Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2016 05-10 HPB Packet Regular Agenda Heritage Preservation Board City Of Edina, Minnesota City Hall -Community Room 4801 West 50th Street Edina, MN 55424 Tuesday, May 10, 2016 7:00 PM I. Call To Order II. Roll Call Ill. Approval Of Meeting Agenda IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes A. Heritage Preservation Board Minutes, April 12, 2016 V. Community Comment During"Community Comment,"the Board/Commission will invite residents to share relevant issues or concerns. Individuals must limit their comments to three minutes. The Chair may limit the number of speakers on the same issue in the interest of time and topic. Generally speaking, items that are elsewhere on tonight's agenda may not be addressed during Community Comment. Individuals should not expect the Chair or Board/Commission Members to respond to their comments tonight. Instead,the Board/Commission might refer the matter to staff for consideration at a future meeting. VI. Reports/Recommendations A. Changes to Certificate of Appropriateness -4610 Browndale Avenue B. Changes to Certificate of Appropriateness-4602 Wooddale Avenue VII. Correspondence And Petitions VIII. Chair And Member Comments IX. Staff Comments X. Adjournment The City of Edina wants all residents to be comfortable being part of the public process. If you need assistance in the way of hearing amplification, an interpreter, large-print documents or something else, please call 952-927-8861 72 hours in advance of the meeting. (''‘'w �j CITY OF EDINA --4A' 0 4801 West 50th Street �'v -Xi rj .�� Edina, MN 55424 .'�` iv ��'` www.edinamn.gov Date: May 10, 2016 Agenda Item#:WA. To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type: Minutes From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner Item Activity: Subject: Heritage Preservation Board Minutes,April 12, 2016 Action ACTION REQUESTED: Approve the minutes from the April 12, 2016 HPB meeting. INTRODUCTION: ATTACHMENTS: Heritage Preservation Board Minutes,April 12,2016 Draft Minutes® Approved Minutes❑ Approved Date:Click here to enter a date. 04)��r Minutes 04 City Of Edina, Minnesota '� Heritage Preservation Board f�• \\ \ .- / ? Edina City Hall - Community Room ,71)'' 4801 West 50thStreet Tuesday, April 12, 2016 at 7:00 p.m. I. Call To Order Chair Birdman called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. II. Roll Call Answering roll call were Chairman Birdman,Vice Chair Weber, and Members Christiaansen, Sussman, Moore, McLellan, Kelly, Nymo, and Student Members Puerzer and Otness. Absent was Member Pearson. Staff Liaison, Senior Planner Joyce Repya, and Heritage Preservation Consultant Robert Vogel were also in attendance. III. Approval Of Meeting Agenda Motion was made by Kelly and seconded by McLellan to approve the meeting agenda.All voted aye. The motion carried. IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes - March 8, 2016 Motion was made by Sussman and seconded by Christiaansen to approve of the minutes from the March 8, 2016 meeting.All voted aye. The motion carried. V. Community Comment - None VI. Reports/Recommendations A. Certificate of Appropriateness: Process for Evaluating Projects Planner Repya provided the board with a written explanation of how the Planning Department staff interprets the Country Club District's plan of treatment relative to when a Certificate of Appropriateness is required. The board members expressed that staff's explanation is consistent with the language in the plan of treatment; however they also understood how there could be confusion from the neighborhood regarding terminology. Dan Dulas,4609 Bruce Avenue, addressed the board reiterating his concerns regarding staff's interpretation of the plan of treatment that he expressed at the March meeting. Draft Minutes® Approved Minutes❑ Approved Date:Click here to enter a date. Expressing a desire to ensure clarity in the plan of treatment,the board agreed to suggest to the City Council that the HPB's 2017 work plan include an initiative to evaluate of the language in the Country Club District's plan of treatment. No formal action was taken. B. Edina Heritage Award Nominations The following nominations were received for the 2016 Heritage Award: • The Vayda Residence, 5201 Wooddale Avenue. Nominated by Rehkamp Larson Architects recognizing an addition to the home that embraced the original architecture of the 1935 Tudor style home. • Braemar Arena, 7501 Ikola Way. Nominated by HPB member Bob Moore recognizing the 50th Anniversary of a City facility that has been and continues to be a popular destination for Edina residents. Upon a vote, the Vayda Residence received eight votes;the Braemar Arena received one vote;and there was one abstention - thus, the recipient of the 2016 Heritage Award will be the Vayda Residence, 5201 Wooddale Avenue. The award presentation will take place at one of the City Council meetings in May, depending on the availability of the recipients. C. 2016 Preservation Month Proclamation Planner Repya provided a 2016 Preservation Month Proclamation for the boards' information; pointing out that annually the Proclamation is adopted by the City Council at their first meeting in May. The text of the Proclamation is the same each year,with the exception of the theme,which for 2016 is "Celebrate the Past as we Plan for the Future". The board agreed that the theme provides a good representation of the goals and accomplishments of the HPB. No formal action was taken. D. Committee Reports • Educational Opportunities The board reviewed the goals/mission of the committee.While many of the goals have been accomplished, the committee expressed interest in organizing an activity to showcase Edina's heritage. • Explore the History of Your Home The goals/mission of the committee were reviewed.The concept of partnering with the Edina Historical Society to assist homeowners in exploring the history of their homes was mentioned since the Historical Society has been a natural stop off point for that type of research project.An online home history survey was also discussed since Edina has over the years had an excellent response rate when survey opportunities are provided. E. Historic Map on the City's Web Site Draft Minutes® Approved Minutes❑ Approved Date:Click here to enter a date. Planner Repya provided the board with a demonstration of how one accesses Edina's historic map on the City's web site. She explained