The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About2016 08-08 HPB Packet Regular Agenda Heritage Preservation Board City Of Edina, Minnesota Wooddale Park Shelter 4500 West 50th Street Edina, MN 55424 Monday, August 8, 2016 6:30 PM I. Call To Order II. Roll Call III. Approval Of Meeting Agenda IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes A. Heritage Preservation Board Minutes,July 12, 2016 V. Community Comment During"Community Comment,"the Board/Commission will invite residents to share relevant issues or concerns. Individuals must limit their comments to three minutes. The Chair may limit the number of speakers on the same issue in the interest of time and topic. Generally speaking, items that are elsewhere on tonight agenda may not be addressed during Community Comment. Individuals should not expect the Chair or Board/Commission Members to respond to their comments tonight. Instead,the Board/Commission might refer the matter to staff for consideration at a future meeting. VI. Reports/Recommendations A. Summer Tour-Country Club District-West VII. Correspondence And Petitions VIII. Chair And Member Comments IX. Staff Comments X. Adjournment The City of Edina wants all residents to be comfortable being part of the public process. If you need assistance in the way of hearing amplification, an interpreter, large-print documents or something else, please call 952-927-8861 72 hours in advance of the meeting. .4;91141;r1, CITY OF EDINA 0 t4801 West 50th Street ,, '',`� ytT\ Edina, MN 55424 v "`Y'uf„ K'° www.edinamn.gov Date: August 8, 2016 Agenda Item#:IV.A. To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type: Minutes From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner Item Activity: Subject: Heritage Preservation Board Minutes, July 12, 2016 Action ACTION REQUESTED: Approve the minutes from the July 12, 2016 meeting INTRODUCTION: July 12, 2016 minutes are attached ATTACHMENTS: Heritage Preservation Board Minutes,July 12,2016 Draft Minutes® Approved Minutes❑ Approved Date:Click here to enter a date. �v•— *41 Minutes ~ ?, City Of Edina, Minnesota 'n Heritage Preservation Board . UM �' �N Edina City Hall Community Room July 12, 2016 at 7:00 p.m. I. Call To Order: Chair Birdman called the meeting to order at 7:00 p.m. II. Roll Call: Answering rollcall were Chair Birdman and Members Moore, Christiaansen, McLellan, Kelly, Nymo, Pearson, Loving, and Student Member Puerzer.Absent were Member Sussman and Student Member Otness. Staff Liaison, Senior Planner Joyce Repya and Preservation Consultant Robert Vogel were also in attendance. IA. Approval Of Meeting Agenda: Motion was made by Moore and seconded by McLellan to approve the meeting agenda. All voted aye.The motion carried. IV. Approval Of Meeting Minutes: Motion was made by Kelly and seconded by McLellan to approve the minutes from the June 14, 2016 meeting.All voted aye.The motion carried. V. Community Comment: None VI. Reports/Recommendations: A. Certificate of Appropriateness: 4229 Country Club Road - New Entry&Addition Planner Repya explained that the proposed Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) application is comprised of two-parts, including the addition of a 24 square foot front entry portico; and additions to the rear of the home that are visible from Wooddale Avenue which is the side street. The proposed 24 square foot front entry canopy requires a COA because it is a structural change to the street facing façade of the home. The new portico is designed to provide protection from the elements at the front entry; and is proportional to the front façade of the home measuring approximately 3.5 feet by 6.75 feet. The design of the portico is consistent with those previously approved for Colonial Revival homes in the district with an arched gable front, two - 10" supporting posts and asphalt shingles to match the house. Draft Minutes Approved Minutes❑ Approved Date:Click here to enter a date. The proposed additions to the rear of the home include three components: 1. A single stall tandem garage/laundry& mud room on the west side 2. A 2-story addition - 1st floor family room/2nd floor guest bedroom/bath 3. A single story pass-thru from the living room to the dining room on the east side. The