTION RECOMMENDED FOR THE COUNCIL'S SUPPORT
At the July 26, 2011, Commission meeting, HRRC endorsed the League of Minnesota Human Rights
Commissions' resolution to oppose changing the Minnesota constitution in order to ban the legal
recognition of same-sex relationships and unions, and the Commission agreed to investigate a
recommendation that the City Council could also support the opposition.
Motion by. Commissioner Bigbee and seconded by Member Cashmore to recommend that the
League's resolution be supported by the Edina City Council.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
Member Stanton agreed to talk to the City Attorney regarding the Constitution and future Commission
activities.
Vlll. CORRESPONDENCE AND PETITIONS
No correspondence or petitions were received.
IX. CHAIR AND COMMISSION MEMBER COMMENTS
Member Bigbee reported that the Board of the League of Minnesota Human Rights Commissions would
be meeting in Edina for its August meeting—Saturday, August 27th, Southdale Library, noon to 3 PM. He
encouraged the Commissioners to consider ways to serve on this Commission.
X. STAFF COMMENTS
There were no comments.
Xl. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business on the Commission Agenda, Chair Kingston declared the meeting
adjourned at 9:05 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Minutes approved by HRRC, August 23, 2011.
Susan Howl, HRRC Staff Liaison
Jessi Kingston, HRRC Chair
MINUTES
OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
AUGUST 23, 2011
7:03 PM
I. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Kingston called the meeting to order at 7:03 PM.
11. ROLLCALL
Answering rollcall were Commissioners Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Stanton and Winnick. Guests
present were Sue Plaster and Dan Heilman.
Ill. MEETING AGENDA APPROVED
Motion by Commissioner Stanton and seconded by Commissioner Winnick approving the meeting agenda
with the following additions: VI. D. Fred Baron Appreciation and VI. E. Edina Community Council
Representative.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
IV. CONSENT AGENDA ADOPTED
Motion by Commissioner Cashmore and seconded by Commissioner Winnick approving the consent
agenda as follows:
W.A. Approve regular meeting minutes of July 26, 2011, correcting Chair Kingston as "present" in the
rolicall.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
V. COMMUNITY COMMENT
Two visitors were welcomed: Sue Plaster, a member of the community who is interested in diversity and
intercultural communications; and Dan Heilman, a reporter from Edina Patch.
Vl. REPORTS/RECOMMENDATIONS
VI.A. 2012 WORK PLAN REVIEWED
Commissioner Mayer reported that the Administration Committee has the responsibility of presenting a
preliminary work plan for the upcoming year.
- It was agreed that a census update of demographic information would be helpful and that it should be
added to the Commission's Initiatives.
- At the October meeting, the Commission will focus on the initiatives and discuss evident/emerging issues in
the community.
- A mid -year review of the initiatives in May was recommended.
- Daryl Coppoletti of the Hennepin South Services Collaborative will be invited to a Commission meeting to
discuss the research and planning of human services and how the Commission could get started considering a
demographics project.
- It was recommended that the Commissioners always bring the current Work Plan to each meeting as a
resource in looking ahead to next year's Work Plan.
Motion by Commissioner Mayer and seconded by Commissioner Finsness to approve the 2012 Work Plan
with the aforementioned additions.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
VI.B. VIDEO-TAPED HRRC MEETING DISCUSSED
The Commissioners agreed that Tuesday, November 22"d, would be the video-taped meeting to be held in
the Council Chambers of City Hall. It will be an opportunity to share with the community what is working and
what the Commission does. Items for the agenda include: the bullying initiative, the Holocaust Day of
Remembrance, the Bias/Hate Crime Response Plan, the Tom Oye Human Rights Award, Domestic
Partnerships and the human services function. The Commissioners were encouraged to visit the City's
website and observe other taped commission meetings. This will be discussed further at the September
meeting.
VI.C. AUGUST 27' LMHRC MEETING DETAILS SHARED
Commissioner Bigbee shared the reminder that the Board of the League of Human Rights Commissions will
be holding its next meeting at the Southdale Library on August 27'h from noon to 3 PM. He reported that a
number of committees were now being formed and encouraged the Commissioners to attend the meeting
and consider getting on board. He indicated that he is currently the Chair of the League's Public Policy
Committee.
VI. D. RECOGNITION FOR FRED BARON APPROVED
The Commissioners discussed ways to recognize Fred Baron, a Holocaust survivor, who shared his story at the
Days of Remembrance event last May.