that the new map will provide links to portions of the HPB's web pages where detailed information on the historic properties is provided. She added that currently the map is not available on the city's mobile app, however the City's Communications Department is checking into that possibility. VII. Correspondence - Preservation Articles of Interest A. About Town - Spring 2016: Call for 2016 Heritage Award Nominations B. About Town - Spring 2016: Oskam House, 6901 Dakota Trail, Designated an Edina Heritage Landmark C. Edition Edina - March 2016:Wooddale Bridge Added to the National Register VIII. Chair And Member Comments • Kelly announced the 2nd annual Country Club District Tour sponsored by the neighborhood on Saturday, May 7th, 10:00 a.m.The congregation point is in Wooddale Park; registration is online, and there is a $10 fee. The proceeds from the tour will go toward funding the neighborhood signage project. • Moore, following up on Kelly's announcement, explained that at the Historical Society, the original blueprint plans for the home at 4513 Wooddale Avenue were found; adding that perhaps the tour organizers would be interested in displaying the plans at the congregation point prior to the tour. IX. Staff Comments • Schedule for Wooddale Bridge Proposed Designation as an Edina Heritage Landmark: Planning Commission - April 13th Meeting City Council (Public Hearing) - May 17th Meeting • Summer Tour 2016 - Consider the tour designed by Student Member Peter Otness of the West side of the Country Club District.The last HPB Country Club District Tour was in 2007. Will add to the May agenda for a final decision. X. Adjournment - 8:50 p.m. Respectfully Submitted Jays 1epyw 4,,% ''N-4,, CITY OF EDINA o 4801 West 50th Street cn v : • �0 Edina, MN 55424 `'tFK ��°' www.edinamn.gov MON Date: May 10, 2016 Agenda Item#:VLA. To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type: Report and Recommendation From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner Item Activity: Subject: Changes to Certificate of Appropriateness -4610 Action Browndale Avenue ACTION REQUESTED: Approve changes to the Certificate of Appropriateness plans for a street facing attached garage originally approved on February 9, 2016. INTRODUCTION: A Certificate of Appropriateness was issued on February 9, 2016 for changes to an attached street facing garage at 4610 Browndale Avenue. The homeowner would like to make changes to the plans which staff believes continue to comply with the Country Club District's plan of treatment. See attached staff report and supporting materials. ATTACHMENTS: 4610 Browndale Ave-Staff Report,Narrative,2-9-16 Minutes 4610 Browndale Ave.-Revised Plans 4, HERITAGE PRESERVATION BOARD ° N �` CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS . �y° STAFF REPORT .,��o moo. V6 Q Originator Meeting Date Agenda #VI. A.I. Joyce Repya May 10, 2016 H-16-2 Senior Planner APPLICANT: Douglas & Julie Baker LOCATION: 4610 Browndale Avenue PROPOSAL: Change to the Certificate of Appropriateness approved on February 9, 2016 RECOMMENDED ACTION: Approve the proposed changes to the issued Certificate of Appropriateness INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND: At the February 9th Heritage Preservation Board meeting, plans for modifications to an existing attached street facing garage were approved. The plans included: • Reducing the frontage from two doors (one single and one double) totaling 21' in width, to one door 18' wide; and providing a service entry door into the home; and • Construction of an addition to the front of the garage measuring 14' x 22' or 308 sq.ft. The existing attached garage is set back 24 feet from the front façade of the home - a hipped roof addition to the front of the garage is proposed, still providing a setback of 10 feet from the front façade of the home. The homeowners are requesting the following changes to the approved plans: 1. Re-orient the garage access to the north side yard 2. Eliminate the street facing garage doors 3. Maintain the existing capacity for 3 car stalls 4. Match materials and the details of the home as follows: A. Option 1. Stucco and half-timbers to match character of existing home as well as dining addition to the Southwest corner of house; or B. Option 2. Brick and stone to match character of existing home, dependent upon availability of matching brick. Original brick manufacturer is no longer in business. I H-16-2 4610 Browndale Avenue May 10, 2016 The revised plans provide for an attached garage that is no taller than the previously approved plan, yet slightly smaller in mass and width than what was originally approved. Furthermore, the revised garage will be setback further from the front street, with the garage doors facing the side yard, not the front street. The intent of the revised garage design is to retain the traditional detailing and quality of craftsmanship of the existing 1933 home, as well as the surrounding historic neighborhood. STAFF RECOMMENDATION & FINDINGS: Both of the proposed changes offered for the attached garage on the north side of the home, (identified as options 1 and 2), comply with the Country Club District's plan of treatment, as did the plan originally plan approved on February 9, 2016; thus staff recommends approval of the requested changes. The approval recommendation is subject to: • The revised plans dated April 29, 2016, and • Notifying City Staff of the decided upon final option 1 or 2. Findings supporting the recommendation include: • No significant character defining details will be destroyed; • There will be no substantial loss of historic fabric; • The garage addition will be compatible with the scale and proportions of the historic façade; • The details of modified attached garage are characteristic of the English Tudor Revival aesthetic; and • The proposed plans are compatible with the historic character of the surrounding neighborhood. Attachments: Revised Plans dated April 29, 2016 Applicant Narrative HPB Minutes- February 9, 2016 2 City of Edina Heritage Preservation Board Certificate of Appropriateness for the property at 4610 Browndale Avenue The owners of this 1933 tudor home wish to modify their existing,street facing,three car garage. They would like to: • Re-orient garage access to north side yard • Eliminate the street facing garage doors • Maintain existing capacity for 3 car stalls • Match materials and details of the home o Option 1—Stucco: use Stucco