HomeMy WebLinkAbout2016 06-14 HPB Packet Regular Agenda
Heritage Preservation Board
City Of Edina, Minnesota
City Hall - Community Room
4801 West 50th Street Edina, MN 55424
Tuesday,June 14, 2016
7:00 PM
I. Call To Order
II. Roll Call
Ill. Approval Of Meeting Agenda
IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes
A. Heritage Preservation Board Minutes, May 10, 2016
V. Community Comment
During"Community Comment,"the Board/Commission will invite residents to share relevant
issues or concerns. Individuals must limit their comments to three minutes. The Chair may limit
the number of speakers on the same issue in the interest of time and topic. Generally speaking,
items that are elsewhere on tonight's agenda may not be addressed during Community Comment.
Individuals should not expect the Chair or Board/Commission Members to respond to their
comments tonight. Instead,the Board/Commission might refer the matter to staff for
consideration at a future meeting.
VI. Reports/Recommendations
A. Certificate of Appropriateness: 4601 Bruce Avenue
B. Certificate of Appropriateness: 4905 Arden Avenue
C. HPB Work Plans: 2016 & Proposed 2017
VII. Correspondence And Petitions
A. Edina Heritage Preservation in the News
VIII. Chair And Member Comments
IX. Staff Comments
X. Adjournment
The City of Edina wants all residents to be comfortable being part of the
public process. If you need assistance in the way of hearing amplification, an
interpreter, large-print documents or something else, please call 952-927-8861
72 hours in advance of the meeting.
x,r,„,%A= ,�, CITY OF EDINA
o 4801 West 50th Street
.
cn
t ' o Edina, MN 55424
''` Fltl.,�AKt"' www.edinamn.gov
6N
Date: June 14, 2016 Agenda Item#:IV.A.
To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type:
Minutes
From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner
Item Activity:
Subject: Heritage Preservation Board Minutes, May 10, 2016 Action
ACTION REQUESTED:
Approve the Minutes from the May 10, 2016 Heritage Preservation Board meeting.
INTRODUCTION:
Minutes are attached.
ATTACHMENTS:
Heritage Preservation Board Minutes,May 10,2016
Draft Minutes@
Approved Minutes❑
Approved Date:Click here to enter a date.
.,,,,c.)%1•4 \ Minutes
Go ►— City Of Edina, Minnesota
n Heritage Preservation Board
�• `"° �y Edina City Hall Community Room
May 10, 2016, at 7:00 p.m.
I. Call To Order
Chair Birdman called the meeting to order at 7:05 p.m.
II. Roll Call
Answering roll call were Chairman Birdman,Vice Chair Weber, and Members Moore, McLellan,
Nymo, and Student Members Puerzer and Otness.Absent were Members Christiaansen, Kelly, and
Pearson. Staff Liaison, Senior Planner Repya was also in attendance.
III. Approval Of Meeting Agenda
Motion was made by Moore and seconded by McLellan to approve the meeting agenda.All
voted aye. The motion carried.
IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes
Motion was made by Moore and seconded by Weber to approve the minutes from the April
12,2016 meeting.All voted aye. The motion carried.
V. Community Comment - None
VI. Reports/Recommendations
A. Changes to Certificate of Appropriateness -4610 Browndale Avenue originally issued 2-9-
2016
Planner Repya explained that at the February 9, 2016 meeting, a COA was issued for changes to
an attached street facing garage at 4610 Browndale Avenue. Now, the owner would like to make
the following changes to the plans:
1. Re-orienting the garage access to the north side yard
2. Eliminating the street facing garage doors
3. Maintaining the existing capacity for 3 car stalls, but negating a tandem situation
4. Matching materials and the details of the home as follows:
A. Option 1. Stucco and half-timbers to match character of existing home as well as dining
addition to the Southwest corner of house; or
B. Option 2. Brick and stone to match character of existing home, dependent upon availability
of matching brick. Original brick manufacturer is no longer in business.
Draft Minutes®
Approved Minutes❑
Approved Date:Click here to enter a date.
Repya concluded that both of the options new proposed for the attached garage on the north side of
the home, (identified as options #1 and #2), comply with the Country Club District's plan of treatment,
as did the plan originally plan approved on February 9, 2016;thus staff recommended approval of the
requested changes.The approval recommendation was subject to the revised plans dated April 29,
2016, and notifying City Staff of the decided upon final option #1 or#2.
Jean Rehkamp Larson, architect for the owners was available to address the proposed changes. Ms.
Rehkamp Larson pointed out that as proposed, the windows on street facing façade of the garages
differ for the two options with the two windows separated on option #1 (half timber&stucco) and
close together on option #2 (brick &stone). She added that if option #2 is chosen, she would like to
amend the proposed spacing of the two window as proposed in option #1; pointing out that while the
windows on the home are shown close together, by separating them on the garage, that space would
be articulated as a secondary structure to the home.
Motion was made by Weber and seconded by Moore to approve both options 1 and 2 (as
amended) of the proposal, with the applicant providing staff with the plans for final decided
upon option.All voted aye. The motion carried.
B. Changes to Certificate of Appropriateness -4602 Wooddale Avenue originally issued 3-10-
2015
Planner Repya explained that at the March 10, 2015, Heritage Preservation Board meeting, plans for a
new detached garage were approved. The homeowner delayed construction of the new garage pending
the outcome of additions made to the rear of the home. The work on the home is now complete, and
they would like to proceed with construction of the new detached garage, with some changes. The
proposed changes include:
1. Increasing size from 470 sq. ft. to 527 sq.ft. in area after realizing that the fear of
exceeding lot coverage was not an issue: length of structure increased 2'10';width reduced 4.5"
2. Adding a 1'4" brick foundation around the perimeter on all elevations (brick salvaged from
the rear additions to the home)
Repya added that the following elements of the original plan are proposed to stay the same:
3. Setback from side and rear lot lines
4. Wall cladding (with the exception of the additional 1'4" brick foundation)
5. 14/12 pitched roof- Slate roof if possible (dependent upon final budget)
6. mass of structure - Heights at peak/mid-point/eave
Repya concluded that staff recommends approval of the revised plans dated May 1, 2016, recognizing
that the proposed changes do not change the previously approved project's compliance with the
Country Club District's Plan of Treatment.
Draft Minutes®
Approved Minutes❑
Approved Date:Click here to enter a date.
Joy Martin, architect for the owners was present to address the proposed changes. She pointed out that
after researching the cost of a slate roof, it was deemed out of the budget;thus they will use asphalt
shingles to replicate the slate shingles on the home as originally proposed. She also explained that
sconce lanterns are also proposed to be installed on either side of the east facing garage door.
Motion was made by Moore and seconded by Nymo to approve the requested changes to the COA
originally approved on March 10, 2015, including the sconce lanterns proposed on either side of
the east facing garage door.All voted aye. The motion carried.
VII. Correspondence And Petitions - None
VIII. Chair And Member Comments - None
IX. Staff Comments
• Suggested the board consider preservation topics for the Advisors Blog
• Announced that a press release is forth coming announcing Preservation Month
• Invited board members to attend the May 17th City Council meeting when the 2016
Heritage Award will be presented to 5201 Wooddale Avenue; and the Public Hearing will
be held for the landmark designation of the Wooddale Bridge
X. Adjournment - 7:35 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Joyce/Repya'
9ii== 1-f4, CITY OF EDINA
o 4801 West 50th Street
�v ,,,,.5,. Edina, MN 55424
�'` ;0.,0 w wwedinamn.gov
Date: June 14, 2016 Agenda Item#:VLA.
To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type:
Report and Recommendation
From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner
Item Activity:
Subject: Certificate of Appropriateness:4601 Bruce Avenue Action
ACTION REQUESTED:
Approve the requested Certificate of Appropriateness to build a new 2-car detached garage in the rear yard.