Motion by Commissioner Bigbee and seconded by Commissioner Stanton to send Mr. Baron the two Edina
history books along with a note of appreciation signed by Chair Kingston and Mayor Hovland.
Ayes: Bigbee, Kingston, Mayer, Stanton and Winnick
Abstain: Finsness
Motion carried.
VI.E. NEW REPRESENTATIVE TO THE EDINA COMMUNITY COUNCIL CONTINUED TO NEXT MEETING
Commissioner Finsness reported that the Edina Community Council meets on the third Tuesday of each
month at 7:30 AM at the Community Center. She asked that a Commissioner replace her as the HRRC
representative. It was noted that Val Burke, who had been the Director of the Edina Resource Center, was
now the School District's Director of Community Education Services. Commissioner Finsness' replacement
will be determined at the September meeting.
VII. CORRESPONDENCE AND PETITIONS
No correspondence or petitions were received.
Vill. CHAIR AND COMMISSION MEMBER COMMENTS
Commissioner Winnick shared his concern regarding comments made at the Reflections on Bullying event
last April regarding an incident within the Youth Hockey Association. The Commission questioned the policies
and procedures for bullying in all the athletic associations. Commissioners Winnick and Finsness will meet
with the City's Park and Recreation Director, John Keprios, to discuss the incident.
IX. STAFF COMMENTS
There were no comments.
XI. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business on the Commission Agenda, Chair Kingston declared the meeting adjourned
at 9:30 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Minutes approved by HRRC, September 27, 2011.
Susan Howl, HRRC Staff Liaison
Jessi Kingston, HRRC Chair
MINUTES
OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
SEPTEMBER 27, 2011
7:03 PM
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Kingston called the meeting to order at 7:03 PM.
ll. ROLLCALL
Answering rollcall were Commissioners Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick and
Chair Kingston, and Student Members Aderhold and Nolan. Guests present were City Manager Scott Neil,
Human Resources Director Lisa Schaefer, and Sue Plaster. Staff present: Susan Howl, Human Services
Coordinator.
III. WELCOME AND INTRODUCTIONS
The Commissioners welcomed the City Manager, Scott Neal, and the Human Resources Director, Lisa
Schaefer, and introductions were made all around. Manager Neal expressed appreciation for the dedication
and hard work of the Commission. He reported that Director Schaefer will be the new City Liaison to the
Commission and that in the near future Ms. Howl would be replaced by new staff support. The new Student
Members, Gabe Aderhold and Mackenzie Nolan, also introduced themselves and were welcomed to the
Commission.
IV. MEETING AGENDA APPROVED
Motion by Commissioner Bigbee and seconded by Commissioner Cashmore approving the meeting agenda
of September 27, 2011.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick and Chair Kingston
Motion carried.
V. CONSENT AGENDA ADOPTED
Motion by Commissioner Cashmore and seconded by Commissioner Winnick approving the consent
agenda as follows:
V.A. Approve regular meeting minutes of August 23, 2011, correcting the last sentence in Item VIII:
"Commissioners Winnick and Finsness will meet with the City's Park and Recreation Director, John Keprios,
to discuss the incident."
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick and Chair Kingston
Motion carried.
Pll�r%]�LIuL�I�`Li�'IrI�Iu'LTL�i`i�
Sue Plaster, a member of the community, was welcomed as a visitor to her fourth Commission meeting.
She shared that she has been impressed by the Commission's energy and desire to work together to resolve
challenges. She encouraged the Commission to be a role model to the other commissions regarding how to
address conflict and tensions. Director Schaefer remarked that it is important for the City to focus on training
and relationship building for the City Council appointees as they begin their work on the boards and
commissions.
VII. REPORTS/RECOMMENDATIONS
VII.A. BIAS/HATE CRIME RESPONSE PLAN UPDATED
Commissioner Winnick reported that he had recently met with Jeff Long, Police Chief, to begin the annual
review of the Commission's Bias/Hate Crime Response Plan. The Chief will follow up with recommendations
for the revision of the first and second sections of the plan's process. Items discussed were:
• An inadvertent disclosure of a Police report
• Follow-up information on the apprehension and conviction of the spray painting of local churches by
an individual
• Community education and information sharing: new Hindu temple, Jewish cemetery's fence removal,
and the Islamic community
• A proposed By -Laws amendment regarding non -disclosure of confidential information
Commissioner Winnick shared that the Police Department has been reaching out to build positive
relationships in the community. The Commissioners questioned ways to help the Police Department with
community education, special events, and to collaborate in planning a city-wide picnic.
