The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About19950410_edina_board_of_review263 MINUTES OF THE ZIEETIElG OF THE EDIHB BOARD OF REVIEW HELD MONDAY, APRIL 10, 1995 AT 5:OO P.M., EDINA CITP HbI;L Answering rollcall were Members Kelly, Maetzold, Paulus, Smith and Chairman Richards. The meeting was convened pursuant to published Notice of Board of Review in the Edina Sun-Current and notices posted on City bulletin boards for the purpose of hearing those persons who considered themselves aggrieved by their property valuation for assessment purposes, or who were requesting homestead classification. Mayor Richards stated that no decision would be made at this meeting, but that property owners would be notified of the Board's decision within 20 days. Further appeal may be made to the Hennepin County Board of Review beginning June 19, 1995. The following property owners appeared personally.before the Board, or were represented, to object to the Assessor's estimated market value as of January 2, 1995: Name /Address PID Number Ronald/Sandra Martell 32-117-21-31-0081 5909 Sun Rd 5801 Hansen Rd D. Johnson 4600 Moorland Av 5016 Normandale Ct 5904 Olinger Blvd Represented by Donald thru Homeowners Association 5709 Kemrich Dr 6500 Parnell Av 5813 Bernard P1 Fiterman 308 Arthur St 5700 McGuire Rd 5821 Zenith Av 7206-7208 Heatherton Cr 31-028-24-14-0023 6309 Ashcroft La 4529 Tower St J ay/Kar in Addy 33-117-21-32-0056 Edward Laginess/Jerald 18-028-24-21-0110 Walter Hoff 33-117-21-24-0052 William/Joyce Reich 32-117-21-34-0054 5501 thru 5565 W 70th St 08-116-21-12-0139 Hykes, President of 08-116-21-12-0159 George/Susan Topor 08-116-21-24-0069 Robert Keller/Ann Orchard 30-028-24-23-0047 Andrew/Jacquelyn Peterson 33-117-21-32-0028 Marlys Rechkemmer/Marlys 30-117-21-12-0081 Edward/Beverly Zimmerman 05-116-21-34-0034 Donna Nye 20-028-24-31-0041 F. Hugh/Mollie Sherry 31-028-24-14-0022 Glenn Nybeck 30-028-24-21-0087 William Pepper 19-028-24-24-0051 Assessor's Est Mkt Val $ 232,400 178,000 368,000 reduced to 325,000 185,600 177,600 Various 187,000 195,300 116,900 213,500 212,700 108,600 142,500 143,900 155,200 185,000 Owner's Est of Mkt Val $ 210,000 134,600 300,000 160,000 170,000 Roll back to 1994 value (3%) 180,000 None stated 100,000 170,000 197,000 None stated None stated 138,000 146,000 155,000 264 4/19/95 PID Number 04-116-21-24-0102 28-117-21-32-0162 18-028-24-24-0023 30-028-24-32-0047 31-117-21-13-0047 30-117-21-21-0071 Assessor's Est Mkt Val 199,700 reduced to 190,000 90,100 reduced to 89,000 535,000 reduced to 458,000 207,400 Owner's Est of Mkt Val None stated Name/Address Thomas/Barbara Benshop 6532 Wilryan Av Gary/Barbara Zachman 5343 Interlachen Blvd 78,500 Michael/Deborah Ducar 4616 Wooddale Av 385,000 William/Christine West 6608 West Shore Dr Barbara Houser 5708 Newport Dr Paul Carson 6001 Pine Grove Rd None stated 323,700 290/300,000 235,000 None stated The owners of the following properties submitted letters objecting to their market value and requested the Board's review: Assessor's Est Mkt Val $ 168,200 Owner's Est of Mkt Val