INTRODUCTION:
The applicant is requesting to demolish an existing 2-car detached garage that was constructed in 1953, and
replace it with a new garage of the same size(484 sq. ft.), in the same location with access from the existing
driveway off of Bridge Street.
ATTACHMENTS:
4601 Bruce Avenue-COA Staff Report
4601 Bruce Avenue-Applicant Narrative
4601 Bruce Avenue-Garage Plans&Survey
4601 Bruce Avenue-Exis ting Garage Photos
Originator Meeting Date Agenda#VI. A.
Joyce Repya June 14, 2016 H-16-3
Senior Planner
APPLICANT: Fritz and Carol Arnason
LOCATION: 4601 Bruce Avenue
PROPOSAL: Construct a new 2-car detached garage in the rear yard
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA)
Request Subject to Conditions
INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND:
The Certificate of Appropriateness request entails demolition of the existing
1953, 484 sq. ft. detached garage and construction of a new garage in its place.
The proposed 2-car detached garage measures 22' x 22' feet in area. Access
will be obtained on the north elevation from the existing driveway off of Bridge
Street.
The home, built in 1927 is a Tudor Revival style clad with stucco. The existing
garage, built in 1953 with lap siding, and an asphalt shingle roof is in a
dilapidated state and in need of replacement. The applicant has provided photos
attached as Exhibits 1-5 to attest to the condition.
Plans for the proposed garage demonstrate a structure that is not unlike other
detached garages approved through the COA process in the neighborhood; with
heights to the peak of 15'4", to the mid-point of the gable of 11'10" and to the
eave line of 7'10". The cladding material is proposed to be 6" Nardi lap siding,
with aluminum soffit and fascia boards. A 7/12 roof pitch is proposed, and asphalt
shingles are proposed to match the roof of the house.
Attention to detail is provided on the north (front) and west (side) elevations.
However, the south and east walls do not include additional architectural
detailing because both elevations abut 6' high privacy fences.
PRESERVATION CONSULTANT ROBERT VOGEL'S COMMENTS:
The subject property is a two-story Tudor Revival style house built in 1927. The
house is not individually eligible for designation as an Edina Heritage Landmark
but is considered a contributing resource in the Country Club Historic District.
COA H-16-3
4601 Bruce Avenue
June 14, 2016
With respect to the new detached garage, the COA application describes a
building that is consistent with the design review guidelines presented in the
district plan of treatment. In my opinion, the proposed garage would be
compatible in size, scale, massing, and material with the historic character of the
house. It would not "match" the architectural style of the house. While the
district plan of treatment recommends that new detached garages "should match
the architectural style of the house...as well as the historic character of the
neighborhood," there is no such thing as a historically authentic Tudor style
garage. In my opinion, the proposed new garage reflects the 20th century
vernacular aesthetic represented by most of the garages built in the district
during its period of historical significance (1924-1944); it may not represent high-
style architecture, but it doesn't detract from the historic significance and integrity
of the neighborhood. Therefore, I recommend approval of the COA with the
usual conditions.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION & FINDINGS:
Staff concurs with Consultant Vogel's evaluation of the proposed plans for the
new detached garage, also recommending approval of the Certificate of
Appropriateness request.
Findings supporting the recommendation include:
• The plans provided with subject request clearly illustrate the scale and scope
of the proposed projects.
• The proposed detached garage is consistent in size, scale, massing, and
material with other new detached garages approved through the COA
process in the District.
• The proposed garage would not detract with the historic character of the
house.
• The information provided supporting the subject Certificate of
Appropriateness meets the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance and the
Country Club District Plan of Treatment.
Conditions for approval:
• The plans presented and
• Placement of a year built plaque on the exterior of the new detached garage.
Deadline for City Action: June 29, 2016
2
Heritage Preservation Board
c/o Planning Department
4801 West 50th Street
Edina MN 55424
To Whom It May Concern:
We would like to replace the detached garage on our property at 4601 Bruce
Avenue in Edina. The current garage is wood shingled,rotting and beyond repair.
The concrete of the garage floor has deteriorated and the driveway is cracked.
We are seeking approval to replace the garage.The planned garage will have the
same footprint and be built in the same position on the lot as the existing garage.
The design is simple and will compliment the house.The garage will be visible from
Bridge Avenue.
-The garage will be a simple square structure
-The roof pitch is 7/12
-Exterior finish will be James Hardie siding in a color that is similar to the
home
(home is stucco- current garage has wood siding)
-roof will be asphalt shingles to match the home
-Garage door will be white with carriage style windows,facing Bridge Ave
-Service door and window with divided lights will be on west side,facing the
house
-No doors or windows on east and south sides as they face one neighbor's
privacy fence and another neighbor's garage.
We think the current plans will compliment the existing home and be in keeping
with the neighborhood
Thank you for your consideration and please feel free to call with any questions.
Respectfully,
Carol and Fritz Arnason
952-926-2965
caafra@msn.com
Page 1 of 1
v4 *o ,r qr .r \ ,,, =1,11'
„ - err fi
AN 1
f„, b.kri, fir. . . ' ..� F(( j
A i
,ivi
14t
+y”'it ._ .MM� r,--i,T: Y }f. ';I f,r./.
1 F v ,i; t ' / '"-.. it 1
\\
spy t
A .w�'. a t ,4 ' M 1,},,,, ,„,-11,-_1`ILS' ��;41;4104i rf II p; v/ r, � t- a 'S t 1, . 1
i ,•LF" "t :X f i 1. ? may. I t, XI '7-• ..4'
t r 4 �I t
-.4.,---` , ti
•
f'-',,,,..
A,Y"p' "`j' ...4-%f° H,�,yw,y- `i,#1 ' .e�. *,t'.1-,:,
., 4, 1 ` : ,
x K' S • T .:,2,,,x, fi*'y
x'44 :1 a £ ii
'.:_. , 4
,y�
i ` /F1.�`IIk 11
} 1,. y .SAN..
L
i 11
s " I. asps ,. #
\ it ' 1 r ( ,1 —4 - :.., ..ro , °',
t
#
; - b '
, ,a"'- �� � ,k i. k. '� 8 , � E � }a sir t�•.-. ,�a- �` -
1-/—CoD 1 Zri,tce Avo •
file://ed-fsl.ci.edina.mn.us/citywide$/PDSImages/Photos/1802824120160001 jpg 5/25/2016
sZ
nHo oz �flz0 n °
o H g 7c
y
M i
` .,OI-,II 0 z - 1 �i
Q
OI'L
2O N
,,— v0 ,n- p- Wv
_ 33
QO vQ O� n0 �Tz,¢� a e
c � E'' aTQANO �3z3�3 3 s
20 Off- -'- ��.zo ,,kn''� E s e
O a n
ra30 �O , � SilDE p xPV�H _EON¢ N 111
p 1-1- •.0)- 9,\S 7fl < In
z Z p Q
sv
in CA
dff O a g �¢ OOH �SV
z as
N HO 10•N S S,n
cl x QnS <- \Sv Oz
O z 0 v 7 z �� O ,- 0
�ppI � n_z0 909, L v
iiSL ii ;o kn
o �Zb'9OI'ZO9d'�Jld'I WMANOd 7NIQfl'I0NId z.� 1FP9IH11MXbW.ZIHOl dP 6
il
N_ I}
1
t l U
.z arl
g nz ,n ,v "4:/ 4-
fl
v o
S N Pz.[ `S y il a
S QE n., O $ zv, A
k¢ 80.s z v & flo •r
g �H Ph
It M
co
'0 VS 'i g 2 Q 2 - � 5`\' pal bh
n .7, i220 e_ d Z ,o N,�12 Immt �
ga ft aqy Q z- (L El--,4
2 g i Q ga 2a� 4 ',-0,t1jb3 §,Pg IITI i O '^ �� .
2 `F,a ai0 �nx 3 �o c »�'' t1-1 V� �I1 �M
i �� '� zz _ o'a2 11= o
1Wz `moi e ; � ,;, g i' II'�II N 7
\\\//ff '`?
