HomeMy WebLinkAbout19990419_edina_board_of_reviewMINUTES OF THE
OF THE EDINA BOARD OF REVIEW
APRIL 19,1999
5:OO P.M.
Assessors
Est. Mkt. Value
$244,900
$255,800
$331,700
$217,500
$185,300
$94,900
$341,600
Answering rollcall for the continued meeting of the Board of Review were Members Faust, Hovland, and
Mayor Pro-tern Maetzold. Member Kelly entered the meeting at 5:50 p.m.
Owners’ Board
Value Action
Reduce to
$230,000
$230,000 Sustain
$290,000 Sustain
$204,000 Sustain
$1 75,600 Sustain
$75,000 sustain
$220,000
$320,000 Increase to
$380,000
Mayor Pro-tem Maetzold explained the purpose of the continuation meeting was to allow the Board to
take action on the cases presented in person by residents and by the City Assessor on behalf of absent
resident regarding the 1999 assessed value of property. After action by the local Board of Review
residents may continue the process with Hennepin County.
Name/ Address
obert J. Malby
The Board reviewed each property submitted and discussed whether to sustain, decrease or increase the
assessors estimated market value. Mayor Pro-tem Maetzold noted that Dwight P. Hager’s application
was received April 13,1999, after the Board Meeting. Assessor Petersburg explained that he checked
with Hennepin County and was told the Board could sustain the value on the property allowing the
owner to continue with Hennepin County if’they so choose.
PID Number
05-116-21-14-0043
Motion by Member Faust, seconded by Member Hovland to approve the City Assessor’s
recommendations, sustaining, increasing or decreasing the estimated market values of the following
properties per staff recommendations as noted
5414 Creek View Lane
John E. Elkins 08-116-21-33-0151
6517 Limerick Drive I
5428 Halifax Lane
7212 West Shore Drive
Gladys Mitchell
Nancy J. Van-Zile
~~~ I
Timothy D. Asgrimson I 05-116-21-44-0054
31-028-24-24-0099
28-117-21-23-0114
Thomas Awsumb
4703 Towne Road
Gregory G. Roth
7740 Marth Court I
18-028-24-11-0076
20-028-24-32-0065
Robert R. Pfefferle I 19-028-24-11-0039
$145,400
$370,000
$127,000 Sustain
4525 Vandervork Avenue I
580fD;ew Avenue South
Rodney J. Olson
Chris topher/ Gailen Krug 1 29-117-21-44-0036
5232 Locklov Drive
08-116-21-24-0008 $269,100
$219,100
Sustain
$208,000 Sustain
804 Kemrich Drive
seph H. Anderson
1404 Branson Street I 07-028-24-43-0059
$413,900 I $353,000 I Reduceto
Page 1
MinutesEdina Board of Review/Aprill9,1999
Assessors Owners'