design of the additions is compatible with the existing home including the 8" smooth cedar lap siding, Marvin double hung windows,window trim, shutters, as well as asphalt shingles to match the existing home. Repya concluded that because the proposed exterior alterations and additions will not destroy important details and the loss of historic fabric will be minimal, approval of the COA is recommended subject to the plans presented dated June 24, 2016. Applicant representative: Mark A.Jones,Jones &Company for owners Sandra & Sylvain Lesenfants Motion was made by Moore and seconded by Christiaansen to approve the COA for the new front entry portico, and additions to the rear of the home visible from the side street, subject to the plans presented dated June 26, 2016.All voted aye.The motion carried. B. Certificate of Appropriateness: 4621 Browndale Avenue - Change to Plan Planner Repya reminded the board that on November 9, 2015 a COA was approved for a new detached garage on the subject property. Now, as they are under construction, the homeowner has requested the following changes to the plan: 1. Remove a roof-top dormer on the front elevation, and the dormer's window relocated to the upper level of the south elevation. 2. Replace the limestone window trim proposed with wood/painted trim (except the front elevation where the limestone trim will remain). Planner Repya recommended approval of the revised plan noting that the changes cited would not alter the architectural integrity of the new detached garage. Applicant representative:Jon Linde, Refined Remodeling for Jason &Josie Tabor Motion was made by Kelly and seconded by Nymo to approve the proposed changes to the previously approved detached garage.All voted Aye.The motion carried. C. Sketch Plan Review:4608 Casco Avenue Draft Minutes® Approved Minutes❑ Approved Date:Click here to enter a date. Planner Repya explained that the existing home at 4608 Casco Avenue is a 1977 Contemporary style.A new owner is interested in demolishing the home and constructing a new one. Because the home was constructed after the district's period of significance (1924-1944), it is not classified as an historic resource,thus it may be demolished; however plans for the replacement home must meet the criteria of the district's plan of treatment and receive a Certificate of Appropriateness. Currently,the concept for a replacement home has been created; and feedback from the HPB is requested prior to completing the plans to submit with a Certificate of Appropriateness application. Property Owner: Dan Schaefer Mr. Schaefer explained that the architect Andrea Snow was unable to attend the meeting; however in her absence he provided the following explanation of the plan: • A 2-story, Italianate style, garage in front of the home - side loading creating a front courtyard,with a bedroom above garage. • The street facing facade of the garage will have a single window with pilasters on both side; and a Juliette balcony above on the second floor. • Since the plan of treatment does not prohibit, but simply discourages front loading garages, the garage in the front of the home is shown to preserve an Ash tree in the rear yard and Maple tree in the front yard, maximize the size of the home, and reduce the amount of impervious surface on the property. Mr. Schaefer concluded that he believed the plan provides for a quality, high-style Italianate home with a quaint courtyard that will fit in well with the neighborhood. Board members provided Mr. Schaefer with the following feedback: • The plan of treatment discourages front loading garages, thus the proposal could set an undesirable precedence unless strong justification for why a rear garage cannot be designed is provided. • The front loading garage/courtyard is not a design seen in the Country Club District; and would be more suitable for a suburban neighborhood such as Bearpath. • Balance of fenestration is important - front window on the garage lacks symmetry • The canopy for the Ash tree in the rear yard overlaps with the footprint of the structure, causing concerns for the survival of the tree due to the root system being compromised during construction. • Italianete style is a good choice, however question the wisdom