Commissioner Winnick shared a draft new Section 9 to the Commission's By -Laws that pertains to
confidential communications and exceptions. A third paragraph might be added which would deal with a
closed Commission meeting. If approved, the current Section 9 of the By-Laws—By-Laws and Rules—would
be renumbered as Section 10.
Motion by Commissioner Winnick and seconded by Commissioner Bigbee to adopt the new Section 9 to
the By -Laws at the October meeting upon study and approval by the Human Resources Director.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick and Chair Kingston
Motion carried.
VII. B. ALLEGED BULLYING INCIDENT DISCUSSED
Commissioners Finsness and Winnick recently met with the Park Director, John Keprios, to discuss a bullying
incident within the Hockey Association's program which had been reported at the "Reflections on Bullying"
event last April. Mr. Keprios shared the City's bullying policy, which will be forwarded to the Commission,
and indicated that he would contact the Hockey Association regarding the bullying incident. Director
Schaefer will investigate whether there are any additional City contracts regarding bullying and report back to
the Commission.
VII.C. 'BULLYING PREVENTION MONTH" PROCLAMATION APPROVED
Commissioner Finsness reported that October is National Bullying Awareness Month. Because anti -bullying is
the Commission's theme for the year, she shared a sample proclamation which could be prepared as a local
proclamation for the City of Edina.
Motion by Commissioner Finsness and seconded by Commissioner Cashmore to prepare a proclamation for
the Mayor to read and for Council to adopt at its first City Council meeting in October.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick and Chair Kingston
Motion carried.
City staff will send the proclamation to the School District. It was suggested that this item be added to the
2012 Work Plan for August. Student Member Nolan recommended sharing the proclamation with the 212
Leadership Group, the members of Dare to Be Real, and the Gay -Straight Alliance.
VII.D. EDINA COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING DISCUSSED AND NEW REPRESENTATIVE APPOINTED
On behalf of the Human Rights and Relations Commission and to fill in for Commissioner Finsness,
Commissioner Winnick attended the 2011-12 kick-off meeting of the Edina Community Council. He reported
that Amber Cameron is the new Director of the Edina Resource Center. At the meeting, the members of the
Council had discussed the upcoming School Referendum, the work plan, census data, and how to use smaller
resources for the greater need.
Motion by Commissioner Finsness and seconded by Commissioner Bigbee to appoint Commissioner
Winnick as the new Commission representative to the Edina Community Council.
Ayes: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick and Chair Kingston
Motion carried.
VII.E. CITY-WIDE PICNIC DISCUSSED
Commissioner Cashmore shared that both Council Member Sprague and Mayor Hovland had approached him
about the Commission sponsoring a City-wide picnic. Their ideas and those brought forward by the
Commission included: using ethnic food vendors at a large community picnic, a collaborative event with the
Police Department and/or Park and Recreation, and tying it in with a popular and pre-existing City event.
Commissioner Cashmore will follow up with Council Member Sprague and Mayor Hovland for clarity and
guidance.
VII.F. WORK OF THE HUMAN SERVICES TASK FORCE REPORTED
Having been appointed to serve on the newly -created Human Services Task Force, Commissioner Stanton
shared the process and the work being done. Five advisory commissioners make up the Task Force: Ann
Braden from the Transportation Commission, Colleen Curran from the Heritage Preservation Board, Carolyn
Peterson from the Community Health Committee, Louise Segreto from the Park Board, and HRRC member
Russ Stanton who was elected Chair of the group. Having studied the nine proposals for human services in
2012 amounting to $128,477, the group met on two consecutive Wednesday evenings in September to
review the proposals and conduct a hearing for the providers. The third meeting will be to draft a proposed
2012 human services budget in the amount of $81,278, representing a two percent increase over the current
year's funding. Thereafter, the Task Force will go before the City Council at a work session on October 4th to
present and discuss the proposed human services budget for 2012.
VII.G. EDINA DAY OF SERVICE DETAILS SHARED
The Executive Director of Connecting With Kids (CWK), Heather Haen Anderson, had provided an e-mail with
news for boards and commissions regarding the Edina Day of Service to be held on Saturday, October 15tH
CWK is a City-wide initiative to support asset development in the youth of Edina. The event is all about
providing service to the community in collaboration with the schools, churches, civic organizations and
individuals. The website—connectingwithkidsedina.org—will be up and running with updates for service
projects and the latest ideas.
