The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About19940411_edina_board_of_review209 MINUTES OF TBE MEETING OF THE EDINA BOARD OF ReVIETJ HELD MONDAY, APRIL 11, 1994 AT 5:OO P.H., EDINB CITY Answering rollcall were Members Kelly, Paulus, Rice Smith and Chairman Richards. The meeting was convened pursuant to published Notice of Board of Review in the Edina Sun-Current and notices posted on City bulletin boards for the purpose of hearing those persons who considered themselves aggrieved by their property valuation for assessment purposes, or who were requesting homestead classification. Mayor Richards stated that no decision would be made at this meeting, but that property owners would be notified of the Board's decision within 20 days. Further appeal may be made to the Hennepin County Board of Review beginning June 17, 1994. The following property owners appeared personally before the Board, or were represented, to object to the Assessor's estimated market value as of January 2, 1994: Assessor's Owner's Est Name/Address PID Number Est Mkt Val of Mkt Val John G. Berg 08-116-21-21-0027 $ 343,000 $317/310,000 Jack/Eileen Abrahamson 33-117-21-22-0011 128,000 118,000 Spencer/Dorothy Marsh 33-117-21-22-0032 130,400 128,900 Jeanette Swofford 32-117-21-23-0048 166,400 157,500 Thomas Wilson I11 29-117-21-44-0056 165,000 150,000 7104 Shannon Dr 5209 Richwood Dr 5204 Richwood Dr 6017 Kaymar Dr Gayle Gamer 5209 Lochloy Dr 4610 Golf Te 5809 Mait Ln 4715 Annaway Dr 6432 Timber Ridge 6104 Wilryan Av 6021 Birchcrest Dr 5308 Halifax Av 6112 Wilryan Av 6121 Birchcrest Dr Edwin/Dorothy Moore 19-028-24-21-0074 -537,100 457,100 Melvin/Linda Vogel 29-117-21-21-0025 591,000 381,500 Thomas/Garin Collins 29-117-21-21-0023 859,600 725,000 Robert/Ruth Donaldson 06-116-21-24-0035 785,000 706,500 Gregory/Lisa Buck 33-117-21-34-0104 189,400 173,200 Christopher/Joanne Kudrna 33-117-21-34-0006 152,800 136,000 Jacqueline Mithun 18-028-24-44-0067 176,000 167/171,000 Rosemary Freeman 33-117-21-34-0183 145,900 None stated Manley/Betty Oakes 33-117-21-34-0012 134,600 128,000 210 4/11/94 Name/Address PID Number Garth/Jean Homes 04-116-21-22-0108 James Toohey 30-028-24-11-0012 6304 Warren Av 6204 France Av So 3516 West Fuller St 5601 Oaklawn Av 6309 Ashcroft La 5101 West 62nd St Flynn 5311 Hollywood Rd 5333 Interlachen Blvd 5816 St. Johns Av We s ter gr e en 5201 Birchcrest Dr 6124 Wilryan Av 5016 Valley View Rd 6137 Birchcrest Dr 7627 Gleason Rd 6012 Killarney La Herbst 93 Woodland Cr Richard/Charlotte Pehrson 20-028-24-22-0021 Thomas/Mary Lou Hines 19-028-24-13-0001 Glenn Nybeck 30-028-24-21-0087 John/Misuk Palmer 04-116-21-21-0054 Christopher/Roxanne 28-117-21-23-0017 Jerome Chapman I1 28-117-21-32-0059 Steven/Kimberly Melin 19-028-24-31-0050 Michael/Dolores 33-117-21-33-0092 Peter/Colleen Pause 33-117-21-34-0100 Michael/Geraldine Sjoblom 33-117-21-34-0067 Thomas/Mary Lave11 33-117-21-34-0016 John M. Zwicke 08-116-21-33-0084 Kenneth/Mary Ledeboer 31-117-21-44-0047 Scott McNairy/Nancy 19-028-24-14-0036 The owners of the following properties submitted market values and requested the Board's review: Name/Address PID Number Patricia A. Moe 04-116-21-23-0035 6401 Mildred Av 6505 Wilryan Av 6300 Valley View Rd 5517 McGuire Rd 6414 Timber Ridge 6524 Cherokee Tr William W. Plante 04-116-21-24-0099 James E,/Beatrice Voss 05-116-21-11-0060 Randall/Elizabeth Stukel 05-116-21-43-0021 Dennis/Donna Bock 06-116-21-12-0006 Susan/Terry Jacobs 06-116-21-13-0037 Assessor's Est Mkt Val 143,900 85,000 146,700 207 400 152,600 186,400 225,000 Owner's Est of Mkt Val 135,000 78/80,000 127,000 180 000 140,000 175,000 200,000 153 400 146,750 126,100 126,600 178 900 170,000 191,200 170,000 187,600 173,000 154,900 None stated 382,000 303,000 228 100 255 000 306,000 301,000 letters objecting to their Assessor's Owner's Est of Mkt Val 139,700 128 900 Est Mkt Val 124 200 None stated 111,500 None stated None stated 150 200 491,500 None stated 264,000 None stated J 4/11/94 211 Name/Address Douglas So derb er g 6424 Timber Ridge Albert J./Jewel J. Lalim 6600 Blockfoot Pass Ed Szachowicz/Laurel Ferris 7028 Wexford Dr James M./Ann M. Bourey 7117 Fleetwood Dr Stephen/Fay Gold 7409 Shannon Dr Timothy/Nancy L. Gagner 5747 Long Brake Tr Diana L. Thompson 4371 Thielen Av William/Mary Fitch 5201 Mirror Lakes Dr James M. Ronning 6416 Interlachen Blvd Cindy/Perry Witkin 5112 Ridge Rd Douglas Forsberg/Janet Pollish-Forsberg 5033 Green Farms Rd Robert W./Janis A. Froemming 4930 Interlachen Ct Robert E. Jepson 6208 Parkwood Rd Daniel R./Mary S. Hurley 6017 Killarney Ln Lauralee A. Lindeland 5541 Warden Av Michael J. Lonergan 5812 Olinger Blvd Stephen A./Christine M. Ullom 5229 Richwood Dr 5712 Bernadr P1 Washburn 5029 Normandale Ct 5025 Normandale Ct John L. Holahan, Jr. Margaret S. 5320 Birchcrest Dr Wesley J. McCoy 5312 Birchcrest Dr Kenneth/Rebecca Jacques Gordon S./Renae R. Weber Don E./Virginia L. ''Joyce Thiss PID Number 06-116-21-21-0012 06-116-21-24-0015 08-116-21-22-0001 08-116-21-21-0050 08-116-21-31-0044 08-116-21-34-0028 28-117-21-21-0131 29-117-21-34-0027 30-117-21-13-0017 30-117-21-42-0010 30-117-21-42-0032 30-117-21-24-0024 31-117-21-11-0006 31-117-21-44-0015 32-117-21-14-0011 32-117-21-34-0060 33-117-21-22-0016 33-117-21-23-0038 33-117-21-24-0022 33-117-21-24-0029 33-117-21-33-0069 33-117-21-33-0071 33-117-21-33-0087 Assessor's Est Mkt Val 532,200 281,600 252,100 240,100 515,700 537,100 158,700 190,400 193,500 413,700 542,100 501,600 260,100 208,900 177,500 180,100 146,100 128,700 162,900 144,100 180,500 174,000 172,900 Owner's Est of Mkt Val None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated 160,000 None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated 5316 West 62nd St 4/11/94 212 Name/Address Frank R. Cardarelle 6125 Wilryan Av Ikbal M. Elsafy 4013 Lynn Av Arthur J. Downey 4113 Kipling Av Joseph H./Sara H. Anderson 4404 Branson St Jerry W./Maureen E. Knob lauch 4100 West 44th St Robert T. /Donna D . McGarry 4526 Casco Av Charles J. Washam I11 4508 Drexel Av David B ./Cynthia S . Farmer 4612 Casco Av Anderson 4631 Bruce Av Joseph T. Green/Trude J. PID Number 33-117-21-34-0122 07-028-24-13-0041 07-028-24-13-0131 07-028-24-43-0059 07-028-24-43-0131 18-028-24-12-0103 18-028-24-12-0125 