_MEI I
n/ \\\\
_M=.11=
Z�111-111-F
II
1OL-J 1L6iT
= lI
, °
y=O
o l'i
il: 17- I
11
'I 'A
m
/ YI c
sE- I,• Ll v,o4, Mt Lz5 dvfl ,T,.0
o58
I '14
IIT- � c U�9
4gi II�-'�I�IL'S
�
cC iEA ° cy
a
oaEE`
< 41 I ,ICm
i c
E s` o
'O'.0'S C Z
C "PA C C
F,
3>e1 >
z as
3 3 cn
G
R (/J
it ti
s
1 '! 11 I a
ate'
R
1y so A
z
�P at oN
i,
Epp
< Z k
E � 's P e
Q 3 2
ci oo ❑
0.
b‘1
ii P
O
N
�c
C
h
fli -ec
A Ii
o, , y
Q; E
•i
t 1//--!Ill
A w
e
J
z
U
9
11 I 11 y a 17:1•11
•
•
r "
G�
m
o o
o
z_ �g
II Oo '^ `V
Q
S : 1
ciDe
I U
W
® 0
® D �0D 4
1 ® D VD 0 °'
4 55'2 °°n
e
III� III 12 ocEEy
9 0 Q i'� c'L
kd u u 2'p G
;BA T. u
“',2v
r
` ,,o-.ZZ ' W-'
0. a,
` ,O-II " �,O-,II ' : 3 y
eC o 4 Y
\/ Q A
Y 11
I A
fl
Pr 0
G G 44
ctt
- - - ONzNz 4o A
NDN A
111 1-61
Q =9Z NUN
n
n Z K ,nQ 2 6 - =
,n O 1L �
1 �L�2- Z a I E
zi c-2, 0 N .
I ° - � p\ ,, <I �F „ N aoo
O �N x �0� N N �u �C`DZ 2z ON oce.
z S
N S z X x Z e N
O
N 6 N OQN_� ZN L a[a
1 MI N
v �]O'J�aofl Cv
Z2 i � 'a
N fl �
O
WG n Y. .N
d N
Sr P
V R c
U a
o
• ew
a
s W
C2
g
X c
O
o
,33
Tr
oazNi
•, 1
wvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvwvvv\vvwv�vvvwwvvvvvvvvvv�wvvvvvvovvvvwvvvvvvvvv��\vwvvvy wvvvvv =n -
a
O Noa NW - t,1�
oz
o
Z O*Z Z ^^,, y b
lIN w zz
v c 03 ° ° ` o`E , Q eo
�11 � O
o OT ���fl 3p �- rn� 7r
o ho x,09 = o ° �, V�
' sn,, S. v
L't� o `9 N Z ° =w L:
O `-O § v�, gt.
O# ° 0�2 O
- ,c)1- E , ° a O C — C
▪9
L
V
\n - ^ Ot—W. oss
11:111L o
AA\\\\VAAVA\VA\\VAA\\AAVAVA\V,,,,,V\VAVAVAAAVV\VA\AAAAA\VA\VA.. ..V AAVA\\\\VAVAVA\VA�\VA\VAAA\VAVA\AA\AVVV\VVAV\\ V V - e c a
• uii c'fl
_= c
3 >,2.
m °
?-
as
w COmw
V I
.f-.F
LL LL LL LL LL 11 1 , N 00.00'33" WLL om.1-- Yr x
-°
4.1
50.28NN0N d o l� ih 2
Nw N O Xa N V N �'� oz \s
com
17„../
�_ ti o
E i
/Z74.1....."..,
0z ¢ 3.3210NO3 �0'ZZ \.. lgBYozQf 1 L'688 nWa , _ w ❑
1-1
t- m o I I J
W 0 m
w H ) T W o
o¢W W ~ a 00 / �/ /�� j .mQry w ❑
sono
a
K
1 W MI-%�X W to
LLLi-rt-_t- F ''''''''1—
m l o
LL LL LL LL LL W LL F ��55 N
a ^ ¢S O�
.......oN C'/ " �• m'y,, ; m� W 6 Nj r,'0 °� �
,.�nv�N c0 v' N l ^ )1100TK99Z 4m � M Q
¢ Nva N n m m — as o� \oat to m '�
W ,— N �`1 ) B
1 ( \ Day
q 11� z.Z\ PX8¢
I ( I �• H
2U' Sg I ni \ E
U' ¢ 88 1 \. o I1� -\ t 611 ggs 3
1 31 �i \ m
N J} N JLs_ U �It�naa rc
w 3 m 3 w W O J I I
Clm m °
1, co8
N Q>C7 Y I--1=- < < U5Z ) r ) m U
n¢....Uo¢ 't- ¢ 3 lice o 1-2
Z5
oaswwmo o a
.0=za LLz t- ,iii I \ o `a
\\ n 0 "t:$� `ral
mat
t —
\�` \� x - r-s'o \ h
K�� — \-50.23 l --�` ..L
4' N‘R0'25'03" W xwo see
(Y
m
z w
ai
N 0q q
p oW
N V
❑
Q
O
o
(% 3 • ° ,sY U h o - C.OGC o - -- C
bO 2o O .0 TN20 00 °i '' y O O'G
° U i,, ; 5 5 WG .O N 7Y o@ t,.6-=, y P
3 ° b0' ^ 0 0 0 1 n. y - 0 3 2 o '':N x it
o0 0 • T .E 4 . '^ '.$-' or v >,2 u _ s S
m b o .a mo o bo ti a'x m 2o ; ow ❑s a v ru o 6r'` a so .R m •' oOm 'r ''° sc ubevi N or? y N o 60.-2 ,,y ° . N7 ❑ z
Q.z 0 � > o ` ❑34
' R ° WZ.9. — n ? ' -0 ,;',.,-.=.
,3.y. 8 F c o 0 " o
a
O > CA O y L y N '' ° N ",4'y N O y U T 3 ,,.N W
V F N . yN.a y oE'y E -1 °Ya ❑ av O Y.d..o-o.E <., n . c 9oo. .5 8 o o
ck ' EU.; m o o aa m co @
= , ro ' w v` w. .j . -- v � .45o
G . -8 ro HA -a 5,b0 N yc A-24 5 " N 82 y O U. C O 0 o v v p Ao.-,,,i o co ) Q0 0 0 �L
`42
0
� O °o _
•y 6 •�'yva.0 o , vv ? '�°1
0❑o 3 E 8'-__ o' ,, >0 yw
n
❑
U, COVti.5 ,° 5 ooY e h ,9,-0 y;, m,2 66 00000c E 000 o
m
n l''
U 3.❑ oo Ep y tib.w vEcy_t°0o0E �.E ° `° S hwm.e Py o
Q r 0 0 3 8 m o b " ❑ a•ti.Y Y ,,- o0oo3 . o „ j� u
d o
C7 °c 0 v o_ a E._v 3 n E[a o v a m« w oo r o N O O N U 0 o
W o 0 0
',� K ice'' ^ y+,.,` kj
,
1,7
. L'''''...agr'' '4, -04r7,,
,,
, ,, :,, .
f .. $t ,
. :.:
., .. ,
1 -,.• fit- ,,.:-.:7..,:„ „:„.....,..,..,,-„,,!.,..,,„,,„..,,,, ... .. ,,... ,,, :
. . . ..
,,,:,,,,,,,t L.L.:,:.:;:-...;17:„.„::,, ,,. 4 1 -. 1, 1', , 4 .1, _ r
1 444 h.
s
l £.
.:„„.,-.. '.‘i.- All,
s
�. 9
.E :4. ALS'...:°!'!'::::i .gp f' :
-k-
, .. N. — ,l,, w
,,,,,,„:z.,..„,...,,,,,,..4
x
L• ! _,,, „A.,:,.,.. ,„. - a �'
ad 44- i•
", -'. *s. a a- c ,„0.',,',1-i.,,L:' p{, + ;
. 'his, 3 k cap �'e, x
Y
�, ,4 _) t is ply a `
L ji
Tv
,! a A
a, a. e M
L t. , pggp.