Name/Address PID Number Est. Mkt. Value Value
Raymond H. Ehlers 30-028-24-43-0023 $144,900 $136,900
Board
Action
Sustain
4212 70th Street
Jacqueline S. Mithun
5308 Halifax Avenue I I 18-028-24-44-0067 $205 ,100
$170,000
~~~ $195,000 I hcreaseto I
$245,000
Reduce to Andy A. Ponaus
4909 Trillium Lane
Lowel/Patriaa Johnson
6004 Hansen Road
Scott M. Busyn
5019 Bruce Avenue
James Huettl
6805 St. Patricks Lane
James F. Gehrke
4622 Casco Avenue
Randy T. McKay
5615 Schaefer Road
Andrea Weisberg/ Daniel
Ruiman
6728 Rosemary lane
Clara Gooding
5824 Halifax Avenue
James Ostlund
5020 Normandale Court
James Voss
6300 Valley View Road
Demetrios J. Villas
5416 Creek Valley Lane
Grandview Cemetery
6901 Maloney Avenue
I $174,000 I 31-028-24-22-0074 $181,600
33-117-21-33-0049 $168,000
18-028-24-42-0036 $307,600
06-116-21-44-0047 $227,800
18-028-24-13-0022 $344,900
31-117-21-140037 $531,900
06-116-21-41-0048 $272,100
19-028-24-41-0021 $164,400
33-117-21-24-0027 $285,700
05-116-21-11-0060 $134,200
05-116-21-44-0053 $221,300
30-117-21-23-0002 $50 9/40 0
$297,200
$145,000 sustain
$260,000 sustain ,
$278,000
$215,600 I
sustain
sustain
John A. Palmer
$123,400
04-116-21-21-0054 $202,900 $177,000 Owner withdrew
$258,000
5101 West 62nd Street
C. KelseySmith
$152,300 sustain
request 4/14/99
18-028-24-22-0006 $197,100 $175,000 SUStain
I $279,000 I
4801 W. 44th Street
Marie Hidem
4007 Sunnyside Road
John J/Mary Jane. Raich
Virginia Borgeson
6613 Galway Drive
6216 EwLng Avenue
John S.Newhouse
5216 Larada Lane
4514 Edina Boulevard .
Dwight P. Hager*
$127,500 sustain
sustain
07-028-24-44-0050 $158,400 $145,500 Reduce to
$145,000
05-116-21-42-0033 $244,600 $239,000 sustain
29-028-24-22-0057 $166,500 sustain
30-117-21-43-0050 $540,000 $450,000 Reduce to
$450,000
~~ ~
18-028-24-21-0061 $822,800 $762,800 sustain
Application Received April 13,1999
sustain
Page 2
Minutesmdina Board of Review/April19,1999
Frank Cardarelle
6125 Wilryan Avenue
00 PhiIbrook Lane
33-117-21-34-0122 $412,400 Sustain
19-028-24-14-0075 $217,800 sustain
04-116-21-34-0056 $152,100 Sustain
Motion by Member Hovland, seconded by Member Faust to sustain the Estimated Market Value of
5300 Glenbrae Circle, PID No. 32-117-21-11-0023 at $320,000.
Rollcall:
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Motion by Member Maetzold, seconded by Member Faust to sustain the Estimated Market Value of
I - 5226 Green Farms Road, PID No. 30-117-21-34-0026 at $568,000. i Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Maetzold
Rollcall:
Motion carried.
Motion by Member Hovland, seconded by Member Faust to sustain the Estimated Market Value of
6805 Dakota Trail, PID No. 06-116-21-43-0032 at $699,600.
Rollcall:
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Motion by Member Hovland, seconded by Member Faust to sustain the Estimated Market Value of I
- 6109 Ridgeway Road, PID No. 32-117-21-43-0041 at $257,100. I Page 3
MinutesEdha Board of Review/April19,1999
Rollcall:
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Motion by Member Hovland, seconded by Member Faust to increase the Estimated Market Value of
5309 Blake Road, PID No. 29-117-21-33-0004 from $137,200 to $171,100.
Rollcall:
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Motion by Member Hovland, seconded by Member Faust to sustain the Estimated Market Value of
5632 Chowen Avenue, PID No. 20-028-2423-0102 at $176,100.
Rollcall.
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Kelly, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Motion by Member Maetzold, seconded by Member Hovland to decrease the Estimated Market Value
of 7200 France Avenue South, PID No. 31-028-24140001 from $2,969,000 to $2,511,000.
Rollcall:
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Kelly, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Motion by Member Faust, seconded by Member Kelly to decrease the Estimated Market Value of
5618 Concord Avenue, PID No. 19-028-24-23-0041 from $221,600 to $210,000. I Rollcall:
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Kelly, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Motion by Member Hovland, seconded by Member Faust to sustain the Estimated Market Value of
6321 Mildred Avenue, PID No. 04-116-21-22-0021 at $159,100.
Rollcall:
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Kelly, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Member Kelly moved, seconded by Member Faust to re-open the discussion on the property located
at 4808 Upper Terrace. Member Kelly asked for a clarification on the reduction of the Estimated Market
Value.
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Kelly, Maetzold
Motion carried.
Following a brief discussion Member Kelly made a motion that was seconded by Member Hovland to
decrease the Estimated Market Value of 4808 Upper Terrace, PID No. 30-028-2433-0090 from $357,000
to $320,000.
Rollcall:
Ayes: Faust, Hovland, Kelly, Maetzold
Motion carried. I Mayor Pro-tern Maetzold adjourned the Board of Review at 6:lO P.M.
Page 4