of planning the design of the home around a questionable tree (both because it is an Ash which are being removed Draft Minutes® Approved Minutes❑ Approved Date:Click here to enter a date. citywide; and due to the potential damage construction would impose on the tree's root structure). Mr. Schaefer thanked the board for their input. D. Historic Context Study Update: Consultant Robert Vogel explained that the Historic Context Study provides the HPB with the basic foundation for decision making by generating scholarship to substantiate decisions. Mr. Vogel elaborated on the work he has undertaken relative to the four following themes: 1. Churches 2. Cold War Fall-out Shelters 3. WPA Federal Relief Construction 4. American Four-Square Houses Mr.Vogel pointed out that when completed, a result of adding these new themes to the Historic Context Study will provide the board with necessary information to add new properties under those categories to the list of those that could be eligible for landmark designation.The board thanked Mr.Vogel for the update. No formal action was taken. 1. Correspondence and Petitions: None VII. Chair And Member Comments: A. Chair Birdman welcomed new member Scott Loving VIII.Staff Comments: A. Next Meeting Date - August 8, 2016 (MONDAY) B. Summer Tour 2016 - July 20, 2016, 6:30 p.m. (Special Meeting) C. 2016 Preservation Conference - Sept.8 &9 in Hastings. D. Joint Meeting with City Council - September 20, 2016 IX. Adjournment: 8:20 p.m. Respectfully submitted Jayce/Repycv 4,,).i CITY OF EDINA o 12nt 4801 West 50th Street V.6 y Edina, MN 55424 www.edinamn.gov Date: August 8, 2016 Agenda Item#:VLA. To: Heritage Preservation Board Item Type: Report and Recommendation From: Joyce Repya, Senior Planner Item Activity: Subject: Summer Tour-Country Club District-West Information ACTION REQUESTED: None INTRODUCTION: The board will take a tour of the west side of the Country Club District to see examples of historic architectural styles and review homes that have received a Certificates of Appropriateness. The tour will include the following streets: Browndale Avenue, Moorland Avenue, Edina Boulevard and Wooddale Avenue ATTACHMENTS: Sunnier 2016 Tour-Country Club District(west side) \S lr 2-°1(a 1411/1 Edina Country Club District Walking Tour Welcome to the Historic Edina Country Club District.This walking tour is intended to acquaint you with Edina's noted Period Revival neighborhood, and provide you with an introduction to the characteristic design features of several of the most common architectural styles represented in this historic district. The walking tour will take approximately one hour.The map on page 4 of this guide indicates the suggested route,which begins at the south end of Browndale Avenue,turns right (east) on Sunnyside Road,continues from north to south on Moorland Avenue,then south to north on Edina Boulevard, and finishes north to south on Wooddale Avenue. Homes of particular interest are numbered on the ma with a brief discussion of each featured house on pages 5 13 of this guide. The guide concludes with a list of the references consulted in assembling this guide, and suggestions for further reading. We hope you enjoy the tour! Please respect the privacy of neighborhood residents by viewing all homes from the sidewalk �' {t+� ;: syy, `�` • m1.im-- 'i--3,4_,,,.. ",, --. ,4g4 :\ { � & '{ 1 r � "-- --- G `~ ap v.,_ �r -, .. - A (k W r rte. _- F -j_..V -A ^; - t i -•- -w7 i ,.� .,eon _„ 6- �; _.. _ 111— 8rvndafekvtle Oa :_'�- "EdgebroSk Plage .;' Bridge f- ,-. s r '- Future SunnyslopeAddion Fes" '. a' t T { #rt -?'FP" � { -ter r,s .. , --- Photo:Edina Historical Society Blog;Country Club District in the 1930s a �s tl�-t have' /COP re e e,i v ed CAS-Ifi C t ` Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 1 o-F p p vo I� at(42s S have- e, o ii t,e v\ CIA .Cu ed, • A Walk Through the Care was also taken to protect the property values in the form of deed restrictions,valid for Historic Country Club 40 years,which were enforced by the Country Neighborhood Club Neighborhood Association led by Thorpe. The regulations were strictly adhered to and dictated,among other things,what kind of trees could be planted and where garbage cans should be placed. In addition to the 40-year usage restrictions, perpetual covenants were included in the deeds prohibiting non-whites from owning or residing in the District. It was expressly stated that"no lot shall ever be sold, conveyed, leased or rented to any person other 1 ..'