18-028-24-13-0017 18-028-24-13-0087 Daniel J. Jurgens, Ann M. 18-028-24-13-0144 Mersell 4906 Bruce Av 4200 West 50th St 4825 Maple Rd 4807 Maple Rd Witherell 4932 Maple Rd Lederle I11 4507 Browndale Av 4508 Edina Blvd 4513 Edina Blvd 4518 Wooddale Av 4700 Sunnyside Rd 4904 Sunnyside Rd 4613 Wooddale Av 4615 Edina Blvd Linda K. Benham 18-028-24-14-0040 R. Stewart/Phyllis Gavin 18-028-24-14-0070 John R. Naab 18-028-24-14-0074 Larry L./Charlene 18-028-24-14-0095 Frank A./Janet A. 18-028-24-21-0037 Richard D. Antone 18-028-24-21-0064 Daniel R. /Deborah Day 18-028-24-21-0075 Virginia Lupo 18-028-24-21-0079 Charles D./Janice Buth 18-028-24-22-0045 Robert S./Sally J. Lund 18-028-24-22-0055 Mark D./Rebecca C. Odland 18-028-24-24-0006 James J./Dana K. Rude 18-028-24-24-0018 Assessor's Est Mkt Val 405 700 178 300 185 000 165,300 164 700 305 900 276,200 300 600 232,700 224,400 150,500 265,200 194,600 248 700 417,600 496,700 631,600 292,500 484,400 392 900 478,300 483,800 Owner's Est I of Mkt Val 290/300,000 125,000 None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated 215/220,000 None stated None stated 370,400 None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated I, 421,000 459,000 41 11/94 -, 213 Name/Address William B./Laurie J. MacLean 4604 Edina Blvd John D./Joanie C. Fox 5015 Arden Av James Hiniker I11 Betsy Jo Simon 5014 Arden Av Bishop 5324 Halifax Av Daniel J./Andrea S. Gionet 5517 Kellogg Av Donald P. Paugh 5513 Kellogg Av Christopher Long 5529 Oaklawn Av John/Devonna Murrin 5506 Lakeview Dr James/Elizabeth Nunn 3308 West 56th St Thomas D./Mara L. Cain 3505 WEst 55th St Lucy M. Rath 5708 Ewing Av Ralph S. Hanson 5928 Chowen Av Charles/Janice Thang 6312 Peacedale Av Warren T. Plante 6804 Wooddale Av Michael J./Carol H. Erdall 4700 Wilford Way Donald Montgomery 6824 Oaklwan Av Maureen A. Kranz Kurt N. Johnson 6837 Point Dr Michael P./Sharon Wagner 6941 Southdale Rd Yan Zhangpan-Ping-Dong 7225 Cornelia Dr Ellen/Arthur Dahlquist 7024 Kellogg Av Erling Rovick 7104 Wooddale Av George/Carol Hite 4720 Aspasia Cr Ronald Schumeister 4921 Trillium La John R. Crist/Anne M. PID Number 18-028-24-24-0044 18-028-24-42-0046 18-028-24-42-0071 18-028-44-42-0061 19-028-24-12-0110 19-028-24-12-0111 19-028-24-12-0127 19-028-24-22-0034 20-028-24-21-0131 20-028-24-22-0109 20-028-24-23-0055 20-028-24-32-0143 30-028-24-11-0032 30-028-24-34-0045 30-028-24-34-0092 30-028-24-43-0067 30-028-24-43-0075 30-028-24-44-0021 31-028-24-13-0037 31-028-24-21-0063 31-028-24-21-0082 31-028-24-22-0006 31-028-24-22-0071 Assessor's Owner's Est Est Mkt Val of Mkt Val 646 200 596 100 265,700 None stated 252 100 None stated 155 600 Nohe stated 204 600 None stated 202 300 None stated 154 000 None stated 346,300 None stated 116 900 None stated 169 600 None stated 139 600 128 000 117 500 144 000 175 300 242 400 167 900 190,000 155 700 162,700 151 900 169 400 249 500 146,500 100 y 000 None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated 4/11/94 214 Name/Address Ted Cadwell 7308 Wooddale Av Robert E. Adams 7228 West Shore Dr Dick A./Deborah K. Wi tt enber g 7516 Xerxes Av Judith B. Burdick 6268 Safidpiper Ct