and Half Timber to match character of existing home as well as dining addition on Southwest corner of house. o Option 2—Brick: use Brick and Stone to match character of existing home,dependent upon finding a brick match. Original brick manufacturer is no longer in business. The proposed design is slightly smaller both in width of garage mass coming forward as well as distance that the garage comes forward toward the street,than the previously approved design. The proposed garage addition at 4610 Browndale Avenue seeks to retain the traditional detailing and quality of craftsmanship of the existing 1933 home and of the surrounding historical Country Club neighborhood. Plans and elevations of the non-street facing additions to 4610 Browndale are included. Draft Minutes0 Approved MinuteslO Approved Date:3/8/2016 yf'tj�•\ �I_,\ Minutes t/ ` City Of Edina, Minnesota ` '; Heritage Preservation Board Annual Meeting a . >.,, ,,✓ 4801 West 506 Street Edina, MN 55424 Tuesday, February 9, 2016 at 7:00 p.m. I. Call To Order Chair Weber called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. II. Roll Call Answering roll call were Chair Weber,Vice Chair Christiaansen,and Members, McLellan, Birdman, Kelly, Pearson,O'Brien and Student Members Otness and Puerzer.Absent were Members Moore and Sussman. HPB Staff Liaison -Senior Planner,Joyce Repya was also in attendance. • III. Approval Of Meeting Agenda Motion was made by Member O'Brien to approve the meeting agenda.Motion seconded by Member McLellan. All voted aye. The motion carried. IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes-January 12,2016 Motion was made by Member Birdman to approve the January 12, 2016 HPB meeting minutes. Motion seconded by Member Kelly.All voted aye. Motion carried. V. Community Comment- None VI. Reports/Recommendations A. 4610 Browndale Avenue-New Detached Garage Planner Repya explained that the applicant is requesting to add an addition to the street facing attached garage. The proposed plans for the garage addition will allow space for a secondary entry(service door)to the home, more in line with the existing scale of the structure as well as complimenting the home's details and finishings. Furthermore,the garage addition will provide for additional storage and parking for three vehicles. Ms. Repya also pointed out that the hip roof on the garage addition will replicate the hip roof on the home, however with a lower slope to minimize bulk. Ms. Repya pointed out that plans for additions to the rear of the home, (not subject to a COA)were provided for the HPB's information.Ms. Repya also reported Preservation Consultant had reviewed the proposed plans and found the design in keeping with the subject home,surrounding neighborhood, and consistent with the provisions of the district's plan of treatment.She then concluded that staff recommended approval of the subject COA subject to the plans presented. Applicant Present Jean Rehkamp Larson and Anders Matney, Rehkamp Larson Architects, Inc. Architect Rehkamp Larson addressed the low pitch of the hip roof on the garage addition,explaining that they initially pursued a higher pitched roof on the addition to replicate the pitch of the gables on the home,and found that the lower pitch would be much more unobtrusive and appropriate for an attached garage. Draft MinutesO Approved Minutes® Approved Date:3/8/2016 Motion made by Member Kelly to approve the COA for changes to the street facing façade for an attached garage addition subject to the plans presented.Motion was seconded by Member Christiaansen All voted aye. The motion carried. B. Educational Opportunities Subcommittee- Update Chair of the subcommittee, Member Christiaansen provided the board with a summary of the committee's activities since the last meeting.She pointed out that the goal to work with the high school to gain student participation in creating a heritage preservation app ran into a snag with the high school contact reporting that they have discovered the app creation to be too complex for students. She suggested the committee check with the teacher responsible for scheduling the 2017 May term projects to garner interest from the participating students. Planner Repya offered to check with the city's communication's department to see if there is an existing or planned Edina app that would be able to include a heritage preservation component. C. 2016 Nominations for Edina Heritage Award Planner Repya reported that the month of February is typically when the call for Heritage Award nominations goes out to the community.She pointed out that the current description of the award states that"The Edina Heritage Award showcases local preservation activities";and pointed out that some of the past recipients have showcased local preservation activities, but have also highlighted sites that have enriched the fabric of the community- harkened to the city's past,so to speak,ex. Convention Grill, Edina Theater Sign,Southdale.The board agreed with Ms. Repya's observation and thought to expand the description to include"highlighting sites in Edina that have enriched the historic fabric of the community"would be a good idea. Board members brainstormed ideas for potential award recipients. Ms. Repya concluded that the deadline for 2016 Edina Heritage Award nominations will be Friday,April 8th,to enable the board to decide upon an award recipient at the April 12th HPB meeting. D. Annual Elections Nominations for the office of HPB Chairman for 2016 were requested. Motion was made by Member Christiaansen to nominate Member Birdman to the office of HPB Chair. Motion was seconded by Member Kelly. Member Birdman accepted the nomination.All voted aye. The motion carried. Nominations for the office of HPB Vice Chairman for 2016 were requested. Motion was made by Member Birdman to nominate Member Weber to the office of HPB Vice Chair. Motion was seconded by Member McLellan.Member Weber accepted the nomination.All voted aye. The motion carried. E. Affirm 2016 HPB Meeting Schedule Planner Repya provided the board with the 2016 meeting schedule and explained the reasons for the following Monday(rather than Tuesday) meeting dates: August 9th- Primary Election October I I th-Yom Kippur November 8th-Election Day 17LZL 9Z Z1.9'Xe� SLL-S9Z-ZL9 I .J.ePV 4ZPSS NW rOUIP3 a 01.1759 NW'sldW'}ea SS W£17}saM ZELZw anuany alepumo�9 01.917M -ON1 S1O311H3aV1 NOS21V1 dWV)IH321 NOIIVAON3a a3)1t/8 i NOIIOla1SNOO H01 ION y y ,....,:f.