L.2e {
i''''''' ' ' ...:'''.(;:.;;., I ' 1 i ,t
,:.,.,,,,,
rx
$i
1 °
r
[� is
a.
i
3 Y
z���
, ,
� 4t- ,
: { a � .
h �
i
Er' - -
t.,_ 1 ,. , .., p, 4
ai
,
3�t�. t �., �
i
, . • is, ,
�'�z-A7i9F"
i'.k2tim ' aArH''�
•
., '
...
1
.
i
'•••••„;•',,,,e.,'•40,:,t
t ,,�
I
4
S
-' •
.,
y
r
.
{
p r _
y.. 5 sf ,"
is
q.•
d
x�.
.A;.:, 1'''" )1-'
10
v,,"
yr ass
s"5 -
„v
{
{
{ � 3
a i
P
r}Gr ,'y by \
I
,
_ ry
Ili IrR i. #. " .. _ _ ;P: 6. `a-i).4 �4+ fes.'.•
!L J t
,t
'
S,
j
itIt
•
� el
n _
will,yy s
:':
,,,,;,,,,i1,01
4
w y
iJ1{ �
i,`
" r
a,.
, '= t
ill
1' ..t, `
o
� r , ^
bwY #z, j k . F "
a
ntt
zs.'
4
'-'; ' „. .4. ' ...„ it -
i.
r u. a
f
°r �a
.W
-4...,- ,if - a
s
'4.- I i ;:l l''' 10 ) " ), ,,,, ,itt
.1 t , .,,. 1 . 1 .. . _. .,.,
: 1 -,1 A., # - i t 4 •
4 € r �� r
111
P
h
I ! it4 3
VP I
A #i a r; .. :,..-,
t
J I 43 r',..4,' 4 •
a
,,, 3 4 4 ' \ \ t25
r
drt t .
stn
f
i F
VI
1
..".•.',V-
. . i �'�" r `.
r 1
t
� t y
U.
, ��
yak 4 p" ,
q
•
}
!
V V t. . ' , ,.az."44
fa" ,
'14),„ n
Y
F
F
,r •
7F
r
1 r 'T
y
a
- ..,i* r M {
r,ar - .. r p yty," " °y alk *, 4 «'' .r
, L <,
L -� *ft "4 eft k ,.: .
,� t 4, 40 '0 "4
4
� . .
,I
_ e _
I ! — Jo n , , "
w
—
ra , . '
4
lilt T. ., . . .. .. „
.
wi'
. ' .`
& + i
r. t ;�
I r .
', e
a , Li ,,
y
r v "iy �° s "' '� " "r`7
fie
ii
•
qq a•
+, r' z <.
}
,'�t
r ' � .
c a s car ,
,
s, M r
y.
.+..' �Ru w "� rod, a" Fr f }
ws , ,a
d s!+f pt k # k • i1
995f'•� M., lit ' ,..,,t, MF
*. a
�6'� •, m�`:,'',``'� �. �° • , M '....::-..t., �, _'_'�. s ^q ^a T w.� ''Y 7`v�.
•4 -V 1, tt;
� s` �'yIC�.; ,,,,',"S'..•
` ` ..•ti �
•
��,• 4 i" Y ak. .,,,,:t.-.4'
* a$ i , a k a* r
LI.
• V '.-s-
,;(4•-•-**-
R
�.. i+ # �..,,,,-.. .1,!;;::.•;.,,,.,,.......,;-.H-40;..
"-�' s arra .}` ,
i fly 0-,1:10'-'4
.$� -''-•
y°�„� av� ::'q;a , * !� '�,.
0
A-•,,,,.',
:. •. � 'fi 7 ' T'r"�' .:fie
`
n at r
a x
{ ,4, a ,may 9§p : x+' S
s= d
t : " , �"
9: 11,x,, CITY OF EDINA
o 1m ` 4801 West 50th Street
cntNv `e 4,) Edina, MN 55424
•",,,,,nY3 ,° www.edinamn.gov
Date: June 14, 2016 Agenda Item#:VI.B.
To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type:
Report and Recommendation
From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner
Item Activity:
Subject: Certificate of Appropriateness:4905 Arden Avenue Action
ACTION REQUESTED:
Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness request for a new detached garage at 4905 Arden Avenue.
INTRODUCTION:
The applicant is requesting to demolish an existing 440 sq. ft. 2-car detached garage, constructed in 1983, and
replace it with a new 484 sq. ft. structure in relatively the same location; accessed by the existing driveway on the
south side of the property.
ATTACHMENTS:
4905 Arden Avenue-Staff Report
4905 Arden Avenue-Applicant Narrative
4905 Arden Avenue-New Garage Plans
Originator Meeting Date Agenda #VI. B.
Joyce Repya June 14, 2016 H-16-4
Senior Planner
APPLICANT: John & Erin Schultz
LOCATION: 4905 Arden Avenue
PROPOSAL: Construct a new 2-car detached garage in the southeast
corner of the rear yard
RECOMMENDED ACTION: Approve the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA)
Request Subject to Conditions
INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND:
The Certificate of Appropriateness request entails demolition of the existing
1983, 440 sq. ft. detached garage and construction of a new garage in
approximately the same location. The proposed 2-car detached garage
measures 22' x 22' or 484 square feet in area. Access will be obtained from the
existing driveway on the south side of the property.
The home, built in 1929 is a Tudor Revival style clad with stucco. Plans for the
proposed garage demonstrate a structure that compliments the architectural style
of the home; with a heights to peak of 18', to the mid-point of the gable of 13.5'
and to the eave line of 8'. The plans also call for stucco cladding with limestone
accents on either side of the overhead door to compliment the home, and the
north side elevation includes a service door and double six-over-six paned
windows. A 9/12 roof pitch is proposed, and asphalt shingles are proposed to
match the roof of the house.
Architectural detailing is provided on the west (front) and north (side) elevations.
However, the south and east walls do not include additional architectural
detailing because both elevations abut 6' high privacy fences. The lack of
detailing on exterior walls abutting privacy fences is common to new detached
garages that have been approved through the COA process.
PRESERVATION CONSULTANT ROBERT VOGEL'S COMMENTS:
The subject property is a two-story Tudor Revival style house built in 1929. It
represents a good example of 1920s suburban architecture in the Tudor mode
and appears to be in a good state of preservation. The existing detached
garage, which according to building permit records was built in 1983, is not a
historic resource. While the house itself is not individually eligible for designation
COA H-16-4
4905 Arden Avenue
June 14, 2016
as an Edina Heritage Landmark, it has been evaluated as a contributing property
within the Country Club Heritage Landmark District and is therefore considered a
heritage preservation resource.
With respect to the new detached garage, the COA application describes a
building that is consistent with the design review guidelines presented in the
district plan of treatment. The proposed new construction will match the
character of the historic house. In my opinion, it is compatible with the existing
house in size, scale, massing, and material and will also be visually compatible
with the character of the surrounding neighborhood. Therefore, I recommend
approval of the COA with the usual conditions.
STAFF RECOMMENDATION & FINDINGS:
Staff is in agreement with Consultant Vogel's evaluation of the proposed plans
for the new detached garage, also recommending approval of the Certificate of
Appropriateness request.
Findings supporting the recommendation include:
• The plans provided with subject request clearly illustrate the scale and scope
of the proposed projects.
• The proposed detached garage would be compatible in size, scale, massing,
and material with the historic character of the house.
• The information provided supporting the subject Certificate of
Appropriateness meets the requirements of the Zoning Ordinance and the
Country Club District Plan of Treatment.
Conditions for approval:
• The plans presented and
• Placement of a year built plaque on the exterior of the new detached garage.