VII.H. TAPED MEETING IN NOVEMBER DISCUSSED
Because the November Commission meeting will be its annual meeting and broadcasted on cable TV, ideas
for creating the meeting agenda were shared:
• Introduction of Commissioners
• Census data update
• Domestic Partnerships
• Anti -Bullying initiative
• Days of Remembrance
• Bias/Hate Crime Response Plan
It was suggested that the Director of Hennepin South Services Collaborative and the new Director of the
Edina Resource Center attend and highlight demographics and census information in a PowerPoint
presentation.
Motion by Commissioner Winnick and seconded by Commissioner Newell to create an agenda at the
regular meeting in October for the November Commission meeting which focuses on past
accomplishments.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick and Chair Kingston
Abstain: Cashmore
Motion carried.
VIII. CORRESPONDENCE AND PETITIONS
No correspondence or petitions were received.
IX. CHAIR AND COMMISSION MEMBERS' COMMENTS
Commissioner Stanton reported that he had communicated with the City Manager and the City
Attorney regarding the Commission's ability to advocate/educate during the upcoming dialogue
about the marriage constitutional amendment. The advice received was that HRRC could take a
position and adopt a resolution pertaining to the subject but could not expend public funds
advocating its position. In addition, HRRC could host an educational forum as long as multiple points
of view are presented. Commissioner Stanton recommended that this be discussed as part of next
year's Work Plan.
Chair Kingston reported that she will prepare the League's GLBT Resolution to present to the Edina
City Council for approval. She also shared that 13 Minnesota cities have now passed a Domestic
Partnership Ordinance and that she will be attending a November meeting in Plymouth to discuss
creating an ordinance.
Commissioner Finsness shared that the film "The Bully Project" could be considered as the topic for
the next Edina Dialogue. This film is a new feature-length documentary that follows "a year in the
life" of America's bullying crisis and offers an intimate look at how bullying has touched the lives of
five kids and their families. It stimulates the concept of a grass-roots movement to prevent bullying
through new school and community initiatives including campaigns, social media, and video projects.
X. STAFF COMMENTS
There were no comments.
Xl. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business on the Commission Agenda, Chair Kingston declared the meeting adjourned
at 9:20 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Minutes approved by HRRC, October 25, 2011.
Susan Howl, HRRC Staff Liaison
Jessi Kingston, HRRC Chair
MINUTES
OF THE REGULAR MEETING OF THE
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
OCTOBER 25, 2011
7:03 PM
1. CALL TO ORDER
First Vice Chair Finsness called the meeting to order at 7:03 PM.
11. ROLLCALL
Answering rollcall were Commissioners Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, and Winnick,
and Student Members Aderhold and Nolan. Staff present: Lisa Schaefer, Human Resources Director; Karen
Kurt, Assistant City Manager; and Susan Howl, staff liaison.
111. MEETING AGENDA APPROVED
Motion by Commissioner Winnick and seconded by Commissioner Cashmore approving the meeting
agenda of October 25, 2011, and continuing Item VI.E. Process/Questionnaire for Funding Requests to the
December meeting and replacing Item VI.E. with Bias/Hate Crime Meeting Update.
Ayes: Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
IV. CONSENT AGENDA ADOPTED
Motion by Commissioner Mayer and seconded by Commissioner Seidman approving the consent agenda as
follows:
V.A. Approve regular meeting minutes of September 27, 2011.
Ayes: Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
V. COMMUNITY COMMENT
There were no community comments.
VI. REPORTS/RECOMMENDATIONS
VI.A. EDINA COMMUNITY COUNCIL MEETING DISCUSSED
Commissioner Winnick reported that a VEAP representative shared the following information at the recent
Community Council meeting:
• There has been a 29% increase in VEAP's services, which include the food and transportation
programs. More seniors have called for help, and there was a large increase of families accessing the
food shelf.
• Bloomington Public Health shared that the Statewide Health Improvement Program (SHIP) will be
presenting a grant proposal focusing on chronic disease causes, prevention, obesity and tobacco
use/exposure.
VI.B. TOM OYE HUMAN RIGHTS AWARD PROCESS REVIEWED
Commissioner Mayer shared the history of the Commission's award which is presented annually at the City's
Volunteer Recognition Reception in April. As he will continue to oversee the process, he invited other
Commissioners to assist him to ensure that the following is completed:
• Produce article for the About Town.