#r .':;:,,‘,-.i..,-,..:Ji'll , ',.1,,,. '.'',- Y ,, -:0,.., . ,..w...„,„09,-. jei,,, , ,, ; 7. ,� QII ll ,.,.. i.: $ o if i' z r ei O III .... ,,,, ,. -, _,, ...,. i i ' W (6 ccr i 1 >q>q1�jj N' \ -' (§,§ x 2"6 s. . .. W m m ti -.'3',',;,...'4.?1 1,4' Ca /11 11 N �� `'�i ,, ,' Q Y o W 4. I W 5m1E_•_ y Q 1� ` z FO OZ 4LZL-98Z-Z19'Xed 9LZL-99Z-Z19'101 II 42445NW'euIP3 w 2F m§ ¢ wa 01499 NW'sldW yaaJ;S PP£41s0M Z£LZ anUOAV eiepumoig 0194 i o y i w - W F o ONI S1031IH021tl NOS2IV1 dWtlNH321 ■ NOIJ.VAON3212I3>it/8 a w -� g$ o ''u a NOI13f1211SNOO 2IOd ION 1 ,� I d, gill al r�l al!Ilr '�'luF I H,t,,, it C1. I IIID IIP I Ir -; lil ��- 11.11: il,lzl r 'u I F � i:1111' lli III.1r �Y 1' \� 1Pr 1 '1'1'1' 1101111,1f F 'HO C 111 Il'l '11..�I 11 l L I IIII{I 18`',1 11 I ' -i:' L IIIIIRI IA Il y' ti IIII IIiI1.1!'iI 1� '1 r h Iddi'I II I l�•ul'11 'L� I 1.1111 Ir �I— - ! �0I� I , f1i1 IIII111 rl�'i.,'rit�l� pn 1 _ �- i 1 !,11!IIlliihI 411 I�t1( '� 9 _ 41II lu h 10,,,,,,,,,,11 ,11,,,,',,,,1,I'. I'll I II ^� .r I @111 IIII III !- .NrI_ 1 �,+ 1.�Y�`� I4 Irr ,{CPQ '-'w:41'r _ f ,1r_:b.- Phi II_a_ IIII I P�lil� 111 i:. hIh 113`1,`; `III ' 1 I lllilili 11 j �I°� IJ Il}1 10 114 v. I ' i4 lhaf raI it !!I It I 1{� or,t,. Fit 1111'1 ili fiil ,. i it i1;1,1;1 :,,,.,11,1,,1:4,,,;:: I.,I {Ii1'I�I IVO ! - 111 I' I11111 IJ.I,111,1 ,!1, r Ily1 -. si6P11111i 11 11110Hr: �� I r. 1 .I1.11 111'I --- imi I II , �� III r -lll'r6'1 1 'I I Ens 11 111 I�� ,Illlill ! 1 1111 -,{11 V 11 , hJ l ',ll4�11'JI1I1iI! ,� '� iI „1:1 ,,, ,11) r III III�Iry ram � I � li � NW 13�fl1�II 1 1 1 IIIA I`I V I111616j0[Thf® !,-,,71,7,77- � �'4l 41 PI 1 1 - ,di 10111111 'ilni 1111 1 IP>U 1f{I d 1 III III 4Jr! Kg! II 111111111 :1, , I 1f1g11 y1,11Fi 1 , 4 II ' I, 11 I I I�III, 11' 1111!Ii3ql ! 11, 1 u � 1:hl I Y I1�ir�li ill I1Fd111�1�ItlII II,�.i;•i , ,� I I a I I ,Oli'A�l 111 .. il. 1 1Ji:C 1 �'4 '1IIIc i4II ii'il. �� 1 I�1I�I. IIII L ! iilll 1 I' �O aoo 111111 I - III'' ' 'aol— '111111 i r 1! I ' _ i 11 =� . �1l 1 I I° i1,.�I o0o Ip11 11` 1 '11'1111 �■��1� '1 1 i1,1141 III Iy r '11711%.11111115/1111111 n 1 1 I f n I ¢ 1' il'rll fl Ir �� ® 14 l 4' 9,IjC 1r 11 p ®' 14 141144 41111I!1111�I' II„i-,,,11,11;i { ! I I 1!11 !1 I 14,11 ,11:11 I� 1 I! I i I 11 P o. C l n II 11,,.� ` I I 1, I!tag IIl1i� ! I III r, r 1numNI 11 i 11 0 0 44 II 1111111x,1i 1 ll�i�'I11MINI X Iii NI 11 •1 I i 11 : III, 11�I'', m rx Ii■Mmi ;I4 �I l.i{ 1 r 191 ,,, LI�i 91 OI I l uL®� L 1,111 !II 1 1 rl 1 11�I . 111 1 l; 1p 111I` I =1 111111 II41 I',..N 11111 111 III i I� D CC i� 1 1 !I .' I 1 I'1 I !� D1 E ii 1111 ,I.ii II 1 t'1 tl 'SII I,p h:II,,.r'I'ama„°, ! {”' �' '{I Iii 1� Ii IIsi+III � I�II1 }��� 1 � � i !�I �I�� y �r 1t4Giiilyh�l II V. Il !ill �il 111 I.1 BI illi, 'I I n 'III'Ill,I ! II 1^ 11 , ill 4 n' 1 1 1 1 il��l llr It, ��ll,,ill I 1 11111.111 1 JI,i I r 1 . imi yy�111$1 p'lit 14 111,1,4101,110111.4:0101. i;I 1,11 1 I II ivolip � �1 �;111E '�lII�I 11;1 ;I�1Ibl 1I�';I� �'I'�I r; �;';111„I� 11111 111 11 11 I�� #,�I '���Il111 '1 li4ili ili iti�r+ lil Ill alill'�i 111 �1��111h 1111 411111111111 t died' 111111 11111111111'�]1 111 il'li�i'Ill 111d1�ld 1.1111110° 1111111i'I111 i1 1'1111 �t IIIICIIIIII I, ,Ii J, I Il,l�I1111 II1111111,11111q I I P 11�I1 411q,11l!11'INI III 111111 111 1I 1 111111II 110 Ill 11 1" i I I1I, I 11111,1 N1 '0111141111$111 I 1 11 I��1i'�1111 11/11111 11'99',,1119941,11' 11 111,41,1 11411,,411141 1.�I 11411 1 411111111111a1111,14110441,4,1111.11.!111 41 111 1 lii I m.1.1111' 11 llli� 6CWild' 1 III ' °kith di'l Ilitl ILMI! ' '1 Ill�d l 1 �I 41�L r !1, '''IIII I� I I I I I �I X11 I� �� � ��� 111111r'l1!l yrlf'11I 1� �II Htllli' Q- '' (il 1 D C,1 1 I' Q I r II 1 1 18 I �r4111111t11i111111I,Ii t f o Limilui IC w III � �I� o U I1 w' n 1,1 I I g L .��� J - ���11 1itl°Ilr�l° 1 ,milli 1 .I.._I� N �� rb 1 1 1 '1 i. I mi� • 1 y 8 I I I I r A II 116 I t t ;. a e mihr4 �!hid�ol i w II. fl IIf 4,[4. I',°Jlr.l.lw _l,,. ill w I r l iii o- IN Intl �o:�a1� .L 2g: I �7ll� Iimml m > .9 'III 9 • y a- x 6a3W6 � . z 0 z < 5 4LZ 1.-99Z9•Xe.d 5 LU-S9Z-ZI.9'lei 4ZPSS NVI'eulP3 MKS NW'sldw'IGaliS Pitt,IseM ZCLZ anuenv elePumate 01.94 ; 6 1 1 1 3 u '3N1 S13311HOLIV NOS21111 dINVMH311 II I 1 NOIIVAON3N 213)1N/8 I i i i A NolionmisNoo NO.4 ION I I 1 ill 11 - I 111 1 q 11 11.. 1 s 11 . E .i 6 1 11 i 1§111§ 1 ig i!!! 15 il 15 ii 11 i . Si .: .1 5 1101111111'•1119,111;limos . 1-111011 111114i1[111 111-rillillil .1'•4111-,1'1.,,•1, 1 FANS. . 4..•-„ii,!?;.....fltr•-,,Lot:,. 1,,,,,1,1,.,,,11,.11, , •. - 1 .F.,I.,1 0,„.1k '„,iw_-„,,,,s,,,,,,,,-:::'.- ,;:', •4,4:„T,,,,,,,,1 . 1 . ,I pi,. , ir.11,,• , imam,', ,. ,411.1ir,1,,111,1' stign,1 r;,00lt ill,.r., _ „,. , . ,111,1111,1,11 "i„,;! , -411 111 ••10,1r,',,, ,i r,' ' • , ' 1 MIK ,.if ill J 1•'' ,gi 4, -:IT.,,;[1; iii•1. [ 1 ' 1'11.' [J '.:ii -ri.'lira 4 111 i 2 l'.1 [I til•[i';',[ [ '[ ell111 BS . •[ , [ Ril [ ..r,,g, L„.- -tiir 1,Ip 1'N111 P ' ozn. Ng !, ', I : 11,. Kitaliooli'r',61 1 !i ,,: ,I. i .,),-.11,11i11,::,),1'„,. iFf-;iii- - :' ' '[A!!1'1:1rir'llrill'I IIIIIIIIIIii II Itl ,:[11[!1611‘ .... 10.1.!,1011k1 MI, --L,-„ ,,„2:,-,.:,,,,.,,', im,l' 1, „,..iv,„......t,„.4,,,,,..4K,:p.;,..,-,,,1„,, ,,L,,,,,,,,,,....„4er,...r,dviroiroppiropium7 -,•,-piliiiti.tiE11111}011-4.'•'' . . • • , Ilig41119iltiiSOIVIII• Mil' 1141114t151111141'f114111 I, ' 1,1-.1 ''•: 71:1-' 11011111111111111111=11411 l'' P,4'11',',11.'i''111,Aa4 j1.1, i 1 1. . -•. :-..1- -1-• IllinillpgiNiii ri, ' 131'11111111' '.• ... iltoltliplit ipliipp,1 im, lilt'Pl!,:, 1 ,,,i illEIMmat 001. 1141:$ i es.-11,1v. 1111111 iiiriTill :1111111 'I r 111111:1P11 rr 11[:'1 ''',r:err rr•:[[r.[[rr:r'r.r'[[,, 1111111111181i111111111 LI,11 [" 1 i L [ 51:0„,,,, 1 0 [ rommol IF NI ---11041,1[10 11011:11 ; ' ' '• ' !Il'' 7 gni c-_ , ...lpilill iliol IT i III 1,,!1, ( 2._ , 4itliii , li ,21 1-i7-..saAtiii. .4110 I En.fENZIO 114, ,1,1'' l 1[ 11. """g• imam Vigq NIIII i , ,,, on. lb,AI . -... •yy.I.11 111,10 1 1' I mil-ol,IliCrid It I 1 •, '1: riA winsfithe--- 11*44191iPilliv-A. $1iiii . villomi,11111.0,11!;5:,111,0 - I', I,1 Ili r• 1,07 •---mm....• 114011,11,t114 11,11111i I 1 ' ' I '1 -1111111MEIUMP1111.P5.111, I 11 1 1. fl ' 0,,,,,fige lilli,1111,110,,i1,1101,1,10.1,J,41 - 1 'II i 1' '• .. ' ' :. IMIMM-ririHIGMF (63E5[7_7=H=T1 1•1 1 II" 1 1 Len=;41-ra - i'gEfiE f 11 1 I l'i 11 :NE Inililililinillililirdiil , 111 I '1„ t '','1 ' • ' - '1 --- 1 PI' ' 1,,il 11 II, ., ,,,11, 11-=,,,,„,•,- 1>XL: _C1.--,_z, ,r-iiii 111,1 :: ..... Mi.ri-Furoi,iii,1 , i• . ,,, 1 - 7-''.