Deadline for City Action: June 29, 2016
2
John and Erin Schultz
4905 Arden Avenue
New Garage
We completed an addition to our house this past winter and have planned since that time to eventually
tear down the existing garage and rebuild a new one that matches the style of the house on largely the
same location. To be specific,we will move the garage back one to two feet and to the south two to
three feet. We plan to build a 22x22 garage in place of the 22x20 existing garage.
Our driveway was significantly removed during the remodeling of our house. We plan to pour a new
concrete driveway to extend from the existing concrete driveway that ends halfway along the south
property line. Overall the total surface area of the driveway will decrease.
The current garage has never matched the style of the home. Our intention is to build a similarly-sized
garage to match the style and gable of the current home. We intend to add several windows including
at least one to the front facing side of the garage. This window will match the curved window in the
front of the house. We will also rotate the pitch of the garage to slope north/south versus east/west.
We are increasing the pitch of the roof to allow for a small standing attack space for storage. We do not
plan to finish the interior of the garage with drywall nor do we plan to make the attic space a livable
area. The east and south sides of the garage exterior will have minimal decoration other than textured
stucco to match the house. These sides of the garage are currently bordering the neighbors'fence lines
which extend nearly 6'from the ground.
We currently have three large silver maple trees in the backyard all of which are not covered by the
recent tree regulations in the city. Regardless,we do not plan to cut any of them down and will take all
precautions to preserve the root system and trunks. We have consulted an arborist who helped provide
guidance to us and the planning.
All materials on the exterior of the house will be an exact match to the house colors,trim,shingles and
door styles.
Thank you!
John, Erin,Jack,Andrew and George Schultz
Page 1 of 1
4 ,..:., fig=
4Via, # 9 " • ,1 A #
t
' ,A44'7'1„," -,, , 1 ,'s kk'* i 41',1 r . ,. t i
_ 410
iik- . es't :. ., ' - — ''' k
viii •As'ir
) , , :-.., , , „,., ,.
.n
,,* '.' : .,. , tk,, „pi, „\ iii. ,.., s 2,— - -
a
1.
v‘ ;'r 4p : '-''
l
fid
ki,.
.---
+610 S Ard en A v2 .
i
1
file://ed-fsl.ci.edina.mn.us/citywide$/PDSlmages/Photos/1802824130117001 jpg 5/27/2016
AI
1HOH 'M 044 O '1H9H 21000
„L-,1/ / „O l-,9
O
J _ O _
In Nw _I
C) 2 ¢ 0 4
�A
w C, w b
•
rn
CV/
_CZ O
'--. /E- =
Q
I
LL, W
N ,
O
Z= v)
O W
c,w .-
=S
H U
N I-
I-
-:c
.m 7
N \J {Ai/
F
LIIII -IN 11
= _
CA 1-1
w
ZN
w
U Z
Q
C3
Z W
O
To W U
Q rn �� w
O p,
w m w
VZ GG N W'VNia3
w • z _g m' 'll-I O Q te ¢ Lo CLio LI_.y 0 4, 3nN3Ay N3aay S06b
a
.
rygz 'eanz FUI
zI- r- . ; . L.. i- OgSgEo4owUFwa $ g "Ili! a =o WW 1 4 N o = t�= oa ud (<1 as �� o wgogoZl1nHOS NHor8 NI83 z o 112.
C`V
E.
asv5N W
307NfSlafwHSD3Ls =''o cn_
xwa .0 swa oaa
�q p.e
�'L !:, 5s_ k
V i.d .d d
(13
),,,,,,_=, '''. 1.1.11111011111:
, 14/111 IRILIIII
ii mu
,1 il
a)
41II!
CD
•
11 ��I,id15" LLI
,'T's�dS el;'
91011 A.m,!ON ximx eau
.Ll 9-sI + 0 ,�in 9-s. �1} �-
iox and aan/MOW �• ewa and oon �• 7
.VI o-AI F/I 0-X
Wx 9
d 3 d P.: W
01
1.1
\
#a p 1::
g1 EE
rg
=' O
0 II 0•
II
z cn
17.
d iox-SI 4Y ooa \Ills;:,i, a 1/19101..10 �• .7/I clod a�ooa •d0
~
lit 9-SI
.)ll 9-51
'lanaalad a09/3co O /1000
,t/o-AI .h/I a-AI
z o 1Z NW`VNia3 Y
• a
ImN1�1_ w a 2v a �o rn W 2`-'
w y m 3f1N3/�V NBa v SO617
al I,J0 U Z m g.u W%n_rte- 'a!q A,��5" € Z c ZI.1f1H�S NHOr�8 Nlii3 Z o FyJ
\\— ` W ?N @J g., QQ 0145,i Q 3 S N �J
IIh U F N EW ¢ JW 3`JVrJtl�W01Sf1� w _
Q =W �� a 5 6 *iy r w 33N3C11S3y o(n
do m- N g € p,.,I, N u S
!i,61-1_''A oN 8�Ne g .oefio� w ZJT[IIHO ic
13 .B,9 5_.,,
td id
�•I
i'r'4-I
111.1.1
._
_......,
(_,
..)
1 l ' V..)
)I!� t
", ul�11
o
�CCr�S
�a and
wx,xeacsoon
u
J,SI,..,,,,./..
.va-av
..„,,,."./...
.-v/iyay-.-91
7 'iwx 1Wel.,,non
N WI 9-,n
s
gd c*g
and
11 1
�'. I O
-, .'
CD
1
•
COo
w9n 1 � _.
�ax.9
cCS
n ; d
9w1.1 xwx aoaa41)
f a � o zz 17Z-1755 NW'vNla3
311NEAV N3a2y SO6b
cr
85
N,1�' 0)31,7.; aN Oa Nm u ie qiF Ili i c O Qi r- R 4 gg�vk
I
= UF • s_ 0 € €%1ei w
iii a o r ZmN go4 ¢ds ~ r o _ sf Z1lnHaS NHOf Q NIi3 a
w
1 g
3ON34ISLFo3Jvave O1sno w wm=
717IC1HOS x
L
4)
/ ,o-,zz / „0-,L
/
3N11 Al2i3dOdd 1SV3
3'o.o-z®I
_
s3ssn?ll 300H '
30V60LS 0111V
N
Om
M
NZp r 7c-C-1
I o I o— w Iz
(noo h g > Ow to o `UII WL ]
ii
O lire.
O
o
N
co
< J2' '0N00
2,9x01,£ Q_
a�
L I
T " J •
� - „____ill a3
H33NN3A 3NOIS 2O 'H'0 O,L X O,LI H33NN3A _NOLs
(AJI000)YW3B 76„4l-Z CZ Ii
CD
/ LX:5
0 ,ll „0-,ll
I e
/
(____)w
- ..
VZ�55 NW`VNIQ3'1 ,w W o � G w
0 ¢QNN ro F (0 . € c m'1- 1 7d m, w } :sB N- i U wF N "a� �On O=tx :i: eIwIIII a W °r " W 4 w
nsp `i 3nNAy N34a1 90617 S
•
wZL1nHDS NHOf Nla3 0 -
a " W
A0vays woisno _
30N34[S3H y a m
d a 63 ''d w o 8 i a ,1 wLs W
,00'00=,Nn A1a0cCad 1SV3 III
' )
_m\
`,n NOV813S 3Ona•0 DIVA W8,0-,£ /
- Im z 1
O-'-o is a
dHC7r'i IA
2 u) o i i la
e
OZ , o I (O I"
.1w ca cu E.wl
D eL000 w3 w
d0 CO cn 03
[] ,— �CDWCCD3
F.
oa
�aa m�JO
WdN x � CO
v) v) no 000
CL-.
_r I LL
wa�� cn<e
pm7 [S) I-f 0
W(nO n QQQQ r +--+� W
w d.)
