HomeMy WebLinkAbout1959 10-07 Planning Commission Meeting Minutes Regular4050R
i;1Z,-ET1V(3) il':LD
OCIUBER 7, 059, AT 0 PO4 XN THE
EDINA VILLACE HAII.
�rrinys Prosent: T* L. Todd, Chairnax Q. Hiatt. 0c 6. Lewist John
F,I,, Ane Vb, djjkj�gnn; G:�-qn C, Hite, Plynning Direr -
to ivy o 01yran C, Hyac. �I&Wge _v. ti
V,nujen nj the meytlng of soptamhei 9th wc.w approwed on motion, seconded
1. ZONING CHANGE MUFSTY
1-09-16, IN
Request wos
to chnn;e tho zorKC of An Dvir at !,00 �'Jfsst 50th Street
f�am C"pon Dcvclopment to Autemobile Packing District.
My, h. 2. Ellingson, Senior Warden oF a Stephen's Episcopal Church,
cresented nnA read 0 letter from the Chuich, requesting the rezoning.
George Hite then presented potition; ruimitted by 27 propexty owners
in the neighbonhood, requesting ACL the pyopetty not be rezoned, which,
Fr. Todd read to memberA ond nudienn&
it., Q,,tenj,, who lives diresti; croon wo arnat from the Darr houte,
said he felt thot a wking int an the 9pzuperty would increase the
Accident rote an 501h Uvento
Cth,, p,Stjt,rS, all uf whom yhjected is Lhe vczoning, were Bill Eagaw,
4902 Brunel Peyry Mcoruo 4215 Country Club Road; Tom Newman, 4908 Bruce;
Curdelte Durst, 4906 Orume; Er. k0onnA6. 4900 Bruce; Robert Fischer,
422i Countil Club Ropd; Dnn Hey, 4914 Bruno; and Wenvy Car eon, 6 Edinn
Court,
Dick dill?, who submittod n Uttey Ln6knovinq if..: he had a purchase
ngneoment EC7 Ke P1,111Y if the 0000 awn UV010 to awarcise its
option. Qd th.L &K None nV� M 400"InN 13mark in ;he Village
if Edina 3rd th"t if hn naronnseu K, he w3uld mAnipin it an a private
home,
11. Ellingscs said the "Qu& perking lot 1, 2oAilwle to them an week-
��:16,j du uge Uj bot plot thein is G onflint on week days 60
nlghtv
After 110ening Lo all A tha ye"*Ons PTOOM&I YQv 6nd Pgainst the
razcning. K. FoIny slic he felt PAYM.'",riq .,-o
houid iook at
the property and hava mofe KAQ�S "00001or On the traffic A"
len. Pjj 3nd COQ aOd MM,& th-L 10 yk�jYy� A w0ed for futther
stujyv Theia wus no . nd K thj_ Y&Knfton kurtit Cyr discunslon�
-i moved tu ytri y ihlAlon ku kna Council with the
th,t pj ... in, ocnmissive oi)j givo it further study an6
,,k . . ........ d,licn 40pcz; 0he n,yt Cou"zi2 ywatAnq. Seconded and
yKrvia&
001-0 00 v1shrick" or- 112o1€en wa,�
OvsenT and vsked tc he a !coed to OAK &UYU QUY01OWS, one svor,�,
high, on this pyoperty. SAM2 &YOU iv 00 UWW� to this property..,
vnti"j WaS MR& by Hloij, IC -C&06 by ZKOM,r, 00 Carried K lefe-
�4i. a.. kei to Planning Qircrlsr 7pj viijage nyinenr for funAer si&,,
0 ac -o t nci, t':P5i taiValley View Road and
�duth o thine i+ -pile Cr,-Lt:y Y:'GI^ �:L`-on Devolc mon to Multiple Residence
District:. This Mas tu•zined down, but motion wras made ty Hiatt, seconded
by Leiiis and carried to record approval of a preliminary plat for
residential K7Urpose5 only.
4 c: V59-21, Ft�.EED, 1orthweest cornor of 'Highway 169 and 100, from Open
Development to Office Building Dis-irict. lir. and h s. Freed were both
MrOsent and were told that in erder to comply with the necessary set-
he,cks, a building on ;,his lot would have to be no more than 16 feet by
75 feet long. The plan called for a 30 by 95 foot building and the
Freeds felt they could cut this to 24 by 90 feet, if necessary, but no
less. Motion inns then mode by Le,, is, seconded and carried to table for
P
urther study.
