HomeMy WebLinkAbout19790619_edina_board_of_review126 I
6/5/79
M. I?. -Schneidcr, 5208 Birclicrest Drive, requcstbg review of the market val
of $89,100 on his property, based on ,the fact that he purchased 1t one- Gedk-
prior to Januzry 2, 1979, €or $84,000.
R. Waldo Anderson, 5209 Valley View Road, objecEing to a narket value of
$102,700 for the reason that the truck traffic noise on the Crosstom high^^^$
has increased during the last few years an:! he would be unable to sell' t%e ~ * property at that value. e*
,; 5
I Donald C. McGorman, 5917 Killarney Lane, objecting to a market valuk of" - *
$98,300 on his home and requesting Assessor'to view same. He stated t1;at . *-'
in his opinion the market value should be in the area of $85,OCO bo $98,000.
. James E. Donohue, representing Dale E. Johnson owner of 7519 Hyde Park Drzve,
objecting to estimated market value of $192,000, based on actual cost of
building the home as being $1'36,299.
Xr. Johnson then presented the fpllowing list of property values currently under
review by the Assessor's office and advised that the requests had beea mad2 by'
phone conversation with or by personal appearance of the property owners :
Xame and Address Estimated Market Valce James Rutherford, 5301 West 63rd 'Street $103,800 * 4. '*
Leo J. Raskind, 3 Orchard Line 100,500
Betty Parsons, 5912 Grimes Avenue 56,300
Nancy Birger, 5716 Xerxes Avenue 68,700
Daniel Dodge, 6309 Virginia Avenue 99,000
- Carol A. Wilson, 6844 Oaklawn Avenue 77,500 *
Donald McGorman, 5917 Killarney Lane 98,300
There being no one else requesting to be heard, Mayor Van Vallcenkurg declared
the meeting adjcurned until 4 p.m. on June 19, 1979. Adjournmeat at 5:05 p.m.
Acting City Clerk
MINUTES OF THE CONTIBUED NEETING OF THE
EDINA BOARD OF REVIEW
HELD TUESDAY , JUNE 19 , 1979 , AT 4 :00 P .MI
Answering rollcall for the continued meeting of the Board of Review were smi)zrs
Courtxey , Sclmidt and Xayor Van Valkeiiburg.
Xr. Robert EIifl, 5204 Richwood Dr., appeared again to protest the Assessor's
estiinated market vaiue of $69,800. He ad-viscd that, while lie could not sell
his hme for more than $75,000, his estimate6 market value is higher than otker
houses in his neiglhorhood which would sell for considerably nore.
Ta37lor of the Assessor's office advised that she had made comparisons with the
property at 5229 Richwood Drive nentioned by Pir. Hill, and had forind no as-
cregancies in the values of the two properties.
Property at 7201 Bark Ave. was represerited by Ms. Donna King wbo made comeats
additional to those made by Mr. Edxard H. Palmer at the Board of Review Neet-
ing of June 5, 1979. She conteiided that, until the building is completed 2nd
occupied-, the vdue should 5e proportionately lower.
Councilwoman Schmidt's nation was then seconded by Councilman Richards, for
reduction of values en the f0110~hg properties :
Xame Le gal Description Value
Arthur Buffington Lot 1, Bi. 1, Ovzrholt Hills Georgia 3rd $ i2,OOO
sdins Mascinic Lodge 8343 18,000
Keith Carlson Lot 1, 33.. 3, Ediri~ Icterchauge Centzr 55,5@3
Keith Carlsorr Lot 2, 13.1. 2, Nim: 8ile Vest t:;t Adcin. 324 > 500
21s- Jo
Part 01 LO^ 23, iurtitor's Subc!ivision 196
Motj on was scconded by Councilman Richards.
AJPCS : Richards, Schmidt Van 'Jalkcnburg
Nays:. None
>lo t ion carried .
The Board reviewed ledger sheets showing costs for the home of Dale E. Johnson,
7519 Hyde Park Drive, alcng with recommendations of the Assessor for the
renlainder of the persoos who had appeared in person or i;rho had subnltted written
applications for review at the last meeting.
that the Council accept the reconmendations of the Assessor which included
reductions in value on the following properties :
Counctlman Richards then moved
Name
Carol A. Wilson -. Legal Description Value
Part of Lot 2, B1. 1, Brost Addition $ 72,900
.?in Hiniker Lot 4, B1. 1, Southdale 3rd Addn. 92,000
PI. W. Schneider Lor 12, B1. 3, Birchcrest 2nd Addn. 83,000
R. Waldo Anderson Lot 2, 331. 1, Genevieve Addn. 93,200
Nancy Birger Lot 5, B1. 1, Brookline Addn. 63,000
Daniel Dodge Lot 12, B1. 1, Replat of Block 10,
Nomandale Addn. 94 , 100
Motion was seconded by Councilwoman Schmidt.
Ayes : Richards , Schmidt, Van Valkenburg
Motion carried.
~ Nays: None
The Mayor then. declared the Board of Xeview for 1979 adjourned.
5:OO p.m.
Adjournment at
I