---- --1 i'l' t_L, 1' ''lj {Es ggi eimarg Ill: , • . ,,, 1 053 "NG I riati;r4i61 1 , ,i i , - r.,.1., ,r, .... 0., , ill ' ' II1L iii '-------- - -:‘,.11'0,,i.,..;11115itiiiIP . 1 I • i i,t, 1,. I', „ ,., t-:',H it pilirili"11111 ' I 11 MIN I i 1 . ' Z d 1 1 iiiiii,iii,liiiiirrocAir 14-, ,. . . II '14 11.11 Ahl'iptiliitlifin'Vitirlikt10101:441i0114#1 1 1 1,14itTiViiltillir47111ildirirtillitieNCIPAgiiiii104 . Ittlidli iliiiithaNio+011,4111111, Ad 01,1000 41 etwoho,r,,, li I aill I IIP.I'l )41 '''' '' lillf v tvi Om Al$Itlittool 1,1141;11,11A1111114111,111,01,411s :El q4. lilt ,0111411 114411011 ftel$011044,14141111111b011144.1 1161111111111101101111,111101110. 11'III 41111111geillittifillillStillgaiiii . Alb! 8111.1 PRILAFIAIldhjOI?,.Edir411#615111* .11LIMA".--' '11111 lit Egz= II 8.,_ 1 .1., rjtils'Atini !4. ; E [Itimill - iii_. 1=11_111 t...).,,.; i LI I, c 1 I [ • =- ill 1=1MM S 1 • [ [ ' I 1 [ n OS 106 11 I-I-'÷[F1 II 1;4'4; = 6 i' I' , '1 . ' - kiNnisim , c , . ,'11 , - -, 1, it l'i .1, 17. . . , pihormoo , .h ' " ' . '' monliriaisigii -' i , ,:,i i ._ . , f r [1 1 ir 'rr[[ [ [ r[[rr r r II/IIII.1114 1 t - Two ,A ' •ri. 1 1 :LIM liMP—',111 1. -11111_11, .., 01 111111' '101,I MIZZLII 1110..0 inn=I. ., .4, 1 ' ) Ill', .,7 " .k 1b '1;, - 7 " li 1our =1 ..I' CO riegmall .i‘. 0 - i -- - 1 -..., - ,=.1.141,, .,im Hit: 1 ; 1 ' 0 ii #1 11 II li 11 ig r I;,-,1 R5 6 • p 1,§ 1 p it ii o= '7o 4LZL-S8Z-Z49'Xad 9LZL-99Z-Z1.9'Ial 4Zb99 NW 1au!P3 i6 w 2 o ¢ W a 014SS NW`sldj'la oils pj£4 3sOM Z£LZ anuany appwMOJB 0 lab i-2'_; x 'ONI S10311HO21V NOS21V1 dINVNH321 .... NOIIVAON32I 213NNV8 ,_oA&f t QI a z v ■ a NO113f1211SNO0 2101 ION � dI J —o- t ' _ '11 1-111 9At Mr" 1 / ' I ' 0; ;1 1 111 1, 1 11 , I IIR4 eIIsti 'ITi { irRiu Iri 11 tl � uII 1Ikx I HE 111711IE ( Ihl1,1111{ ?n ti— I. I1I I ii l ,1 1 l{ 111 (! 110 1 1 1 1112/A I1' I !,, aL 11 r A , _ 1-7-7-1 11„, tl p��II� a III �,I J Et(•1. 1,ri4'h It 1 r �! —_L_ M .11,1 Ii i � II gill .,„I 'c I� ' 1 III1lit!1 Iy 71L1. ► , ,� bk . !ill )il id 11E Z illi Lb' �� Nl �H � ., Ia.�I :: � t ■4t n lh7OI �' G i;i r } F Pal �JI p 4 } tul°j �I rt }i 4l r 1,11,1:1,11 , 1, 41 � i f tr i{ a '�—r-� ' MIEN SC :0 r II t.II ii It `i i L-1III 1, r 1.1 . ~ 1< f ri 7�q fiwkr ."'�r f > Ih ti i ¢ I l 1 i J., 'A Ju ,,, y i SII iy�,4r W A I�rG+��l��rlt '1 a r4h� tr. l?” r �.� w.- All"{!illt `I i�t i,:,e,.1I Y t I ki � Ltq { III. fI IIII I!I1 I III III _ �5 '11':k1'1411IIII "� i�1 ll I —'lam Lt:-.,f-11:-.1 t— or !III Il i1 IIl E� �i�� IR k z' I 7. _ ...� i it Yh atT 11 K't .L� z- �I i - t!1d r r..i n` ij°,I 41 i �p . u l=, 1 .f--r-I--I 0.1 ''I�'n III'I - >n i'l 119 1u 1VEiii ,',; U,: . -H,-' z a 1 1 1111 1 r111'111r'11,11��� 1 O a N- . .lid a° y w3 III'�° <' 1,,1 linit 1 ` 0 III,moi.i 1t �lili I N 11 4LZL-98Z-ZI.9'xed 9LZL-98Z-Z1,9'lel 4Z4SS NW'eu1P3 ! ! ! I =21 0t4S9 NW'WIN'1aaJl9 PME43sOM ZELZ enuany elepuMoi9 0194 W Z = '3N1 S10311H021V NOS21V1 dINVNH321 NOI1VAON321213Htl8 t" t 1 " ` o E NOIJOf1211SNOO 21Od iON [HI 1/ lima , 'it' �z ii JA - iilf� l' �ANN „ � ijriii'4 - SD MI c 'm�,r f n,s rt x 1 tion •J � :14`,•11,14,,••-,1L ',11,1, '” p �I I•� '„ ism 'TAlf T;"4x+15i�"�"+ori,,Y �Ii—_pI, • '„ � ' � �1 iii I e � i� � 1 ,. �® Aril 1 ' , 1 - : ',7, 1 r , . i Atiguali vim : J '•,® � .hit411111211111 9 in 'iI •im• 7.11=1411..., ®_ it �I _ , ' - —_ A .,. p t , , 7 , 1,,T.. ..., , 1,r,',4- , , , ‘,,,, ii i l' �h ' —I r Z I II I , w i. ill..., wt,_. r�/1�..����. o �I T , � f p x �/n9�� F 1„4,-,,.i,k, rpa tsxx 14 I lir14 ' I��: + I I 1 , I. �4 i ,q'`rti x,r� � Lk r� "r,,til t ,} t ,i 1" ' 1 h .x.0 �(i4w4 Is L 6,: �4� t-I ` t t ti. "� i t�, ��j .'_ a,I .���_Auuvi IN _- _ x; ,14; 14 ildpf W 11=111111111141011i\Ia�E i t tnw I 9 t i1In f j � K, ? II ; will; �i`3��,( �� I.� $y I , � 1 h,l ' 117.,...0.....70-12.7, i ..':4.-:,,, .': °l® -: y u . ,1e _ is eillit !1:+ -' lit d -,i h i',HiIlli 0 MAIM; ' 0i 1 11 1 i .11 i 1! 11 11111 i a e 3 N, t i e Y; III 1 EI i i1 ti Z oZ 6N 17LZL-59Z-Z1.9 9LZL-59Z-Z1.9'lel 17Z1755 NIN'eu!P3 E§o « ,9- E \ 011755 NW'sldW yaaJ;S PJ£173saM ZCLZ anuany alepumol8 01917 V"o='" ." I E 5 ~ g`- '9N1 S10311H0?JV NOSH 1 dWVNNH321 NOI1VAON321 213NV8 a a 1 << I N o WU a NOI10f1211SNO0 21Od ION i �I �F` t 1 ., . ._....._-: fx 1 1 I DI 3' 1 tillill' 111111 I 11 � ® � e II�I „I I _ .. • • 'I ki ® . , • H ' 11• , 1I ' I� II , _ 1 ;',1 I tom .�q -:4F- �, 1,,,, � 1 L . ii ' :i I - 1 Iii isti I ,i.._;_—, ii . 1 II :® 1l sooi I I�/I :� f®.� Or I I1 Z1 I _- _IIs G ' _ •1 If WWIS =' LI !!1I o ;1t 1-= i ,. + I : ImoI it -Ili' �9 _ 01 kO f p IIu lE r- I1n l - I II I F------- .1 solI I1 � i 111 1 11 1 o 4t rlIs fi mo I l,1 _� iII ( � II` " SEII II L Fil [ 1 -EH 1111', 111 III! e i � ' {i 'iilih II � I d1i ! i itll° liI, r r1111 ,: Ii I1' lily,II [,[r„,[1iriti "� r I�� �1t,I, d lil4 i I�I i{i411lV Si b . I!•II , lsil� ui1�w,u:Z14 u.. :r. ". r! — bIIMIl,k1 tli " 7ilPk' "iW.1 ,IIV III!" I x' 1 1III1, I t I V _ I I 1 , _ 1 I.h� r ! I°I i 11, t, l 11, lSIII1j, U III I I,II . � 111 I VI ,I 11 "1i4 IIS1,i' III, 1,,I 11 • ' i IIl � V 1lift 11111,1 IIg Il ll � �01,,,„, I111 II ,, ,• ; - ' I' I iI ' �I Ij IL, 1'`Li'I' I ` 1ut� II,,, lII1 Ih ih �' 1i' 1 I'! ,'1,1 z ,214LZL 582 ZI-9'xed SLZL S8Z ZL9'lel 42455 NW'eu!p3 `i o a w 01.499 NW's!dW';aaJ;S PJ£4 3saM ZELZ anuany alepuMoJ8 01.84 T Uo ; oe " ; E o ONI S10311HO V NOS211 dWy>H32 • NOI1VAON321 23) d8 r,15 g' ' • ywv � I � � ri' I .4gE 1 1a il 11 111 6 ® - ---v, a a ' NOI10f1211SNO0 210J 1ON ii II ,y' a� ba a1 y p w � Ilipiii 11 P3•-' wa . 8F,8":1'.6211Vo u ,I r I' r _ F + ,_ 1111Ie -Ta2iI . fli , 1I 1 ��!E11i ! I! smi 111:Nu a H3 1 I� �� •�! IISli �. ®®=i_ems: 0 i l,,�, BE, Juin 11!11 I -i 41- -� � Ii11 � II w, 1, ®runt IT.. � I �, I ®Iop • I itsi'.;M',i�lpll �I b 6' qx`X1111 ,0 ,11t,xu ` 1 ti 11 ll It I111il Ih81 1 1 II 1I�I f 1 11 �I di ill ! I 111' if rill I , 1 i 11), 11 Irk ILEI 1 �I r. 4LZL-S8Z-Z1.9 SLZL-S8Z-31.9'1e1 4Z499 NW'eu!P3 !HI! m ''�� R R < `— S 06499 NIN'sidil ye8l}S WE4 iseM Z£LZ . ;- enuenV elepuMaa 01.94 JSP - i ,-c4 < 11 '3N1 S10311H3 IV NOS2IV1 dWVNH32I NOIIVAON321213)IV9 1 g - i i NOI1Of1211SNO3 2104 ION t *tut 1 is rt 1§ !14 ttttt gt § g g 2 N - A^•C.8 .2 WI - II• j gy i' I 1 ! 1 � o e 1‘Z.,:=21-S- 1=7-7-11=1...