• Produce announcement in the Sun -Current.
• Work with the Communications Department throughout the process to prepare for a segment on
Cable Channel 16, highlighting award recipients.
Re -submit nominations not selected into the current process.
Be ever mindful of ways to increase the visibility of the Commission and its mission.
VI.C. NEW DRAFT TO THE BY-LAWS AND THE OPEN MEETING LAW DISCUSSED
Human Resources Director Schaefer commented on the draft to the Commission By -Laws submitted by
Commissioner Winnick regarding confidential communication in response to the release of private data by
the Police to the Commission. She reported that it is rare for a commission to have a closed meeting. The
City Attorney does not recommend a policy change to the by-laws and encourages the Commission to follow
the data practices of the City.
VI.D. BUDGET, EVENT PLANNING AND POST EVALUATION PROCESS REPORTS REVIEWED
Commissioner Seidman presented the following reporting tools for the Commission's evaluation:
• Budget Planning Worksheet
• Event Planning Guide
• Post Event Evaluation
She requested that the Commissioners submit suggestions and indicated that the forms would be on the
November meeting agenda for approval.
VI. E. INFORMATION FROM THE BIAS/HATE CRIME MEETING SHARED
Commissioner Winnick reported that the Police Department's Public Information Officer, Molly Anderson,
met and welcomed representatives of the new Hindu temple in Edina. Officer Anderson has also been
involved with other potential hate crime issues. The Police Department has indicated that it is making
internal adjustments to ensure that private data is not released in the future. The Commission's 2012 Work
Plan could address ways to incorporate protection of private data into City policy as well as updating the
Bias/Hate Crime Response Plan.
VI.F. COMMISSION'S 2012 PRELIMINARY WORK PLAN INITIATIVES APPROVED
With the 2012 preliminary work plan having been submitted last August by Commission Mayer, the initiatives
for HRRC were reviewed and assigned accordingly to Commissioners as lead people:
• Monitor Domestic Partnership Ordinance (regarding Section 4) — Commissioners Cashmore and
Winnick
• Initiate census research funding recommendation — Commissioner Stanton
• Update Bias/Hate Crime Response Plan — Commissioner Winnick
• Participate in the April event regarding the Nazi persecution of homosexuals — Commissioners
Cashmore and Kingston
• Sponsor Anti -Bullying event and community education — Commissioner Finsness and Student Members
Aderhold and Nolan
• Sponsor Marriage Amendment Forum — Commissioners Cashmore and Stanton, and Student Member
Aderhold
• Sponsor diversity awareness event — Commissioner Mayer
• Sponsor Days of Remembrance — Commissioner Seidman
• Coordinate Somali relief efforts — Commissioner Newell
Motion by Commissioner Stanton and seconded by Commissioner Mayer to approve these initiatives for
the 2012 Preliminary Work Plan.
Ayes: Cashmore, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
VI.G. NOVEMBER COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA DEVELOPED
Because the November 22"d Commission Meeting will be held in the Council Chambers and taped for cable
viewing, the Commissioners carefully reviewed the order of business and agreed on the following agenda
items: census data update, Domestic Partnerships, Anti -Bullying initiative, Days of Remembrance, Bias/Hate
Crime Response Plan, Tom Oye Human Rights Award, and the Commission's event planning process. Amber
Cameron of the Edina Resource Center and Daryl Coppoletti of Hennepin South Services Collaborative will be
guest speakers regarding census information. If PowerPoint presentations are planned, they should be sent
to City staff by November 10`h. It was suggested by staff that rollcall be simple and not involve sharing
personal information.
VII. ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER, KAREN KURT, INTRODUCED AND WELCOMED
The City's new Assistant Manager Kurt was introduced and welcomed to the Commission meeting. She
shared that one of her assignments has been to look at the boards and commissions in a global sense and to
evaluate staff assistance. A process to change commission by-laws was explained:
• Create a common framework for commissions' by-laws.
• Invite a representative from each commission to evaluate the newly -created framework.
Commissioner Mayer agreed to serve as HRRC's representative.
• Plan the "walk-through" of the new framework at each commission meeting in December.
• Bring the new framework to the City Council for approval in the spring of 2012.
Assistant Manager Kurt reported that a survey will soon be sent to all board and commission members for
sharing their experiences as appointed advisors to the Edina City Council. She shared that a training model is
being developed for the orientation of new board and commission members and that student roles are also
being addressed.