0 3 i c
D 3 ,„
o
_ 0
o y -p xH
Z e xi -
aNac k
L
r - -
W m w 2
�=x
x O
zUI. I W=�� JY
CD
QI
R � Up
T .314 AO 1.1r£'Ala3d0ad S63OVf00H (1)^'1 j I I 6308130 133a1S I N3314138SON]31VNIXOaddtl CD
) 1i.1 D Z } ,0'60'A1a3d0ad 16330£00 Mai,0-,0£
(-^7 L v 361 i0 530tlJtli 1NOai 361
A v r` �LLIN N33)4130 10310N�7%0addtl - _ 11.... -
'X
< wV <� o1 COCD
00
W O w 2.=3Nn Ala3dOad 1536
I 615663015 0605103
U U) Z oZ
UW U w .d'w
anuany uapay
'g:t.'4.
EE 11'E A
- z„
E„ �:
_` ane°
gif
4' oE,^g b :1;,,�' c�-.
II - _m < QEe .% a Aa&EE olu�i
LL/ / ( �c c ;i-IF
�ef!'; _ - S Om ..c0
z \i,c 6-I- o
N L .., z° o I S �¢
1 m k c _F i . y 3 0
H1nOS
O
El
Wa
m 011
OA
U1� 0 cJ \ g;c.l 3 3 cJ
O O _J_IL
H H 6 1 S
H-H 0 F II .. z �., F
Q Q N Li-. J .I-
EE
- R
a
-e +''-;T S • — P g
aHlaonl , s Iko�x ina F
CI a n 1 5e%▪ _ gosCC LL 3
dgYB 1..--
E
3 cl 3 A V N3 a d 9 1 j aolss z
=g8 g
Q1 e„
NdI a o-- y
Ed
N m
0
CITY OF EDINA
0 t �� 4801 West 50th Street
�0 Edina, MN 55424
•``tt,„1„ ,v` www.edinamn.gov
Date: June 14, 2016 Agenda Item#:VI.C.
To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type:
Report and Recommendation
From:
Item Activity:
Subject: HPB Work Plans:2016& Proposed 2017 Discussion
ACTION REQUESTED:
Discussion
INTRODUCTION:
Evaluate the progress made on the 2016 work plan initiatives; and begin planning for the proposed 2017 work
plan due to the City Council on September 23, 2016.
ATTACHMENTS:
2016 HPB Work Plan
2016 HPB Calendar
2017 Work Plan Template
Ln
0
N
' l t. al
• N Vf
P m a ami aEi
U
P3yo�j ° o
Fs o C
17)
J U J (� o
a a 3
4);;, U
fh >. -a L o
p Al0 co L u0 U
I•+ C
1.71 CD
cc c
of 'iQ r( C a ty 3 0 'L 3 4-
cu
U
Crcu
a
cc E
L (Q E _U L L a a
'a Q > p p �O + >
L1 0. O �� 0 VI O
L 0 p MI cu - L
Cr v 3 O O0_ oD - 3 Q
•
CU N <t *E � N a 3 Q
cc E' -Q 4- 0 CO C 3 4- a vi
i 3 f0 `� o_ p (6 c >-
C it � � @J = dU of Q ��
Q_ cn O U
3 3 vii 0 ISO3
y.. L C CE u C
4-
l0 (6 E +-+ (6
a
(% C) a U U S -a
v .� a •L
OA 3 CO 3
13
3 a 0 3 a 0
L/ m 0: z m Q: Z
-o
R i••' L
O a O o
m -0a
C m cac 0 °)
O 0. Z.
:F+ a E E
m U u°
I=
-
RI
C 3 a �o a to
p L. 4'd L d.d r-I
W ato
(o m
CD
0 W 0
L. cu
- Q O
Ci. 13Li0 E >-
Hu° a
CO a CU
> > CTS ? a' °
�+ > U CU
RI 1
R a , to > C (o ( > C 0 (o
L.
2 �= C ++ U oL
_ 474 W c4 a O W (0 a a 3
•• to C !'' 3 O O C Y 3 .a C Vf
++ 7 C f6 C o (o p O u 4
O L c p c 3 'C c? C7 = :7D:Ecu°c
'� O +� C7 C a o C onLaQc +,1A d Cp CQZ u O Z u 0oLo Z u O v Q ❑ ® ❑ cu N ❑ ® ❑ ovE 3 ❑ ® ❑ =• Y (aUC
(O L LE, 8 O C L L
0 C O1 0 o o a O. L > Q
V C 0 a 2 0 a t a
a-i l0 N p[ N `� Q: m a s CC
a aJ H a a *' Y fil
L
13 > m 0.)
(n > m v- CD H a a) O O� H
47,
to a a a
RI P'1 (0 to _-, Op f�_0 oCD OA !2
7.0x,_ O> ca bD
CCI N oz a` o (_° a` c as a`
5-1
0
N
1114�,�c, 4--1
L
01
C c c c E
a v� a a a a
aE C O E O E o f O d
O
v, v, £ cnE v, E ,n p
Oa s a s O CD c
J U J U J U J U J O
C
3
'a C -0 -0 "O 13 C
O
'� a) C m '3 a '3 = = a s '3h.
o o 2O :N S E E S U
a c n a) 3 a 3 C) +' .4., 0)
Cr E a o cc o c -Q E
L ,n L
i E a Q L a L •�+ ++ L E L a
O O p ,,, O L CU
+� O c .-40 0 0 >
0. ua. a) a a. _o O. c ,, a a. a) `° Q :S.:.1
N E 3 cn o 3 N o L �' c N E 3 N a
44, ca 0 +�
, CcE v o
Ct.) ‘,1 Y
It LA .Y
4.4
n > = o V) > u �3j a CU t- >- =
13 13
ti/3 SiD 3 a 00 3 b.0 3 43
3 W O 3 a O 3 QS 0 3 QJ 0 3
CO CC Z 1:13 CC Z m OC Z CO CC Z CO
C C C C C
O 0 0 0 0
a).471 .471 CU Com) G) a}')
E E E E E
U a
tO 0 0 0 U
.,..' 0 y., C a+ O +d ++
a)
5tin.. •.L 12.04-•a) o 013 CU >. LM � � 2.4
f6 Q f6 ca c VO ca CO A co O co
H p < )- p 0 H p 2 H In N F-
m as 3t o o
47,
> a '5 L > a •U a > a •E > a m
> > n > -a a —
ro '+.. ° 0 c +� o c 2 a c m 4' v c
RS 'CS oA co
A 'a O co 'Cs tiA .a ca., ca 'a .a ca •> co
+' C E nn RS : c ca •j ++ 3 c tao : 3 c ••L c 2
C O E of6n > L c O c�a c O O • c c 'p a s c
O c L ca > *' +, C = N 3
> c U u a h a 3 • l? . 3 'c l7 oa
a O c N O > a 0• c •� a) 0 C cu :E a) o C c a a)
Z u Oa) +' a s Z u O m c Z u O t +-' Z u O +' E Z
Lao
❑ ® ❑ c � cc .. ® ❑ ❑ cc-LI ® ❑ ❑ oY ® ❑ ❑ cEl
u
+, O 3 � coa
O L a O
4"atiD0 ao OL E ca O O
Q a ' a '- 0-o a +' ac a
o �, co c
a
a ` L 01 Ln o = o aC C ns cac Y Ce CO
m
a C a V, to a) -91-', co Li) a) C of a L o of a
++ O 3 -C4-� :
Ln
0
N
Lri
'I
'a5
4-, y _o
E
a a
to a.)
o
U >. +n
c c .= s C
= us =
a s a) L •o a E to .. U
L) ; a) a U
N U O +' > t .0
L
Q
U U C y'' — a) , >
n C L C • .- O a L.o
_cl
0 3 a o 3 0 en C C m a
N c O '13 Q
L `
In O U j, � L-+ a "VI So
c
Cali E ° o �° E .3
co
L E c '''' Y
f6 O U [6
E o . 'c —LA g -.y
OL
c vi E ra G
a a
(I)
'Li as YCU3 a) E >. a
a) O L O Q O o to)
.3 E U C
L � m7 � i co 4c
a L
CI) O O 9 :'- cm a) tU C!