� 5 than of the white or Caucasian race..."Such private deed restrictions were found to be unenforceable by the U.S.Supreme Court in 1948. -` I Thorpe's historic Country Club District was added to the National Park Service's National Edina, Minnesota Register of Historic Places in 1980,recognizing the neighborhood as one of the first planned The Edina Country Club District is a residential communities in the United States. suburban neighborhood covering a 14-block area bounded by Minnehaha Creek to the Ninety-one percent,or 507 of the 555 homes in west,Sunnyside Road to the north,Arden the district were built between 1924 and 1944, Avenue to the east,and W.50th Street to the when Thorpe Bros. Realty controlled the south. The District encompasses approximately Country Club development and enforced rigid 555 dwellings and a City park. architectural standards on new home construction through restrictive covenants. History Overall,the level of preservation of historic The Edina Country Club District, platted in 1924 facades in the district is outstanding, by Thorpe Brothers Realty Company,was one of particularly in comparison with other the first modern planned communities in neighborhoods of similarly-aged homes Minnesota.A majority of the homes were (including those in historic districts)in the Twin constructed between 1924 and 1941 on land Cities.The loss of historic integrity(i.e.,the originally serving the Browndale Farm(Henry ability to visually convey historical significance) Brown's land)and the old Baird farm(George caused by inappropriate remodeling and Baird).Samuel Thorpe carefully designed every additions has been proportionally small:fewer aspect of the neighborhood to include heavily than 5 percent of the homes more than 50 tree-lined streets and parks,as well as uniform years old have been torn down or renovated to building and design restrictions. Unique to the the point that they no longer resemble the times,Thorpe ensured that all of the major original home. utilities were installed before the lots were placed on market,thus ensuring that the [Source:Edina Heritage Preservation website] neighborhood was developed according to his plan. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 2 Characteristics of Common Architectural Styles Represented in the Country Club District Period House Revival: Edina's Country Club District was constructed during the period house revival movement of the first third of the 20th century.Architectural historians Poppeliers and Chambers note that"the horrors of[World War I] convinced many Americans that styles reflecting their own past,with attributes of comfort,familiarity,safety and honesty were worth emulating." Each period revival house followed one particular design heritage, but in planned developments such as the Country Club District, the scale and orientation on site of such houses were generally consistent. In designing a period house, architects reviewed reference works and authentic examples in order to approximate appropriate proportions, materials and details. However, most of the homes in the Country Club District are not pure examples of any particular style. For example,shutters are a traditional feature of Colonial Revival architecture, but in the District non-functional shutters on Tudor and Spanish-style houses are often seen.Three of the most common period house revival styles in the Country Club District are the American Colonial or Colonial Revival style,the English Tudor or English Cottage style,and the Mediterranean or Spanish Colonial style.The attributes of each of these styles are summarized below, and characteristic examples of each type in the District are identified on the following pages. American Colonial and Colonial Revival Style:Colonial Revival houses typically have a rectangular footprint and may be one,one-and-a-half,or two stories.They may have either a hipped or gabled roof with a medium pitch.The facade is generally symmetrical,which gives it formality