___."I %r " ' 1111 W _ r \ W til d I s= i J u • ' r N 1 III I -- - Cl All, _ . ,— II F K y J ` „.., tillii II / II II _ a -: LIT } I k, Tir -� ... n ll�l2' II J iip 0 I1 I II n$ II8 I I t c I I'_._____ 1 1j'Li _ ❑ ® ❑ b¢ e k -� 1112 II� 11 ill F-F' A ' -'-'-'------- III SII r 114 t + o o r `A- I1 A I 't-I4 r n I 1t I I -- LI 11I I L u 1 "r— s bLZL S8Z ZL9'xej SLZL S8Z ZL9'la1 bZbSS NW'ewp3w c E m 0LbO9 NW's1dW'laa11S Mt 1SaM Z£LZ anuany aIepunna8 Ol9b lig 5; w- « m ' > 'ON1 S13311HOiIV NOS21V1 dVdVNH321 ■ NOILVAON321 213MV a"�a w <g a /, I U / / / NOIl3fR11SNOO WA ION fI ; / ) ---7/ _-- i II / 1 i f / � �/ /, / ,, L._ � i , , / , , , , , i , , , 1 , , ., , __ , i / i /i 1 1 I /a' , , ' r 905 i �;'� ;; % , / j II / /, i // / / )) //// / i t,-._ trA---,-- ,,,, , , ._ , : ,.1 IN -,-- .1 , [l u /r 11 1 I / I 10 'I ,"iIfi�. r/ II / I -�.ry 1 �� �, f I,- i I i , J — 1 I I - /•C25 j _... / , / '/ I 1i 1 ) / °`,° ..,_________ _ _ / / I I I I �� 1 e \// — J II �I' o� ,l II a . hi— 1 LL$g� .I) �J y x 711'1 I <— I�_ ,t' J,1/ m: , Imo— A I 1 \ — Q I�. - i I Iii i �' 11 t t-_ j HI 9�I - I I F Kit.-1-' II I- I II _ p . LLJJ RI \\ 3 1 � & - - - ® :39 Us \ o a am, ii -- ---'__‘j- Oz fes.. J //WAI _ 4 I i ...II /._ 111 III { r11, ._. J 0 ,L ®I Tr -- }4 W ft '- k '// \ ri 1I -- -- -1 , $ I I `II�- 4 II y I l'> 1 I I. n r- x I C' IRr _-, 1 ''II _I 6 P"`I ,'I j: m wK III I�.L i0 {1 N % Y F- .... I I CD 1 III orc� � W o II I 1,'„), \ U.1- — --II 'l l - a II L1,' 0 w,oj� CITY OF EDINA 4 4801 West 50th Street . `M �� Edina, MN 55424 •'' , ,,"°• www.edinamn.gov ,H.a Date: May 10, 2016 Agenda Item#:VI.B. To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type: Report and Recommendation From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner Item Activity: Subject: Changes to Certificate of Appropriateness -4602 Action Wooddale Avenue ACTION REQUESTED: Approve requested changes to the Certificate of Appropriateness for a new detached garage originally issued on March 10, 2015. INTRODUCTION: Plans for a new detached garage were approved with a Certificate of Appropriateness in March 2015. To date the garage has not been constructed, as they were awaiting completion of additions to the rear of the home. They are now ready to proceed with the new detached garage, but are requesting some changes to the originally approved plan. See attached staff report and supporting materials. ATTACHMENTS: 4602 Wooddale Ave.-Staff Report&Attachments 4602 Wooddale Ave.-Revised Carage Plans w� 1� HERITAGE PRESERVATION BOARD °44"9,241: 44:2,, ti o CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS ‘fruso. y STAFF REPORT 4roRAOFU�F'�• 1080 Originator Meeting Date Agenda#VI. A. 2. Joyce Repya May 10, 2016 H-16-2 Senior Planner APPLICANT: Mark & Deidre Palmer LOCATION: 4602 Wooddale Avenue PROPOSAL: Change to the Certificate of Appropriateness approved on March 10, 2015 RECOMMENDED ACTION: Approve the proposed changes to the issued Certificate of Appropriateness INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND: At the March 10, 2015, Heritage Preservation Board meeting, plans for a new detached garage were approved. The homeowner delayed construction of the new garage pending the outcome of additions made to the rear of the home. The work on the home is complete, and they would now like to proceed with construction of the new detached garage, with some changes. Details of the new detached garage plans approved in 2015 included: • 470 sq. ft. in area to accommodate lot coverage of proposed rear additions to the home; existing 1973 garage is 528 sq. ft. • Wall cladding - Wood pilasters, parged concrete base and smooth wood cement board to match additions made to the rear of the home • 14/12 hip roof to compliment the Norman Revival style of the home • Asphalt shingles in a color to complement the home's roof The homeowners are now requesting the following changes to the approved plans: • Increase size from 470 sq. ft. to 527 sq. ft. in area after realizing that the fear of exceeding lot coverage was not an issue • Mass of structure to remain the same - Heights at peak/mid-point/eave • Length of structure increased 2'10'; Width reduced 4.5" • Setback from side and rear lot lines to remain the same • Wall cladding to remain the same with the exception of adding a H-15-5 4602 Wooddale Avenue May 10, 2016 1'4" brick foundation around the perimeter on all elevations (brick salvaged from the rear additions to the home. • Maintain the 14/12 pitched roof- Slate roof if possible (dependent upon final budget) The revised plans provide for an attached garage that is no taller than the previously approved plan, and no larger than the existing garage. Furthermore, the addition of the brick foundation and potential slate roof will complement the architecture of the historic home. The intent of the revised garage design like the plan approved in March 2015 is to match the character of the 1937 home. STAFF RECOMMENDATION & FINDINGS: Staff recommends approval of the revised plans dated May 1, 2016, recognizing that the proposed changes do not change the previously approved project's compliance with the Country Club District's plan of treatment. Findings supporting the recommendation include: • The plans provided for changes to the approved plan clearly illustrate the scale and scope of the proposed project. • The new garage will match the character of the historic house and be compatible with it in size, scale, massing, and material. • The new garage will not be detrimental to the adjacent historic structures. • The information provided supporting the subject Certificate of Appropriateness meets the requirements of the Country Club District Plan of Treatment. Conditions for approval: • Subject to the plans presented and • Placement of a year built plaque on the exterior of the new detached garage Attachments: Revised Plans dated May 1, 2016 HPB Minutes - March 10, 2015 2 MINUTES Regular Meeting of the Edina Heritage Preservation Board Edina City Hall —Council Chambers Tuesday, March 10, 2015 7:00 p.m. I. CALL TO ORDER 7:00 P.M. II. ROLL CALL Answering roll call was Chair Weber and Members, Moore, McLellan, Sussman, Christiaansen, Birdman, Pearson and Student Member Otness. Absent were Members O'Brien, Kelly, and Student Member Druckman. Staff present was Senior Planner,Joyce Repya. 111. APPROVAL OF MEETING AGENDA Member Birdman moved to approve the meeting agenda. Member Moore seconded the motion. All voted aye. The motion carried. IV. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES February 10, 2015 Member Moore moved approval of the minutes from the February Ie meeting. Member McLellan seconded the motion. All voted aye. The motion carried. V. COMMUNITY COMMENT- None VI. REPORTS & RECOMMENDATIONS A. Certificates of Appropriateness I. H-I S-5 4602 Wooddale Avenue -A new detached garage Planner Repya explained that the subject property is located on the west side of the 4600 block of Wooddale Avenue.The existing home, a Norman Revival style constructed in 1937, currently has a 2-car detached garage located in the northwest corner of the rear yard. The COA request entails replacing the existing 528 square foot garage, built in 1973 with a new 470 square foot structure to remedy the substandard condition of the existing garage and allow for an expansion on the rear of the home. The proposed 2-car detached garage measures 23' x 20' 5 'A"feet in area. Access to the garage will be obtained on the east elevation from the existing driveway where two overhead doors with divided light windows above are proposed. A service door and windows are provided on the south elevation. The west/rear and north/side elevations lack architectural detailing because both sides abut a tall privacy fence. Ms. Repya pointed out that the design of the structure is proposed to complement the Norman Revival style of the home. Although the home is clad in brick, the product is no longer available, thus the proposed wood pilasters, parged concrete base and smooth wood cement board will match materials on the sunroom located on the rear of the home.Although the Edina Heritage Preservation Board Minutes March 10,2015 home has a slate roof, asphalt shingles in a color to complement the home's roof are proposed. The garage plans demonstrate height and massing that are consistent with the surrounding detached garages and new garages previously approved by the HPB through the COA process. Also, the proposed location of the garage is shown to be in compliance with the city's setback requirements. Ms. Repya added that preservation consultant Robert Vogel had evaluated the plans for the new detached garage and provided his comments pointing out that the proposal is consistent with the design review guidelines presented in the district plan of treatment. He also pointed out that the new garage will match the character of the historic house and be compatible with it in size, scale, massing,and material. It appears to be compatible with the character of the neighborhood and should not detract from the historic significance and integrity of the district as a whole. Ms. Repya concluded that staff agrees with Consultant Vogel's evaluation, noting that the detached garage is consistent with new garages previously reviewed in the district-thus, she recommended approval of the Certificate of Appropriateness request. Findings supporting the recommendation include: • The plans provided with subject request clearly illustrate the scale and scope of the proposed project. • The new garage will match the character of the historic house and be compatible with it in size, scale, massing, and material. • The new garage will not be detrimental to the adjacent historic structures. • The information provided supporting the subject Certificate of Appropriateness meets the requirements of the Country Club District Plan of Treatment. Conditions for approval: • Subject to the plans presented and placement of a year built plaque on the exterior of the new detached garage. Applicant Representative: None in attendance Board Member Questions/ Comments: Student Member Otness stated that he liked the proposed plan and believed that they did a good job of complementing the home. Member Sussman observed that the applicant indicated in their narrative that because the brick on the home is no longer available they opted to clad the proposed garage in a wood panel product, matching an addition on the rear of the home. He pointed out that, they wouldn't necessarily have to match the brick, but could have used a similar brick that complemented the home. That being said, Mr. Sussman stated that the plan was nicely done. 2 Edina Heritage Preservation Board Minutes March 10,2015 Member Christiaansen stated that she liked the plan, especially how they incorporated aesthetics from the home into the design. Public Comment: None Motion: Member Birdman moved approval of the Certification of Appropriateness for the new detached garage subject to the plans presented and a year built plaque be installed on the exterior of the garage. Member Moore seconded the motion. All voted aye. The motion carried. 2. H-I5-6 Country Club District Neighborhood - New area identification signs at 7 entrances Planner Repya explained that a committee entitled "Country Club Neighbors for Historic Preservation", comprised of Country Club District residents is proposing to install area identification signs reading"Country Club District/National Register of Historic Places"at the seven main entrances to the neighborhood. The proposed signs will be one-sided, facing the respective entrances, measuring not more than 18" x 24" for a total of 3 square feet each. They propose the signs to be mounted to the street light poles at each of the seven entrances. If approved, Edina's public works department has agreed to mount the signs on the light poles at no cost to the neighborhood. Because Edina's sign ordinance allows not more than one area identification sign per neighborhood, not to exceed 6 square feet in area and 6 feet in height, a variance from the sign ordinance will be required since the sign plan exceeds that which is allowed by the code. However, prior to pursuing the variance request, the Planning Commission asks that the HPB first provide approval of the plan through the COA process. Ms. Repya added that preservation consultant Robert Vogel had evaluated the subject request and observed that the district's plan of treatment does not address signage, and there is no evidence that entrance signage was included in Samuel Thorpe's original design of the district during its period of historical significance (1924-1944). However, the Secretary of the Interior's standards for rehabilitation are applicable in this case. Mr. Vogel pointed out that the proposed sign plan appears to be appropriate for a historic residential district and should be compatible with the character of the district. Furthermore, the distinguishing original qualities of the historic neighborhood will not be impaired by the signs. Ms. Repya also explained that relative to the standards for rehabilitation, installation of the signs will not destroy or obscure any significant historic architectural or landscape features -the design does not seek to create an earlier appearance; and furthermore they will have 3 ainpaimpio s 1 I€ £ t Z !i.I o Pl P i 4 e I s �— l¢ i 1 / 2. 