Gordon C. Lewis Lewis Engineering 4201 Norex Dr Chaska MN 55318 Wallace Kenneth Beatrice Dvorak ' 5300 Malibu Dr L.A. Real Est. Group 3930-48 West 50th St 5100 Lincoln Dr James/Lavonne Rasmusson 7216 Oaklawn Av Vernon R. Clauson 408 Blake Rd Mervin Kronfeld 4816 Woodhill Way 2100 So. Ocean Blvd Apt 106 South Palm Beach FL 33480 Ronald/Judith Ves s ey 4610 Wooddale Av Dale/Irene Correa 5633 Woodcrest Dr Richard/Patricia Cox 6601 Normandale Rd Mary O'Neill 4812 Roycar Rd Betty J. Aungst . 5109 West 62nd St Moses/Marie Kata 5328 West 64th St Richard/Patricia Hansen 6216 Hansen Rd Warner Nibbe 6728 West Trail Gerald/Patricia Hadd 5024 West 70th St Paul R. Flatley 6404 Stauder Cr PID Number 31-028-24-24-0081 31-028-24-24-0103 32-028-24-31-0012 05-116-21-22-0039 28-117-21-33-0031 28-117-21-34-0019 28-117-21-34-0022 28-117-21-34-0026 30-117-21-32-0004 30-117-21-33-0007 18-028-24-14-0126 31-028-24-13-0072 30-117-21-12-0052 18-028-24-23-0007 18-028-24-24-0026 19-028-24-14-0061 30-028-24-32-0004 30-028-24-32-0084 04-116-21-21-0056 05-116-21-11-0022 05-116-21-11-0084 06-116-21-32-0039 09-116-21-21-0013 31-117-21-13-0003 Assessor's Est Mkt Val 159,600 160,300 103,000 124 900 95,600 314,900 119,700 444,800 975,000 2 , 140,000 144,700 4,529,200 Owner's Est of Mkt Val None stated None stated 87,300 None stated 278 900 I, 709 000 137,000 3,700,000 w/o contamination 3,400,000 w/contamination 179 , 600 171,900 115,900 None stated 289,700 None stated 384,900 308,900 235,200 191 $900 146,800 165,200 148 , 700 152 , 400 124,200 352,900 None stated None stated None stated 155,000 None stated None stated 135 000 None stated None stated 346,000 4/11/94 215 Name/Address Clara M. Johnson 5520 Merritt Cr Frank Cooley , Jr 4912 Arden Av James/Gail Hogg 4400 Browndale Av Robert/Marcella Hogue 4015 Wood End Dr Yvonne Eissinger 5828 Chowen Av James W. Tindall 6329 Brookview Av Lester Anderson, Jr 6200 Beard P1 John/Rita Tiggas 5637 Chowen Av John 0. Murrin I11 4018 West 65th St Thomas/Janet Becker 4828 Maple Rd Paula Engelking 5553 York Av Edina Properties, Inc. 3906-16 West 50th St James/Caterina Lopesio 4708 Mirror La Gladys Mitchell 7212 West Shore Dr Merton/Mardelle Schaar 6604 Naomi Dr PID Number 32-117-21-12-0054 18-028-24-13-0129 18-028-24-22-0040 19-028-24-14-0009 20-028-24-32-0051 30-028-24-12-0041 29-028-24-22-0040 20-028-24-23-0068 30-028-24-14-0003 18-028-24-14-0084 20-028-24-14-0073 18-028-24-14-0022 29-117-21-12-0003 31-028-24-24-0099 04-116-21-32-0018 Chi K. Liu/Miriam G. Gong 07-028-24-13-0100 4024 Grimes Av Assessor's Est Mkt Val 199,800 247,600 514,000 129,400 123,000 160,900 171,400 136,600 390,000 222,700 105,900 1,541,500 809,600 157,500 153,600 158,900 Owner's Est of Mkt Val None stated None stated None stated 115,000 None stated 130,000 161,000 None stated 300,000 None stated None stated 1,000,000 None stated 154,500 None stated . 138,000 No further appeals being presented, motion of Member Smith vas seconded by Member Rice to continue the 1994 Board of Review meeting to Monday, April 25, 1994, at 5:OO P.m. for decision on the appeals presented. Motion carried unanimously. City Clerk