and balance.Side porches are common. Double-hung, multi-paned windows with shutters are arranged symmetrically, frequently in pairs.The front door is centered and often accentuated with a combination of pediment, pilasters,columns,fanlight,or sidelights. Other common design elements are dormers,classical columns, pilasters,and dentils under the eaves.Siding is frequently clapboard, but many Colonial Revivals have facings of brick over their wooden framing. Roofing material is typically wood shingles, with slate tile common in the Northeast.White was the preferred color for many homes, with trim painted in green, black,or other dark hues. [From Antique Home] English Tudor and English Cottage Style:The Tudor and English Cottage style is distinctive for its steeply pitched,cross-gabled roof.Houses in this style are generally one-and one-half to two stories. Decorative half timbering is common in the gable and second story.The windows are relatively tall and slender with multi-pane glazing separated by either wood or lead muntins.Chimneys are large and often decorated with ornate chimney pots and decorative brickwork.Several different siding treatments are common including brick, stucco,stone,and wood shingle or clapboard. Roofs are found in most roofing materials. Windows,another distinctive feature,are often casement types opening out as well as the more common double-hung window.Multiple windows are arranged in ribbons across the facade. In the English Cottage style in particular,a steeply gabled,enclosed entry is common. [From Antique Home] Mediterranean or Spanish Colonial Style:The Mediterranean or Spanish Colonial Style was derived in part from the Beaux Arts style popular at the turn of the 20th century.The style draws on classical design principles and sought to embody Renaissance ideals. Houses in this style are typically two stories. Proportion is very important. Roofs are generally of tile and are balanced and low-pitched; occasionally, roofs in this style may be flat. Eaves are generally widely overhanging with decorative brackets. Exteriors are most often stucco or stone,and sometimes brick.Entries may be slightly recessed,and emphasized by classical columns or pilasters. Doors and windows on the first floor are often arched,with upper story windows usually smaller and simpler.Windows are often casements with minimal wood trim. Decorative design elements include paired French doors,arches,and wrought iron accents.Chimneys are simple and rectangular,often stuccoed or plastered stone or brick. [From Antique Home Style] Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 3 ..4, I I _ - - -- i 17 I-4 , • V. We A/AT . CZ) ' -1— i.!. . ,4 ' '1 Q .4 MKT AIX Cr. , Cr. Z-- ] pt‘....F.**-Fg. ',.) () II C4rriV.3 I• AV, e 2 51' a s- 1.11 in ..; 0 L... I g4I' 0 t g 1 ' * DREAEL AVE lif 8 I . .1kswissismis a s lb if ........ . .. e ,. saquipsa RA 41+ 1 r- 4. .-•- i ,,,e if* -.. . . .. , .). wagotALE AVE --.4. 13 it Z , .., ri1 i lid DNA illVit AN /*--- 2 AS it ..., s 411 r-1 ..* tt*, .... 0 1 t gi-A%0 AVE thitotl ----IP *- 4 .,2 fa. „vs ....... in , 1 . , , .., , `41- (r ...... . CI 1 i . 4.4.4 , ., 1.1. ...„ -.. • ti- 63 t--...."'Sp 4 , 10"AV.1. ''.4'fr 14 . • tl. „„sovikif 4,2 6* .., u il -.-_-_ .*--- 1 -,,,t-, tr ..... -.4 10-1- ... , -.. o- 4.4„ ...- , 0 -4.. .11P Ci. I Ar. 1 ..... * 1 aii 4,' f'*** 44 4 -,'4 . . I .tt . IF , . A ' ....it 1 , . i 1 . , , 4 , . , 1 , -, ...- - --— -------.... ---------- -- ---------- — 1. 4632 Browndale Avenue. 1925. English Cottage style, Norman influence. Characteristic half-timbering on the gable.Arched windows and small roof over the front door are also characteristic of this style, as is the extended roofline culminating in an arched door to the side � ! ' yard. 3i L.. 4610 Browndale Avenue. 1933. English Tudor style, Norman influence. Geometric timbering and decorative stone work on the façade;large brick chimney; characteristic roofline. ' i �, t , COQ, ro v►-t -� ,a�#�, 4.4144. 5, 4604 Browndale Avenue. 1925. t� K3t 4"+ ... Mediterranean style. Characteristic.0red-tile roof and stucco exterior; large chimney with decorative tilework surrounding arched front door reminiscent "11 of Pueblo style. Decorative wrought ironwork '� under second-story window is also characteristic of it iorta t "m' this style.aft Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 5 (a. 4603 Browndale Avenue. 