GC Z h0 `� . C >a) ,,Ca6.4
Lel CU 44
O > O
C Q L m a O co , (A a
Ca +no � p v of
C {/
44.1•
4.CU CU a Qba
a Q "
CU r 0..c C
(17
4 1••
*
a o c"O o E
73
`u._ wo_ 3 LC 5 44 "L O E U C C
.1-• U a . a s R cn �
_ac..)
';..
E Ta. co
CO
0 ON -0C o 0 0 m U 0 p`„ *,
co O a
O comoL •v GaO a } 4 N
_ .-
a Q t M Q 4 C
O �+ O- C C a 0
Q CU a) OO
= i-, U (a U, Q
C> a oo C CO c u 8
+' > a
0
a - b.!) O L Oi
0ai c6 ++ j a a • x o '7, -0 +, p U, .
'rcC at) ^ c a a) va w a CO t VI
. +' fp OOI. on �I -0 a a
_ECa4=L CN ' Oaa++ O a t N
tl°
CU op
C L-Q. _ O a 2 ( L 'a c Ot �3 (oaO cC 17 a ,7 3 v U pi' ( c o o = c
4,
U O w O c = Y + Qv W03 ro
= > 4 2 03 v' 0
a li C �.;C c 0 '-II D. 0 n v C L 4-. C
C —a o0 t i 0 Z 06 C
E aj .� Q. > O '- a —' .c a 3 ° E
� u Y C E
L Y L,) Q CC CD
2 a 'a) Z = ` O
+� C 11- vi oA U c C ro a U
C 2 4c —
CD
L E a c i c W V) O +V+ L i O U
+aCO ) p w GC Lu c O U a t '-I 0 3
0. a 2 L a i C OC a. NI U NI MI *'' 0 L O
D -O O_ -0 a 0 O N Cl. 8
EDINA HERITAGE PRESERVATION BOARD
2016
WORK PLAN CALENDAR
January 12, 2016
Interviews for Appointment of New Board Members
Recognition of Departing Board Members
February 9, 2016 - Annual Meeting
Election of Officers
2016 Heritage Award Nomination -Advertise
City of Edina Recognition Event- Monday, February 29th, Braemar Club House
March 8, 2016
Evaluate Process for Requiring a Certificate of Appropriateness
New Board Members—Orientation & Introductions
Review of Potential Heritage Award Candidates
April 12, 2016
Approval of Heritage Award Winner
Plan for Preservation Month Recognition Activities
Wooddale Bridge EHL Designation - Planning Commission Presentation -Wednesday, April 13th
May 10, 2016 — Preservation Month
Proclamation "May— Preservation Month" — May 3rd Council Meeting
Presentation of Heritage Award by City Council — May 17th Council Meeting
Wooddale Bridge EHL Designation Public Hearing - City Council - May 17trl Council Meeting
Announcement of Heritage Award Winner in press and on website
June 14, 2016
2016 Work Plan Evaluation
2017 Work Plan Proposal - Planning (due 9/23/16)
July 12, 2016
Summer Tour- Date & Destination TBD
August 8, 2016 (MONDAY)
2017 Work Plan Proposal - Planning
1
September 13, 2016
2016-2017 Student Members Orientation & Introductions
2017 Work Plan Proposal - Finalize for Submittal on 9/23/16
Plan for September 20th City Council Work Session
MN Historic Preservation Annual Conference— Hastings, September 8th & 9th
September 20th City Council Work Session - 6:15 p.m.
October 10, 2016 (MONDAY) - Televised Meeting
MN Historic Preservation Conference Report
November 7, 2016 (MONDAY)
Plan for the televised December meeting
December 13, 2016
HPB Mission and Goals
Review Accomplished 2016 work plan
January 2017
February 2017
2013 Heritage Award —Advertise for Nominations
Routine Business Items
*Resident Proposals requiring HPB approval, including Certificates of Appropriateness and
designation as an Edina Heritage Landmark
*Community Comment— opportunity for residents to share new issues or concerns
*Updates from Planning Staff and Consultant on Initiatives & Grants
2
CI \m
� o.� m
P G' CU
L X CU
L X a) X•
''q'p �� a a a 0) °0)
�/ CU a)L N L L
cc c
L O a) L c a) L c a)
-c 0 0 0 0 o O 0 0 O
O. to i-+ 0. VI i+ 0. V1 ++
3 o 0. ,T, a) 0. r a) o. a
J a) J a) 0 J a)
o
Q N L N 4--. 9-
Ca .4-.y., U (6 I U_
O c (% c/7 U Q U N N U
ra
c
U ra
O -10 L '0 L '0 L
.> L a) Y CU aj a) .a%
L O L c , cL C
c 0- 3 •3 c a) •3 c a)
co ca a) Cr o o Cr o o Cr o 0
CU � v CD 4
Y O +� CC (a v = ra 'co:CC C cu
L L c [6 ++ J a) � J a) i•+ J a)
LI, > a.) Ti, 0 c V X c 4- U X U X
p c0 cn U m U app --1"(75
U 4
> a) c Q
a) •• cco
L L O E c c c
C U _N >. L 0 L 0 L
o
O▪ > EO `. 0. a) t. a) 0. a)
c co c +a E o E o E o
a, o ca o a o a o a)
> F.C pO C. O U L U L ! U L
L in > 4., a) 4-, a) +., a)
ici m .a ;a m a) t a) -c y -c
F:" c o m " X u 4"")
• @ u X
c H 0 (.) H O U i— 0 V a�
C �;, '> O c
y= 3 c a) 00 >
0 2 0 co co E
.> > >
7)
c c c
0 0 0
-0 Q 0. Q
a) UIn
L a) a) a)
RI S as as CO
V a) C C C
L .5 x
E A° L on al DC on
a) ii CO C � C ++ C
0 k- 0 +- 0
0 0 ° _ ° ❑ X ❑ . ❑
Y�
0 [a [6 > L O > L a) >
U a � C m CD E U to,. C m E 0 , c m E
•• 3 O (., , aJ
,� E ❑ ae o
CU v aJ a) aJ a) 0,- a) ❑ a v ;,c? k ; a ❑ a)
a0 p L Mz - a0 7 L +{ CIO 7
.Q L ate-, ❑. s_ C co U co L c c .. E L c
N O 3 O N Z N C Y #i Z N C Y ,4 2 s N c
'� c p0 V ❑ O v U ..WY C i.k ' ❑ p v U U . ❑ p d
p U U U
c • C .v a E v .,_,
(Q cam.) = 0 c ❑ C ii1 Ey c ❑ L iA `,E w- c ❑ L
`UI 0 coc0 a) c )co L 0 l > c ac) 0 'C zO > c
Q _ 5 . J U ❑ m a) E N 0 . U ❑ a) E ,,:0. U ❑ 6 a)
V C a) cu 4= ° E ;00 a! +,- o E bn a) +; o
"CI +a')
Q a c p a) c a1 O (43 C1,E .` aJ c a) p (p°,..�.' CU c
I_ ^ c c t c a) +' t a) 3
•Y ° 7, Z Y IUI z DO 7, Z Y 0 0 CIS Z
U *cc E ❑ u ,u 0. , E ❑ u :7 L� ' a c Elu
CO N * *
01
T5
0
a) CUa)
L X 4-:. >
a a
cu
L +J
a) tY
c
c
i a) i a) •
U
CC
Q O O Q O o a)
Q. •F3 a) Q. •� a) -c5(n J a) •J Q) m
4- 4-
Y t 4- a)
U L
/1 U U 03
4-
C
(6
!
L L _
L L
C C 0
3 N 3 N
a. 0 0 0
CU '1, +, C) +,
(13
re (6 a) a) -s_.
CG U U LE
4--i
O
0
ai
L.