VIII. CORRESPONDENCE AND PETITIONS
No correspondence or petitions were received.
IX. CHAIR AND COMMISSION MEMBERS' COMMENTS
• Student Member Aderhold reported that he had helped created a No Hate Week at the High School
on behalf of the Gay -Straight Alliance and DARE. Posters were placed throughout the school
regarding discrimination and bullying, and a petition will be created and sent to the State Legislature
and Governor.
• Student Member Nolan reported that she is involved in a visual arts project regarding anti -bullying at
the High School. The goal is to have art work and exhibits placed not only in the schools but
throughout the community for everyone to view.
X. STAFF COMMENTS
There were no comments.
Xl. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business on the Commission Agenda, First Vice Chair Finsness declared the meeting
adjourned at 9:10 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Minutes approved by HRRC, November 22, 2011.
Susan Howl, HRRC Staff Liaison
Lisa Finsness, HRRC First Vice Chair
MINUTES
OF THE ANNUAL MEETING OF THE
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS & RELATIONS COMMISSION
NOVEMBER 22, 2011
7:00 PM
1. CALL TO ORDER
Chair Kingston called the meeting to order at 7:00 PM.
11. ROLLCALL
Answering rollcall were Commissioners Bigbee, Finsness, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton, Winnick,
Student Members Aderhold and Nolan, and Chair Kingston. Staff present: Lisa Schaefer, Human
Resources Director, and Susan Howl, staff liaison.
III. MEETING AGENDA APPROVED
Motion by Commissioner Stanton and seconded by Commissioner Newell approving the meeting
agenda of November 22, 2011, with the addition of Item VI.H. Human Rights Conference.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
IV. CONSENT AGENDA ADOPTED
Motion by Commissioner Mayer and seconded by Commissioner Seidman approving the consent
agenda as follows:
V.A. Approve regular meeting minutes of October 25, 2011.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
V. COMMUNITY COMMENT
There were no community comments.
Vl. REPORTS/RECOMMENDATIONS
VI.A. CENSUS DATA UPDATES REPORTED
Commissioner Stanton shared that HRRC could investigate ways to fund a census data report for future
planning. Edina is rapidly changing, as seen in the divided economics within the community. In a
portion of the northeast quadrant, the median family income is $178,000, while the amount is $39,000
in a portion of the southeast quadrant. Edina's population is becoming more diverse, with 27% foreign
born in the southeast quadrant.
Amber Cameron, Edina Resource Center Manager, presented a power point of the 2010 census data.
She referenced the New York Times innovation entitled "Mapping America Every City Block" which
allows a person to explore a variety of demographics such as race and ethnicity, income, education and
housing/families.
• With growing disparities in Edina, the question becomes how to shift Edina's resources.
• There has been a decrease in the White population—the largest decrease seen in the southeast
quadrant.
In every area of Edina, the median home value has increased.
People are not accessing the resources that are available to them. The Resource Center seeks
ways to reach the diverse populations and work with Richfield schools in the southeast
quadrant—i.e. scholarships for enrichment classes.
There has been an increase in family wealth in people over 65 and a loss in income in people
under 35.
• There are many calls to the Resource Center from the senior population, while there are fewer
calls from young families and the populations between 18 and 25.
• The Edina Community Council, the Resource Center's advisory body, continues to seek ways to
market the services of the Center to all the populations in Edina.
• A challenge exists in finding ways to bring inclusive togetherness into neighborhoods which have
greater affordable housing opportunities.
• A do.Town grant will provide classes and services to the less fluent populations. This effort could
become a satellite office of the Resource Center.
Daryl Coppoletti, Regional Planning Coordinator of the Hennepin South Services Collaborative (HSSC),
provided a power point of census information in Edina and the south Hennepin community.
• Trends are the same in all the communities, while issues may be different.
• The senior population throughout the communities is now eight to ten percent.
• The following facts were presented regarding the low income residents of Edina: households are
earning less money; more people are living in poverty; fewer families are living in poverty; more
children are qualifying for free or reduced lunch; more homeowners are cost burdened by
housing costs; and foreclosures continue to rise.
• Research could be undertaken to learn how these changes in Edina will impact the needs for
services.
• If Edina wanted to undertake a study regarding demographics and emerging issues, the following
topics could be investigated: occupational re-training for the unemployed; barriers to building
affordable housing; the growing wealth gap; transportation; and poverty.