1935. 4 . to ' s. ;, New England Colonial Revival. Characteristic } 1'6' symmetrical façade with decorative shutters. Front * ' door accented by pillars and sidelights.Traditional q : color scheme of white with dark shutters. C OA _ Fro ct ytr JO. 4402 Browndale Avenue. 1927. -— Mediterranean Style.Red tile roof,stucco exterior, � �< <: arched windows on second story with decorative ' . r�` 1_'i: ironwork.Arched front door.The large window above ' , ` - ' , the front door is atypical for this style. ja y' tft" 1' �fj 7i�rC' 4! ii ti4tC.3R�.A'''_;;;;; J �C(t...l;t 116 G ,.:1'1 53 .R.� /3. 4506 Moorland Avenue.1930. English Cottage.Characteristic half-timbering and prominent gable.Decorative stonework on facade. I4- L, �� Second-story oriel window is characteristic of this style. 1 r,EFA1 Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 6 114' 4509 Moorland Avenue.1929. w .s14" 0,Vi „azMediterranean.This house displays many typical characteristics of the Mediterranean style: red tile roof, 3, ,.tori stucco exterior,decorative ironwork and diminutive • balconies on the second story,arched window and doorway on first story,smaller second-story windows. /to., 4514 Moorland Avenue.1935. �; a rAr New England Colonial Revival.Note the characteristic symmetrical façade,decorative shutters and traditional • , �� " + color scheme.The side porch,which is atypical for this ; _" °-' -� � .'i .'' style,is common in the Country Club District,and • I nU (g reflects 1920s-1930s preferences. pr /1 4517 Moorland Avenue.1929. t,. English Cottage Style.Characteristic half-timbering and F � decorative stonework on the facade;small-paned ;-. windows on the first story.The curved roofline over the sheltered front door gives this house a storybook quality. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 7 D.4606 Moorland Avenue.*1927. American Colonial Revival with English Georgian Revival influence. Fine detailing on the second-story bay r z window.Front door accented with sidelights;shutters and traditional balanced façade.One of eight original model homes commissioned by Country Club District n — - developer Samuel S.Thorpe. pl .144 t _ f I `, (r,�� . 4612 Moorland Avenue.*1926. French Provincial.Characteristic roofline,decorative shutters and arched first floor windows and door.This is one of the eight original model homes designed by the Minneapolis architectural firm of Liebenberg and Kaplan. _ - I 4 Ifs ''A 2.3. 4617 Moorland Avenue.*1926. English Tudor.The design of this house incorporates the characteristic half-timbering and prominent chimney of the English Tudor style.One of the original eight model homes in this neighborhood,of which seven remain. Immediately south of this house,at 4619 Moorland Avenue,is the site of the former Bert Gamble residence, built for the founder of the Gambles Department Store chain.The 1936 Mediterranean-style house formerly on this lot has been replaced with a house constructed in 2003. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 8 2.1 4619 Edina Boulevard.*1928. �l i,�; i Mediterranean.This original model house incorporates • A many typical characteristics of the Mediterranean style, including a red tile roof,ornamental ironwork serving as 4 ,06`'' a decorative balcony over the second-story window,a • stucco facade,and prominent chimney.This style was very popular in the 1920s and 1930s. 2_6 4611 Edina Boulevard.*1930. American Georgian Revival.The hip roof is characteristic of the American Georgian style,as is the symmetrical $a* • '� s'e ' façade and pedimented doorway.One of the original ��;► , 'I f' i model houses in the District. 2,61.4608 Edina Boulevard.*1926. trio» 5r " ' & := "` ,gyp '�'' 5� t " F",' 030 4'1 If�. �" English Cottage style,with Norman influence.An • . K..;, F.% original model house.Characteristic half timbering, large chimney with brick decoration,and decorative K1 stonework surrounding the main door.The tower1. indicates a Norman influence on the design. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 9 3a 4602 Edina Boulevard.1931. 