None stated Name /Addres s Donaldfiosemary Modeen 5156 Tifton Dr Prakash Puram 6627 Limerick Dr Lee/Addie Heutmaker 6429 Margarets La Mary Louise Lockridge 6613 Iroquois Tr Bertil/Margret Nelson 6764 Valley View Rd James/Frances Huettl 6805 St Patricks Ln George Kosmides 7009 Lee Valley Cr Paisarn/Nuntiya Hungspreugs 7129 Shannon Dr Ralph/Paula Prather 7428 Shannon Cr Patrick/Susan Downey 7501 Hyde Park Av Lawrence/Daisy Erickson 5300 Hollywood Rd Natalie Lund 4816 Vandervork Av Vivan Erickson 5029 William Av Madison/Mary Sheely 5017 William Av PID Number 04-116-21-33-0021 . 05-116-21-41-0066 06-116-21-23-0013 06-116-21-31-0021 06-116-21-41-0063 06-116-21-44-0047 08-116-21-21-0074 08-116-21-24-0021 228,400 None stated 501,300 None stated 396,100 178,500 190,000 147,100 360,000 168,600 None stated None stated 359,900 None stated 08-116-21-31-0077 08-116-21-32-0043 28-117-21-23-0009 28-117-21-23-0030 28-117-21-32-0032 28-117-21-32-0035 431,800 365,000 338,000 None stated 170 , 900 None stated 236,200 None stated 90,500 None stated 125,OO 132,000 reduced to 129,700 192,400 James Tweedy Christopher/Charlene 5405 Mirror Lakes Dr Haschka 5408 Malibu Dr 6608 Field Way Charles/Sheila Davis 29-117-21-34-0035 31-117-21-22-0005 None stated 176,700 312,700 290,000 31-117-21-24-0010 265 4/10/95 Assessor's Est Mkt Val 219,300 Owner's Est of Mkt Val None stated Name/Address Daniel/Mary Hurley 6017 Killarney La Dennis/Carol Monahan 6021 View La Vivian Powless 5500 Dundee Rd Henry Haverstock 6112 Saxony Rd Phil Bohrer Don/Shirly Berg 5900 Hansen Rd Janet Koukal 5005 West 60th St Richard H. Mortensen 5328 Windsor Av Thomas/Barbara Costello 4247 Crocker Av Connor Schmid 4711 Meadow Rd Charles/Ware Washman 4508 Drexel Av Richard Cochrane/Mary Quinlivan 3922 West 49th St Erol T Uke/Karin Tansek 4410 Sunnyside Rd Daniel Evans 4404 Sunnyside Rd Norman/Marybeth Chapel 4622 Edgebrook P1 Sheilagh Ziegeweid 4615 Wooddale Av Ronald/Judith Vessey 4610 Wooddale Av Harold/Ruth Arnold 5404 Brookview Av John/Christine Kellogg 5529 Brookview Av Linda Sonn 4814 Golf Te Timothy Barnett 4612 Concord Te Dorothy Kronlokken 5909 Ashcroft Av 5900 Amy Dr PID Number 31-117-21-44-0015 31-117-21-44-0037 32-117-21-21-0020 280,200 None stated 234,900 None stated 195,000 170,000 31-117-21-22-0070 202,800 . 32-117-21-31-0051 180,200 31-117-21-41-0038 33-117-21-34-0050 212,100 101,400 None stated None stated 33-117-21-22-0074 197,600 None stated 07-028-24-42-0020 130 600 None stated 18-028-24-11-0063 146,600 None stated 267,500 125,000 18-028-24-12-0125 270,300 171,200 18-028-24-14-0014 18-028-24-21-0022 490,600 332,700 None stated None stated 790,000 18-028-24-21-0025 18-028-24-23-0058 805,800 18-028-24-24-0007 217,700 None stated 365,000 170,000 123,000 189,900 139,600 85,000 18-028-24-24-0026 19-028-24-12-0017 392,500 187,100 19-028-24-12-0150 19-028-24-22-0073 128,000 223 700 145,500 19-028-24-24-0087 19-028-24-31-0125 91,900 reduced to 87,900 109,800 Milt/Marie Binger 19-028-24-33-0044 4812 W. 62nd St 5812 Kellogg Av Cole 5920 Oaklawn Av 4621 Drexel Av 5004 Normandale Ct Jeffrey/Maureen