• A study undertaken for Edina by HSSC would be labor intensive—nine months from start to finish.
This could be a cost of approximately $40,000. Another option would be for Edina to re -join the
collaborative and contribute $25,000 annually.
VI.B. DOMESTIC PARTNERSHIP ORDINANCE HIGHLIGHTS SHARED
Chair Kingston reported that since Edina created its Domestic Partnership Registry and Ordinance, 15
cities in Minnesota now have a registry and ordinance. Currently, there are ten couples registered in
Edina.
Citizens of Edina are now assured that Edina public venues will have the same registration,
membership or other fees for Domestic Partnerships as for traditional families.
The City of Edina's Personnel Policy was updated to include the benefits of sick leave, funeral and
illness for Domestic Partnerships.
The initial homestead rights of Domestic Partnerships are now recognized.
VI.C. ANTI -BULLYING INITIATIVE REVIEWED
With 150 attendees at last April's event entitled "Reflections on Bullying," Commissioners Newell and
Finsness reported that it resulted in a raising of awareness in the community, and the City Council
proclaimed October Anti -Bullying Month. The April event included the following:
• A light supper with a presentation of submissions and display of EdinaSecrets posts
• Presentation of the short film, "Bullied," produced by the Southern Poverty Law Center
• Panel with students and members of the community
• Opportunity for audience engagement
Student Members Aderhold and Nolan shared the following activities happening at the High School with
the Gay Straight Alliance:
• "No Hate Week" event
• Petition signing for "Safe Schools for All " legislation
• The 360 Visual Arts Project
• Upcoming "Day of Silence"
• Opportunities to meet with local and State officials on behalf of equal rights for the GLBT
community
VI.D. DAYS OF REMEMBRANCE EVENT REVIEWED
Commissioner Seidman shared that the City's first "Days of Remembrance" event on Sunday, May 1't
was an opportunity to engage the community in acknowledging the Holocaust.
• The City Council proclaimed May 1S` through May 8`h, 2011, as Days of Remembrance.
• At the Sunday event, Mayor Hovland presented the proclamation.
• Fred Baron, a survivor, spoke about his experiences during and after the Holocaust.
• "World Without Genocide" was present at the event.
• Also included that day were displays of the Holocaust in Greece.
VI.E. BIAS/HATE CRIME RESPONSE PLAN REVIEWED
Commissioner Winnick reported that HRRC's Response Plan required that an annual review with the
Police Chief was to be completed in March.
• The Plan provides for a timely local response showing victim support.
• The Plan upholds zero community tolerance for any crimes of bias or hate.
• The Plan seeks to raise community awareness.
• The Plan establishes and updates a network to be activated if needed.
VI.F. TOM OYE HUMAN RIGHTS AWARD PROCESS OUTLINED
Commissioner Mayer provided information about HRRC's annual Tom Oye Human Rights Award to be
presented in April at the City's Volunteer Recognition Reception.
• The Award was initiated in 2006, and ten recipients have been honored.
• The Award recognizes individuals who live and work in Edina and whose good works promote
human relations and advance human rights.
• Dan Johnson, the retired pastor of Good Samaritan United Methodist Church, was the 2011
recipient.
• There will be a story about the Award in the winter About Town and also an article placed in the
Sun -Current to encourage nominations.
• Nomination for 2012 will be accepted until the deadline of February 17th
VI.G. EVENT PLANNING PROCESS APPROVED
In order to establish a structured budget and event planning process for Commissioners to use when
planning an HRRC event and to conduct a post evaluation after the conclusion of an HRRC event,
Commissioner Seidman presented three documents (planning and reporting tools) for consideration and
approval.
• Budget Planning Worksheet
• Event Planning Guide
• Post Event Evaluation
Motion by Commissioner Newell and seconded by Commissioner Winnick approving the three
documents as presented.
Ayes: Bigbee, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Newell, Seidman, Stanton and Winnick
Motion carried.
VI.H. HUMAN RIGHTS CONFERENCE INFORMATION PRESENTED
Commissioner Bigbee shared that HRRC could host a table at the League's Human Rights Conference in
St. Paul on December 2"d. The event will note the League's 40th anniversary with a dinner the night
before. Hosting a table would be a networking opportunity for the Commission. The following
Commissioners indicated an interest in attending along with Commissioner Bigbee: Stanton, Newell and
Winnick. The staff liaison will coordinate the registration fees.