'I,a 4r English Cottage style,with Norman influence. � : Decorative stonework surrounding the door, half- 7 I' timbering,stucco facade and second-story bay window 11 ; , l are all characteristic of the English cottage style.The I > 1 slightly projecting gable adds a Norman influence to this 1design. 1 31. 4600 Edina Boulevard.*1926. ;. '. English Cottage,Norman influence.Another of the '' ` ; s original model homes,built in 1926 by Britton Goetze,a ' !r _ ',•:::‘,,k;-,Ii,' contractor who in the 1940 census is listed as living in �� P �. • ,al Edina.The design has characteristic half-timbering, Ii,wii v6:1, stucco walls and a prominent chimney with decorative R,; :## brickwork.The main entrance is angled to the street, * ��j ' which is common on corner lots in the district. C,0 A = Ne,cd Reached 6d,le, ''3 4514 Edina Boulevard.1935. ,, �# r I New England Colonial Revival;American Georgian I _` i� Revival influence.The characteristic brick,symmetrical =1 lf 0 U % facade, decorative shutters,dormers and pedimented doorway of the Colonial Revival and Georgian Revival styles. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 10 4512 Edina Boulevard.1930. Mediterranean.Arched windows on lower left of the façade,with ornamental ironwork; red-tiled roof,and small decorative pseudo-balcony above the door are characteristic of this style. 41-21„1 tirfq 4500 Edina Boulevard.1925. `, Mediterranean.The open,columned porch over the , front door is characteristic of the Spanish Mission style. ► _ _ . d i t' - � The house has the typical stucco facade,red tile roof, and smaller second-story windows of the Mediterranean style. 3(0 4500 Wooddale Avenue.1930 .04 � I .. A p d.4 44' , ' .1"It i l� at Mediterranean.The characteristic red tile roof and ornamental ironwork can be seen on this house.The rounded doorway is set at an angle to the facade,and the roof has the characteristic low pitch of this style. The Mediterranean or Spanish style,very popular in the 1920s and 1930s,declined in popularity after the Second World War. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 11 '38.. 4506 Wooddale Avenue.1934. y Norman; English Tudor influence.Characteristic half {a; �� timbering and arched door;full-length casement ti — windows(French doors)at lower left. 41. 4516 Wooddale Avenue.1932. American Colonial Revival,with New England Colonial Revival Influence.Characteristic symmetrical, balanced facade; paired chimneys,door with fan-shaped [111 g pediment and decorative shutters are characteristic of this style. 14.2. 4523 Wooddale Avenue.1934. r,Aif.;: Norman,with English Tudor influence. Extensive half- 'II"' timbering on the combination brick,stone and stucco façade,and the prominent chimney with decorative brick detailing,are typical of this style.Note the diamond-paned windows on the lower left.The small rounded roof above the second-story window at the center indicates the Norman influence on this design. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 12 46. 4613 Wooddale Avenue.1935. English Cottage.This house illustrates the variety and skillful use of materials often found in the English i . Cottage style.The covered porch surrounding the front s/ -'•. � door is typical of the cottage style.This one-and one I tf �;n '' half story home was built in 1935 by Aarhus Hansen y ; Company for Clifford Ashley. L4-1. 4612 Wooddale Avenue.1936. New England Colonial Revival.Brick facade,decorative _ shutters,paired chimneys and pedimented front door t ��, ell'� i � � ir� , - ..•,,,s;*•;� are characteristic of the Colonial Revival style. og �� 52. 4625 Wooddale Avenue.1925. A fine example of the Spanish Colonial or �"ife 1 1304 :, Mediterranean style. Note in particular the low- , a'• , }x, ' - ' , relief ornament around the arched doorway, � � shed roof over the center second-story window, ,r , the decorative ironwork balcony,characteristic red tile roof,and arched windows with decorative surrounds. COA= 1�eu1 C7ccra.9e� Edina Country Club District Walking Tour 13 I 2016 Summer Tour: Country Club District- West 1. 4632 Browndale- 1925 English Cottage 2. 4624 Browndale- COA(rear facade) 141 tc' Cra•F1'•/EN1.l 4• 3. 4621 Browndale -COA(front facade/det.garage)1124, Eng.(ol✓. 4. 4610 Browndale- 1933 English Tudor- COA(front facade-garage) 5. 4604 Browndale- 1925 Mediterranean 6. 