9 / I. go! I 1N3W3DV1d3?J O HH a II!! }�° mg %'()i ''''.Z i , IP iii H $ i :>J nvd a ssib i! j g�M� (Eqg�t � ar tt4 Stp Ed 45'" Yep SeEgpq= saA W 1 aE Nom L 4 =- 1 l• m 63 o A H E +. z o � ag c� 'm R Utg � c o. ... m o � „ pp = N F3 Q f�f.TF,,,, 0 N 0 N•N nm O V G 41XON No3 0 =0 a� v E �, X+. R o m m v CJ p S€N�� Nm m ma 3; t'r' mN SZ m c o �a %g 3`'x�ve cNc??c" m' g .. .. n0 g8z o'r f yya � a E r'igAZ a63 u 0— c- 82 V ¢f 2 m -v E 4 pmp sm=€ia y Q em- N JfC -02. n 3 m m Q¢d m .O ._ St m �a m Em C n o c a a d v PIa�° @7yr `oa C �z� we.. � � Ty . .R2-12..� c6ir t9 m m p 33Viaro .Ug'Fa w > .� F:I t . va y v c a q V A1,0,"t .= aic�`gma� 0wozza00MwMw co t p $'-'L'2.-.7..N euzi S •C o c " E,2 w 48 G L .p m _mm o .0 w c o O A DJPe`qL 1 p 0 O O N p m O�N N e?<.n.0 NNa7< Q> . 2.VO.Wa N a CO it a_ 2 a ° <<<<<<< ¢aa¢aaaaaa�a CU L 0- 0 L 0- 11 ilgTgt Q 1 24 15 ? a a $r al gi 3 il g -lap., -1.7r, .� wm w U ii dill 11 b — — I � 0 it laq lislis i 1 .16 I . — 'c 11111 Au,-REE s al 82 TliR8m K2'222 5 2 ' 1 , U O X d RL £ m ?r N yyO `Y N I__ ' IO 0. ig 8101 Q m 1 2 fit .2 - �r.3.., '~ .r.l_ Y— 11.1 tf 3 > m DWI d 2 2 2 - I-I�i� c a mem m pm OMNI f,m r --'I CO oa nogi m 18 _a3 �? H gc_ Mn ill C t ff 1 '— E m m if�r _ Cla 1E5 58 lift Will k;ff U 'E'w -1 2 m Lira L ��11' -, {,-n,#'A, < li Sap-1- of`YY"0 010 . .._€ ~`I-` �b A� W mm V .Fl ic5:8:5I t8 gT $�� CC OCLI 1 li W NO wL mEY1:3Ymm €.aE..€m R= _ d� '113i i2. MMUMINI S= .M6 .025...is w sm cu m m m E l m d *2 13 1 Om Fl-032 "-55E- g,'�5 'QEgt2 a2 co .0 §.1.5 o.m1.3 Ea8stmoi 2' gw ��ag �m8E2 gR .62 � gg ampe4iy3Jo s ps> Z - I 1 ill ig 1g s s €IPE! € 1N3WJDVld3?J a § s O~ .,r g 1 Ili W k 30V2IVO d #. g 1.L tip $ilk` s z k N lir di 11Pi o ° a E6s " 4e { iik iilli ! 1aIi i a MILL' a ipp 1Ib H Liii ._ � I _-)- \ ` 16 --- 7 11 I I II I — u _ - l II I_--- — Lii — — — as ` � - _--------- I Il c. . ' — —_—__ II SZ I m .Z1 1 --------\--:—C-1_—_- 1 I n -4:. __`___—=_�z-- I 3 t .7: 1 11 Lift4 — —_ _ _ 3 ;1 1 cit ' — -- -r iiiii 2 NI , r . .sa lx/4 .o-a t B-8 rs, o...5 :. a§ am; eNam i i I€P 1 1 11g i t s iiii#11IkF& 1.11 1N3W3O`d1d321 b ii (Id lil gw . of i I§ !II w gel it I UI til \ \ 74— \ 1—_—__ ,r, N r =—C— —= _ + -- -----C > m v4, ,i, -1i .i- ,, y .i-B /4/ y iii-41',- 1n is ea e 4,9/ / 4-4 AL-RL 4-.BL eJryoaNDao € I lit' 1 �z _I 0- 2 f r s1N3WDDV1d321 a (Z 0 f''' 1 ® ffi �!Q € e f§1 bd .�$Ei.°$p 3 E �310V 2]�IV�JO J Z R _ ^I T i;n ¢ii gig! ff jipt R •2 A IVa 8O N H Q � #a i,:,, 4 zi¢i .ix a a Ra €�a$A /6 & CDw '$ tou, y1 a 1 �� ZgK EA :Ii 04 1 ,k 8g I , flit 3 I!] lII 4:• — \ \ ii-j-:,..-: ill 1 �; MI = z° Il —_ i = v __ ■■ — 0 ■■ - _ _ LL -1--------- ■ __—_—_ �� — 1,0v - — —rte ■ _ 0 ■ 1 I ■■ W —_--1—_' ■ m _ ■ - ■ — coE ■ J .11 _ _ ., 8 d W Um 1 k U I � g� ItA C I, IA, a, I, 38 Z OP 6l .0.91 It a' oinpaptplo i1s Z / >'- !V i qi i I t i i r I 5, - /, '11 ,- INON3DV1d321 ' * 1 0 di! 9iZ 30V8V0 A s IY ': 0 < 1111 2 a e . 4 z„- id di 1 I il ills -.:'1 i :eglAriVd Z LU— 0 I— < <> C\1 ill, Vii 'i 0 LJ a a ti.,i i , IT Ittlil' iii l' ,.- if Hill itil q g t W. 1 °2 W5 31,s h 5 gl h lh P q .TEOg :: I V iI ' hg pm pg a A . !g v. 4 Pt8 gg li ti§g iiiid EP ,ta Ofg 15 14 i01 a w,;, 51 gu i I I I / 3\ \ \ 11 I . Mill I iill Nil 41.• il• .111. --(-,. All 4 1 41-11 • 1 1 .43 1-n --,‘ —I. % — — —0. — 1 IN — . _ li EN _ IPA • NM _ ' • • 1 Elig I -o — • • -1- wro _ • .• IR1i _ • ell _,-- EV 1 " - • el - 01 gs V.1 EN ....- _- li mEil _— Vie cP. SNI _ II ________ ITO g 1 = # a ; rl m _ • ..• _.--- =W• 6.2..1 SW Pei ru" IN EN 1 -- — inTo" gill a,-E mil mon I.01 CO 'I mii —____ I =MN glit E 0 g$1 m NY 1 —7 III — en I 10 1 011 .,, iz b P < > • .98 1 SS / SI Se • <p <'. 0 aJnpa{lL Jo 11 1 i€l ; >wiz d i 1p 1 1 ` I ail lI 1N3WJDV1d321 z - b Oass • /� Z S4 af. 111 q ; tg. dA 30d21dJ a I - LY Q \\/ CO _ X13Wl`dd Q Q y 9y 55 fill �u ILI,e g VI I� P 3NI1 A1113d01id.133M 3>IIIN3 9NO1H 30N3d AOVAIl1d SAIOaH913N O 19 M M �- \ 7 t,o-t£ - / A- A ,Fo[-az A s = 11 11 / 1 11 I 1 1 1 I 1 I 1 I 1 1 1 = I 1 r 1 r \ I 1 I 1 qea I 1 kg r 1 I f 1 it I 1 N 1 1 Ec 0 tet) r 1 "' I 1 = Cu; N f 1 1 1 w 1 1 I 1 Z 1 1 r 1 I 1 1 1 r 11 1 ZG 1 1 r 1 LO 1 1 1 1 }ti 1 1 1 1 QZZ r 1 r 1 E'm f 1 r 1 cQ --7 r 1 I 1 u — '."'" E 5'-1k i : ..,_ —— — •i, 1 y ..o-.s /. I> _ snoMnaad /QZ �L I I 7 — ii111: I i --- -.'vtw1 —I I I L__J 1 I INN C _ 8 Z I °-o C 0,1 — I —L--I L_ r ,) 01 111 I 1 - - / — — —, I ainpailtiwo it >MZ 111 § z i i gt / ; i ! t, 1021 :1 IN3WD3V1d321 1-- 1.1 , i ce !..- AlliNz 1 0 il igi ° '. i4 :/, e. 01 cgis ---1 i 10 '; , it i .. 1 A < ill' 42 11: :":11t El:: ;'''' ii :Iliii i30V8V0 :egNiVci z <(X, !Mt il i'i It iiiiilt l_6.! -I W EnL. aim u _ 4-774-" .11 4.12 I° I t. k 1 ig ill _ r---is 1 n 11 n - - 1 r 4 i L' . L. , A 14-az 1 111Tf-- -11 3 I 0 ....-,- ••4 I 1 1 ! I h 1 i 7 I I I I I i I I I [ -- .—F I L__.•-=Li.w n n 7-011 1 ,---, ) \ / 414 WC)ODDAI F AVF .111poyiyZ).Ju ° PI @ s f sip£ �Z 41 . , ! . Q ._ 4 1NR\GOV1d321 z - 0 € �\ a 10g k[�il£ .x 9oveivJ a N01— tel 5; '�CZ �,i'� 0,-, .qa Ei eg ii1 nu ! ar X14 •O]YV1Vd 5 :!8° °3oVjrm3s3�ps�6p2110 1�2�s 9 0�"20 _� Q LII c7 �` 4A .e € b.h. a$§§ . : ?�3 _ a ,.sth 2ng z egg . z z i` zo I 0 • mO S oo N 'p -', ND OA-O OW _ m m C J I o .N 0°59'50"W 80.0 1-) \ ce O / -- wood privocy fence on line S",__ 7 1 Z r^ oU ��oT :ii inl, m Z o" 2Uo §-v P, 9iq ZaoW ›— .`;'EB- ili Lo W l N QU2Kp +` rl o w o 7 (/) ct' ` O D LL X969} \ 1.4:',::',.'.;,j,,:: : :::,:; t 1 7 �O/ z l / LZ ce i c o , D ZU j--) c±; Awl _> er m o i AIR i N) r:..i. ,s: (,3H te+- - CY Z G Ooo _ 4 co up W Z ' 8i - , 1 00 N ''=' ��, < 'LCD 0 14:-.-*:, t, N �� I I � µ.�Nm —S 0°01 40 W 80.0 — �� -I \cc' -- AC) -,....c,...,,,./..-„.; r- , r on 0 —i z D a WOOCOO- AV=\ U - �06 RAW) ` o w 0 eJnjoajty3Jo €, i $P 1 Z L J . I3 { : 1N3W3O`d1d321 x �� iil.,,; p f� a $B �i$ g 90b8d0 V k 9 --- OW �s ` Q a g - G 11 .ill •e2w1dd c,W Q �� Ill!' ;s¢ age 1 g i§g gga Lyi a . is £ 4 tug 3 i9i_Fi i1 5 i o _ !„e X31 18! g 'ie,,, Vt. To ,;i1--------- '`‘ 1 • _ ' x0. • f O T '• & Iii \L\\ 2:gli b b /, ?�¢c�i `F. t E6 U ".5'.-F.:a. K C b P. E N C ° k' S E - t�, Z• 2422 i,..;‘16' o lk b y x , Q a 4 '. ;,... -41 ...,, -r ! i ° M . ;., 22 2 T Jeigp , ,N ; II S � ~ gc0f1\ `� l!lit • ” : '.';' ' '1 „' % '\ ' a a .--#. j. 4ililtrill'.' CC E yy I ,fir ,..— • •� •W•.. -�Y sr-- ,;`+,,, ° „,:t"..;?. E 1 o .g L \' ..% y��, V s 'fi' E 1 ` AAA .vvqq 6 •n x, ti o , .