Vll. CORRESPONDENCE AND PETITIONS
No correspondence or petitions were received.
VIII. CHAIR AND COMMISSION MEMBERS' COMMENTS
Chair Kingston reported that a former HRRC Member and State League Board member, Idelle
Longman, prepared a Chanukah display for viewing at the Edina Community Library over the
holidays.
The Commissioners shared their condolences regarding Commissioner Cashmore's
hospitalization and wishes for his speed recovery.
IX. STAFF COMMENTS
There were no comments.
X. ADJOURNMENT
There being no further business on the Commission Agenda, Chair Kingston declared the meeting
adjourned at 8:50 PM.
Respectfully submitted,
Minutes approved by HRRC, January 24, 2012.
Susan Howl, HRRC Staff Liaison
Jessi Kingston, HRRC Chair
EDINA HUMAN RIGHTS AND RELATIONS COMMISSION
MINUTES FOR MEETING OF TUESDAY, JANUARY 26, 2010 - MAYOR'S CONFERENCE ROOM
ADVOCATE FOR BASIC HUMAN RIGHTS AND NEEDS IN OUR COMMUNITY;
PROMOTE RESPONSIBILITY AND INTEGRITY IN OUR HUMAN RELATIONSHIPS
BY PROVIDING SERVICE, INFORMATION AND RECOMMENDATIONS;
COOPERATE WITH OTHER COMMUNITIES AND GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS;
AND SPONSOR FORUMS AND COMMUNITY EVENTS
Members Attending: Bigbee, Cashmore, Finsness, Kingston, Mayer, Newell, Stanton
Members Absent: Mohtadi, Weisberg
Visitors: Mary Brindle, Phil Duran, Carol Jones, Colin Jones, Cammie Jones
Staff: Susan Howl
Time
Item
Discussion
Action
Who/When
7:00
Welcome
7:01
Agenda
Add Nominating Committee Report and Community
Council Material
Agenda Modified
7:03
Guests
Council Member Brindle, Phil Duran, Carol Jones, Colin
Jones and Cammie Jones
Introduced
7:10
12/8/09 Minutes
New format introduced.
Approved
Cashmore & Kingston
7:15 Domestic Partnership
Draft Ordinance
Will go before the City Council at the Work Session.
Approved
Mayer & Kingston - 3/2/10
Will be on the City Council's agenda for final approval.
Future Council Meeting
Resolution will be on its own page with supporting
documentation behind it.
Articles One and Two are not part of the ordinance.
Appropriate language regarding union staff will be
included in #3 of the resolution.
Input to come
from Ceil Smith
Exceptions noted on page 15 help to lift a possible
administrative burden within Exhibit B.
Final draft will be available at the 2/23/10 HRRC meeting.
Time
Item
Discussion
Action
Who/When
8:05
Proposed Annual
Work Plan
2010 Work Plan Attached
Adopted
Kingston & Mayer
Major areas of the plan: Administration (new officers,
Tom Oye Award), Social Service (funding of human
services, RPC, and CDBG), and Other (DP Ordinance,
census research, Bias/Hate Crime Plan, funding process,
and visibility initiatives)
Noted
Items within "Other" would become five areas
for team members and will help define responsibilities
for new candidates to the HRRC.
Open microphone forum monthly for report to the Council
Member Cashmore
Appoint Commissioners to the five areas.
2/23/2010
Consider ways to collaborate with the School District.
8:40
CDBG Funding
Planning staff's recommendation: H.O.M.E. $17,165;
CAPSH $5,000; HomeLine $2,030; TOTAL $24,915
Approved
Bigbee & Mayer
one abstained
8:50
Tom Oye Award
Presented at Volunteer Recognition on 4-29-10
Applications due on 3-12-10
Electronic applications on the website
Jennifer Bennerotte
Send information to: boards and commission, Council
Members, community organizations, School Key Contacts,
EdLine, City Extra, Sun Current
Staff Liaison
9:00
Nominating
Committee
Member Bigbee was presented as the Chair nominee.
Nominations for 1st and 2nd Vice Chairs are needed.
Voting for 2010 officers
2/23/2010
9:05
Community
Council
Materials from meeting of 1/19/10 were shared.
Questions can be fielded to Member Finsness.
Member Finsness
9:10
Volunteer
Recognition
Recognize Rotary's efforts in the schools.
2/23/2010
9:15
Adjournment
Approved