Nalezng 19-028-24-42-0054 David Laucachick/Brenda 19-028-24-42-0103 Timothy/Susan Akers 18-028-24-13-0036 Laura Silver 33-117-21-24-0048 None stated 134,100 None stated 85,000 93,800 374,400 360 000 140,000 157,000 266 41 10195 PID Number 20-028-24-21-0043 20-028-24-23-0019 20-028-24-24-0094 20-028-24-34-0066 Assessor's Est Mkt Val 143,200 reduced to 140,900 ' 93,300 Owner's Est of Mkt Val 120 000 Name/Address Barbara A. Stowowy 5524 York Av Anne Dower Peter Monkkonen/Edith 5704 Beard Av Oberle 5713 Beard Av John Senior, Jr 6100 York Av Richard/Lillian Weekley 6824 Brittany Rd Donald Montgomery 6824 Oaklawn Av Lowen Grodnick 7120 Bristol Blvd Mohamedmargaret Eldeeb 4413 Ellsworth Dr Donald/Caryn Gj evre 7016 West Shore Dr Mark Ettinger 7007 West Shore Dr Janet Windhors t 4702 Phlox La Stephen/Doris Marchuk 4600 Gilford Dr Gladys Mitchell 7212 West Shore Dr David Griswold 6417 Mendelssohn Ln Martin/Susanne Kanter 6624 Dovre Dr Mark Schmidt 6938 Maloney Av John/Christine Carlstrom 4630 Arden Av Robert/Jane Oberrender 4919 Bruce Av Konald Prem 4806 Sunnyside Rd Norman Carpenter 5009 Bruce Av Charles/Bette Sedgwick 6517 Ryan Av David/Nancy Moore 4216 Mavelle Dr Jean Silas 4805 Trillium La Gregory Monahan 6420 Josephine Av Daniel Laurila/Karen Polacek 5905 Killarney La 3918 W 49th St 5136 Gorgas Av Richard Fischer Drew Hoag 81,200 144,900 None stated 177,800 None stated None stated 157 700 30-028-24-33-0005 30-028-24-43-0067 31-028-24-11-0062 31-028-24-13-0081 31-028-24-21-0009 31-028-24-21-0016 31-028-24-23-0053 31-028-24-24-0084 31-028-24-24-0099 30-117-21-13-0055 31-117-21-24-0052 30-117-21-22-0155 18-028-24-13-0084 18-028-24-13-0133 18-028-24-22-0052 18-028-24-42-0031 30-028-24-23-0081 31-028-24-12-0015 31-028-24-23-0008 04-116-21-24-0005 31-117-21-41-0013 158,000 None stated 218,900 None stated 182,100 188 800 None stated None stated 141,400 None stated 177,300 None stated 176,800 170,000 163 800 I None stated 180/190,000 207,700 242 500 None stated 84,300 None stated 200,000 233,700 256,000 None stated 533 500 None stated 290 000 304,700 145,500 148,100 None stated None stated 206,000 119,700 None stated None stated 220,000 242,400 130 000 I 144,800 18-028-24-14-0012 18-028-24-41-0063 124,800 104,200 41 10195 267 Name/Address Nancy Smith Carl Grimsby Brian Lambert James Wu 4228 Valley View Rd Mary/Mark Schwartz 5543 Village Dr Paulette Mitchell 7677 Wood View Ct Ila Nelson 7520 Cahill Rd #212 Robert A. Barbee Cahill of Edina Richard Nordquist H.D./Joan Elverum John/Babette Bean 3713 W 54th St 6112 Virginia Av 4005-4007 W 49th St 7400-7486 Cahill Rd 4350 Brookside Ct #204 6101 Waterford Ct 4360 Edgebook P1 Jeanne Silverman John Fagerstrom 6566 France Av #510 7005-07 McCauley Tr 6909-11 McCauley Tr 7009-11 McCauley Tr 6913-15 McCauley Tr Richard/Patricia Prudlo 301 Jefferson Av Leslee Ojala 6940 Maloney Av PID Number 20-028-24-22-0036 19-028-24-33-0094 18-028-24-14-0106 30-028-24-11-0021 08-116-21-12-0039 08-116-21-33-0065 08-116-21-42-0039 08-116-21-42-0385 thru 08-116-21-42-0426 28-117-21-21-0157 31-117-21-33-0522 18-028-24-24-0082 