� Q
a)
C C n
Q. a) Q. a) cB . —
E 0 E 4O a UCU
CU
U v V
4) CU 0 U
OA O Y -;01
UA O Y
F— U r°J+ H C U °, o a
C > O
0
0-
C
1-
4-,
0
0-
_0 i
U
CP v >-
0.
C CLa
Q L
O o ..Co a)
a) a) a)
v F
LID
own
-1:3
a
cc
C
L a)
X ., a) C
CC
c) ID
0
tau •,•
c C
tll
C)El
0
cu U m
ro
C _�y 1Y.�
a) «�.. ':,Q aJ ❑ a) a▪/ ;r-riY.`., al ❑ a) a) 0et 44
L L
Lo C t.1 C N U C
f6 E f6 N a) E a)
(n N +� + t c Y a) O
0i ❑ 8 x _U ❑ U 0! O
a) E c. C ❑ 'e L c0 .—
(/) s C
> a) O t O
CU U
E N fZ. CO �.N O ; ro y f�.' ++ 4 E
E oa , 0. o E ax) '."' to
o o E °'C di• O C p
(� C0 co ' to L U . 0 Yl L U C a) Y
L.a s L O
0
03 0
to N a) (5 h N N Lvi
o . ' o a, c °' a3, o °' 0. c
i,..0:,•=14---,,,.41%, CITY OF EDINA
0 t % 4801 West 50th Street
co
V�. - . Ay Edina, MN 55424
`''`,..)..^•, www.edinamn.gov
IN BAA
Date: June 14, 2016 Agenda Item#:VILA.
To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type:
Other
From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner
Item Activity:
Subject: Edina Heritage Preservation in the News Information
ACTION REQUESTED:
None
INTRODUCTION:
Wooddale Bridge Designation-June 5, 2016 Sun Current
Edina Heritage Award Progam-June 2016 Edina Magazine
ATTACHMENTS:
Wooddale Bridge Landmark Designation-Sun Current 6-5-2016
Edina Heritage Award Program-Edina Magazine,June 2016
A bridge to history I Page 1 of 3
Community&People
A bridge to history
Published June 5,2016 at 1:18 pm
By Ethan Groothius
Y rt
x 1
.,:.-.....-7,1-_-;.f_
.. r^ °""' :.&,T.x' .:.. .. $ .m _7,
..?,%"tar „w Y -r-,,,,.,..tr..,- - ...
-'—...dire` , .. w.+ .w. .�.Z +�sw .�ex+r.,....
# � «:..
v
1 s,i. g.
Crossing Minnehaha Creek in Edina just became even more monumental.
The city council voted to give the Wooddale Bridge an Edina Heritage Landmark Designation.
The process began in 2008 when the Heritage Preservation Board added the Wooddale Bridge to
the list of Edina properties eligible for Edina Heritage Landmark Designation.
The bridge was built in 1937 as part of the Works Progress Administration,a federal relief
program that put people to work during the Great Depression.The city provided the materials,
and the federal government provided the labor.It not only employed people who were out of
work,but it helped give work to expert,local stonemasons.
http://current.mnsun.com/2016/06105/a-bridge-to-history/ 6/9/2016
A bridge to history I Page 2 of 3
A bridge to history I Page 2 of 3
It was built using a special Platteville Limestone that both crumbles easily and is no longer
available,but gives it and neighboring St.Stephen's Church a very distinctive look that has since
been mirrored throughout Edina.
In 2014,the Minnesota Historical Society included the bridge in a study of 140 bridges in the state
to be considered for the National Register of Historic Places.In February,it was officially added.
While the National Register is an important distinction,it requires the use of local governments
to actually repair and maintain the sites they deem of historic value.
As part of the 2016 work plan,the preservation board brought the request to designate it as a
local landmark.Giving the bridge that designation makes it more expensive to repair but also
gives the city more opportunities to capture grants.
Any work done in the future would be in tandem with city engineers. Engineering Director Chad
Millner said every year the city conducts evaluations on its bridges and said that the Wooddale
Bridge is structurally sufficient,but some of the design and aesthetic elements are crumbling.
"Every time you do something to a bridge,it is expensive,"Millner said,adding that a lot of extra
engineering goes into matching the historic nature of a landmark."We will continue to look for
grant money in the future."
The bridge is not in immediate need of repair,Millner added.
Because the Platteville Limestone is no longer available,the city would need to preserve any
future work to the bridge with a different but similar limestone.
Councilmember Ann Swenson noted that any preservation would make it look how it did
originally,not how it currently looks like with crumbling facade.
Councilmember Mary Brindle asked if a future bike lane is possible on the bridge if it is deemed
historic.A landmark bridge is allowed to be expanded,but with bank stabilization and additional
materials,it would be expensive.
The council voted all in favor for the historical designation.
The George W.Baird House,Cahill School,Country Club Historic District,Jonathan Taylor
Grimes House and the Minnehaha Grange Hall are the other items in Edina that are listed on the
National Register of Historic Places.
Filed Under:edina
S1! _ URRENT
http://current.mnsun.com/2016/06/05/a-bridge-to-history/ 6/9/2016
1
AROUND
TOWN
r r�, AWARD
r `� " r Heirlooms
" The Edina Heritage Award
�; ,.• �,. t r,� honors Edina's history.
, .,2 At I .
i t �, I Y # .
h 2*' ' • Y I. Edina is full of rich history.In
' `st3: f �1 '� 4! } '�; "• } • charge of recognizing and
�"' preserving that history is the
101. ?, * {.�= , i � `" i Edina Heritage Preservation
1? is t Board.In 2003,the board
decided to keep citizens
‘,411L aware of the community's
'j' preservation efforts with
,) , — ,. , .y; •
the Edina Heritage Award.
r; sf ,_,--!1 I ,L,-• -, `-1°° ' f Since then,members of the
y •' `� ; �« ','14:. r 4 ��- , t Edina community and oth-
ers have annually nominated
l' /, =, ,44-14. $E -w' ;.*-"' ,F r r • : area spaces,and the board
4.,�i,w. 1 i ir'"A � 1 :, c••'� `4'fi ,V,r' rr _i'" « has selected two churches,
A
' ',' ,;..; t five private homes and
;',_ - { _ seven community points
F ,` & of interest for recogni-
1* -_ ,,,•)4,,4, tion.Senior planner Joyce
�b
- _ ' , / x� Repya believes this award
R
r ' ' is important because"it
spurs a conversation about
` the importance of heritage
preservations and assists the
te..- • board on sites we might not
' know about."Past winners
"• .., include Southdale Center in
_ . ,''! t ' 2013,The Convention Grille
• �+�. in 2012 and the Morningside
Savory 0-7rd,th WO,
sinner of the 2015 Edina ," 1 neighborhood in 2005,
11entag PI0,P ',itic(1recognizing their centen-
Aw,rd -, ti• ' ' nial year.This award has
c • also acted as a precursor
to receiving landmark sta-
OUTDOORS tus,as was the case for the
Edina Theater sign.—RG
Take a Walk
New and upcoming options for summer walking. a i
Read about past and present m
winners at edinamn.gov on z
0
the Heritage Preservation a
SOME STUDIES SHOW that walking can there is an expanded version available to pur- Board page, 6
provide some of the same health benefits as run- chase from Google Play or iTunes. w
ning,without the intense stress on your joints Though there are many great places to walk in
and respiratory system.Check out this phone Edina,there will soon be one to top them all.The
app and trail information that will keep walking Nine Mile Creek Regional Trail will link popular
in Edina fresh and exdting. area hot spots such as Edina High School,Creek o
MapMyWalk for Android and iOS devices Valley Elementary and the Edina Promenade. LL
allows users to find trails or create routes of their This trail will be completed over the next two
own,track activity and meals,and share progress years,and will be well worth the wait as it will V
with friends.You can even connect the app to surely make for a more versatile and interesting $
your existing workout hardware like your Fitbit walk around Edina.edinamn.gov o
or other activity trackers.The app is free,but —Rebekah Gregorich E
12/JUNE 2016