5� %-59-22, DAVE Tf•iCrrAS, property at 5410 Franco Avenue South, from Open
Development to Multiple Residence District. The plan as presented was
for a 10 unit apartment building. After consideration, motion was made
by=Wilkinson, seconded by Foley and carried, to recommend approval.
i7. ZOT;INGVARIAh?Ci:Fc VEST
1. 1�-59-30, E RtRt?_CA.PPLI, p operty at 6108 Xorxss Avenue Youth. The request
for a �s foot projection into the required front yard setback. Motion
made by Wilkinson, seccrded by Hiatt and ca2rried, to recommend approval.
; 11. SP,:,IAi FEMMIT APPLICATIONS
. F-59-7; TEXLV Q, TtdC ;, property at North -.Vest corner of 70th street and
Franz,e Avenue. Request was for permit for Gasoline Service Station.
Robert abb v#aS csesent and said this &i j't.ion had Ce n in the
SouChda,le blaster Flan for G long ti.mE. It would he directly ccross
from the St6ndard Ser -,,,Ice Sr 4ition on the so=.a�.hti:est corner. Motion was
rade by Wilkinson, seconded by Foley z;nd carried, :o recommend approval.
1V. PREL.IMINARv_ PLAT rR.F: R�;VALS
io 5-59-53, RUTHJOG FNSCN ADDITION, in Peacedalo Acres. This proposed plat
contains lots or less than the required minimum depth and was held over
frorl the September meeting aitch instruc:tiors that the Johnsons try to
purchase the Cutlot to the west of their property, which Chitlot could
bo added to the shallolra to is 4e hring them to legal size. Mr. Johnson
Teporied that they had been uno? )cc,,srful in tho r �ittearsp•ts to secure
•ths Cutlot. h1r. lliil.e, indicating :hot in his opinion ;:he tears of both
the Johnson offer ar:d ti.e Qut.lotc otjnofs. asking price as disclosed to him
were- both unreasonable, recommerded that the plat we once again tabled
and that both the ?ahnsons and the McClellans (owners of the outlot) be
informed that neither of thoir plats would be zpproved by the Commission
until the question of the Cutlot had been resolved. moved
that this recommendation be a.cceNted. fir. Foley seconded and motion
carried unanimously.
• :-59-05, "-'F';_a"!_11- ',,y Foley, seconded by Wilkinson
nd weywed "� inscmmand upprovali
MAKATIF99. Asp Fbtion by Hiatt, second -
A 1v Moy 2rd cDroled, to tneopmand unproval,
4, 3-59-55f Evfcn by 01kinson, seconded by Foley
znd carried, to ronommend appyovei,
V. 111% FLIN A&ROVAIR
This plat conforms to
'!ha pteliminsw pyesented earlier, End ppproval nas recommended an motion
by Kilkinson, sencndad by Foley and caTricd.
2.
TAQ plat ocAfwyms to the prelimineryg which
nos sppraied in aeptcaher; and zpnivyL? A the final was recommended an
votion of WMIrson. sectnoed by Hiatt vK casKed.
Y. >59-42, jj2SLQTM, ADD XT WN.
Ms plat was nZ approved in prv.IM;:a Bre by Planning Commission
Ono theislore, they cocir kot recowmand approval of the
100 plat. N action taken.,
Thlo y 0 Y so conforms to the preliminazy
nsesented c8TnInw: opd appisM Y�s woc:nmundad on motion of Wilkinson,,
by"Indsd hy HIM Ono caysico.
.'.c " "
kill, Double norysion �Nn fuv 6124 France Avenue South. Or'
Geosge HMOs this plip �as zpproved on motion, second
ad and ice' orrind.
MI- 019TRIUMA_
MYN a '�" -_,, "t
''kmille Sotythwho
vas noitinq tc ask Of wqyroval N P how.0 plan on a 90 foot Nt he hopes
to Wild on. who HOU61 Uns 72 foot lung and would require a 2 foot vari-
yanc Ar s&570. '�. Craig ;nAd Q0 hzj.e would cost hin betveon $42,000
M 555yON to 066 ant aoww-inn YQ: !Put such a huase needed at least
Knimpu 6M >PK wha&,. Qlitvi > �.ny the rzq2nst was then made by
�500, sounwd& �y MhAnson
10 onkrep yo, x of ig TO Tongue of women Votersm,
-_�O= Ono yab 0406duuw 1
102ting adjournA at 10:10 P'N"
PoInSCATUIly suhnittedl.
Qvnvgu C. Hitet
Flyrning DWYK00 I