30-028-24-14-0060 07-116-21-22-0029 06-116-21-33-0043 07-116-21-22-0028 06-116-21-33-0042 30-117-21-22-0067 30-117-21-22-0156 Assessor's Est Mkt Val 145,300 196,200 281,500 149,200 180,600 167,300 73,600 87,200 262,200 636,200 reduced to 623,800 190,200 208,000 208,000 196,400 196,400 86,100 84,300 Owner's Est of Mkt Val 130,000 None stated None stated None stated 161,000 None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated None stated No further appeals being presented, motion of Member Smith vas seconded by Member Maetzold to continue the 1995 Board of Reviev meeting to Monday, April 17, 1995, at 5:OO P.M. for decision on the appeals presented. Motion carried unanimously. .- City Clerk MNlpTES OF THE C0lUl'I"ED MEETING OF THE EDIXA BOARD OF aEvIElJ HELD MONDAY, APRIL 17, 1995 AT 5:OO P.M., ED= CITY HAIL Answering rollcall for the continued meeting of the Board of Review were Members Kelly, Maetzold, Paulus, Smith and Chairman Richards. The owners of the following properties submitted letters objecting to the market value of their properties and requested the Board's review: 268 Assessor's Owner's Est Name /Address PID Number Est Mkt Val of Mkt Val Norwest Bank, Trustee 19-028-24-14-0031 455,600 None stated Patrick Sommers 06-116-21-34-0041 1,034,200 None stated 84 Woodland Cr 6505 Shawnee Cr No further oral or written objections to property valuations were presented. Member Smith made a motion to approve the following reductions to valuations as listed below for which the property mer or ouner's representative had appeared In person or had submitted a letter objecting to the Assessor's estimated market value as of Jawary 2, 1995: - Name Jay/Karin Addy Uilliam/Joyce Reich Eduard/Beverly Zimmerman F. Eugh/Hollie Sherry Ralph/Paula Frather Thomas/Barbara Costello Richard Cochrane/Hary Erol T. Uke/Karh Tansek Linda sonn Donald/Caryn Gjevre David Grismld Hkrk Schmidt gonald Prem Davidflancy Moore Jean Silas Daniel Iaurila/Karen Polecek Richard Fischer Drev Hoag Brian Iambert Robert A. Barbee H.D./Joan Elverum Leslee Ojala Noruest Bank, Trustee Patrick Smers Nancy smith PID Number 33-117-21-32-0056 32-117-21-34-0054 05-116-21-34-0034 31-028-24-14-0022 31-028-24-14-0023 08-116-21-31-0077 07-028-24-42-0020 18-028-24-14-0014 18-028-24-21-0022 19-028-24-22-0073 31-028-24-21-0009 30-117-21-13-0055 30-117-21-22-0155 18-028-24-22-0052 31-028-24-12-0015 ~ 31-028-24-23-0008 31-117-21-41-0013 18-028-24-14-0012 18-028-24-41-0063 20-028-24-22-0036 18-028-24-14-0106 08-116-21-42-0406 31-117-21-33-0522 30-117-21-22-0156 19-028-24-14-0031 06-116-21-34-0041 Valuation $ 150,000 172,500 195,000 140,000 141,400 365,000 123,600 155,000 481,000 189,000 181,600 195,000 80,000 523,000 140,000 195,000 226,800 130,000 118,900 133,600 265,000 225,000 240,000 78,000 360,000 985,000 Motion was seconded by Member Kelly. Rollcall : Ayes: Kelly, Maetzold, Paulus, Smith, Richards Motion carried. Motion of Hember Smith vas seconded by Member Kelly for adjournment of the 1995 Board of Review. Motion carried unanimously. Adjournment at 5:35 P.M. City Clerk I