4603 Browndale- 1935 New England Colonial COA(front entry) 7. 4601 Browndale- COA (front entry) 025 l�lcd 8. 4515 Browndale- COA(new det.garage) q 55 Ne&l•ite v. 9. 4511 Browndale- COA(front facade) sq o/cildt•• 10.4402 Browndale- 1927 Mediterranean 1 1. 4405 Browndale- COA (new det.garage) /et 35 E46' ' 12. 4504 Sunnyside - COA (front entry) "l3 Amur.Cal•/Engj•Geel• 13. 4506 Moorland- 1930 English Cottage 14. 4509 Moorland- 1929 Mediterranean 15. 4513 Moorland - COA (new det. garage) s 2R E11.5•1 cd• 16.414 Moorland 1935 New England Colonial 17. 4517 Moorland - 1929 English Cottage 18. 4602 Moorland COA (new det. garage)igts Eng•cot- 19. 4603 Moorland - COA (new det.garage) 1121 &. 20.4606 Moorland- 1927 American Colonial Revival* 21. 4607 Moorland - COA (new det.garage) 1g30 Nerw1•444/E41 ,Taal • 22.4612 Moorland- 1926 French Provincial* 23.4617 Moorland 1926 English Tudor* 24. 4619 Moorland - COA(new home - I st one)Woo tq 3fr Me-4.0443) 25. 4624 Moorland - COA (new home)Was 91.1et Cowen!club -1956 1¢a44.1blcr(2w0) 26. 4621 Edina Blvd - COA (street facade) "131 a4SQ4•Ce%• 27.4619 Edina Blvd - 1928 Mediterranean* 28.4611 Edina Blvd 1930 American Georgian Revival* 29.4608 Edina Blvd 1926 English Cottage/Norman 30.4602 Edina Blvd - 1931 English Cottage 31.4600 Edina Blvd COA(new det.garage) y��,,1� 32. 4515 Edina Blvd - COA (new det.garage) t 9Z9 54 '64' 33.4514 Edina Blvd- 1935 New England Colonial 34.4512 Edina Blvd 1930 Mediterranean 35.4500 Edina Blvd- 1925 Mediterranean 36.4500 Wooddale- 1930 Mediterranean 37. 4501 Wooddale- COA (new home 2"d)1415.6••/934 Norksm0/600•Tud.C2003) 38.4506 Wooddale-- 1934 Norman/English Tudor 39.4508 Wooddale- COA (new det.garage) tg24 B►uj-Cat• 40. 4512 Wooddale - COA(new det.garage) I'V`t N6 Cot' 41.4516 Wooddale- 1932 American Colonial Revival 42.4523 Wooddale- 1934 Norman/English Tudor /1 2016 Summer Tour: Country Club District- West 43.4600 Wooddale - COA (new det. garage) /9 34 "le'r."(O1 44.4601 Wooddale - COA(street facade) /921 /h ed • 45.4602 Wooddale - COA (new det.garage) /9 7 Norm". • 46.4607 Wooddale - COA(street facade/move det. garage)iq 30 avow• £oC• 47.4612 Wooddale 1936 New England Colonial 48.4613 Wooddale- 1935 English Cottage cL.e2°°q) 49.4615 Wooddale- COA(new home&det.garage)Way I q 3 0 me"' 50.4623 Wooddale- COA(front entry) j q 3G aiw. r. Crt• • 51.4624 Wooddale - COA (street facade) f9 37 fie'• Col 52.4625 Wooddale 1925 Spanish/Mediterranean -COA(new attached garage) Original Tour Homes Model Home Acknowledgements and Further Information The information in this walking tour guide was compiled by Peter Otness and taken from the following sources: Antique Home,Colonial Architecture.Web.http://www.antiquehome.org/Architectural-Stvle/colonial.htm. Antique Home,Colonial Revival Architecture.Web. http://www.antiquehome.org/Architectural-Stvle/colonial- revival.htm. Antique Home,Tudor Revival and English Cottage Style.Web. http://www.antiquehome.org/Architectural- Style/tudor.htm. Antique'Home Style,Italian Style-1890 to 1935.Web.http://www.antiquehomestyle.comistylesfitalian.htm. Baker,John Milnes.American House Styles:A Concise Guide. New York: Norton.2002. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour Guides,1983 and 1990,prepared by Edina Historical Society and the Edina Heritage Preservation Board. Edina Heritage Preservation Board Website: Heritage Landmarks, Edina Country Club District, http://edinamn,gov/index.php?section=heritagelandmarks countrvclub. MacDonald,A.B."A Home District Beautiful."Ladies Home Journal,Vol.38, February 1921,pages 12-13;80-82. Kansas City Public Library.Feature article on the Country Club district in Kansas City, Missouri,which served as one of the models for the Edina district. McAlester,Virginia Savage.A Field Guide to American Houses:The Definitive Guide to Identifying and Understanding America's Domestic Architecture. New York:Knopf.2014. Poppeliers,John C.and S.Allen Chambers Jr. What Style Is It?A Guide to American Architecture. New York: Wiley.2003. United States Department of the Interior Heritage Conservation and Recreation Service: Register of Historic Places Inventory—Nomination Form,Edina, MN Country Club District, 1982. Edina Country Club District Walking Tour / . C