HomeMy WebLinkAbout1970 06-03 Planning Commission Meeting Minutes RegularMMUS OF THE OF
TIE EDINA PLANNING COMMISSIUN HELD
WPUMSDAY, ME 2, 1970
EDI,`41A VILLA.GE W%M,
N-_'ber,eG P2; es VY. Lewia, Chairman; Clifford Johnson, George Nugent, David
Qvid sherwaa, sawlel Hughes, =6 Robert Huelster.
Staff Present; 7red MoWnyon and lynnee Marla&
i� Aggynn-l-A-MY-0-19TO Wassa,
NO. Nugnal made a notion to approve the Icy 6, 1970 Finnning Commissin
11'in-,'i s; 1Aro JohnszR seconded the vonivvll Voted PIC. Motion Carl:
17, WKWO
-an,
va
in, Heiningtvu, renowiai IML Ri,.xi Ct-.Yl. AL�, in need of additional
pnTking aad vistas zo �wmova the W,_. e at 6726 ivrx= Avenue South, uUM it
hns nornd Mr sevesal years, for thiv yurpose. V aisc intends to extend tW
000ting PCMUS Mt W W WSM&Y Manign on the property already zony.,
W KnMeMKI.
se %dican? too, MW too In the ayaa consists of a raw of
eaveral 507r?n to 00 20rV Alung xarxco, Vingle Kwily homes eaet of XCAM;
in Richlimn, 70003 W6 cc the scuth nc z',Test. He addedho:
zoniap nansaws of M �V the aarTh r',[& to Ma anoth and wosil
&MCK WeparAnd QW ths McKie& Planning
Wportonna >" i.t,.... _.- in. a;7zawont with this roquum, providing adequM�.
2crneninn in 72ovidee. as Qntam&02 Farkinn z*Quz mould be consIaLent wich the
the Poo" ti be unlefl=a UAVY conarchissivc Uan.
Hr aigbas nn%wd 11 all the hourco cn We west side of Xerzc-', Q
this arra uAll avantusKyW parti. Mz. Aris%gtou replied that they prw-
wily wit! he, as auvansi ah M Wngon oa tole block are =0 by Red Owl saj
Lautal"s A14 Mv %QPrVWCA;.'
K. KbAcr wool mat tin n110001 Wn R-1 WYMUMal Dist in.._
to anunobKo Finnn; Qlmowl,z on appwai.e it, Ow 0 jlcuiug revs�ns:
1. AaramnMe ;a&,,; inning 1! A lazzon! extypiYa of tQ
=IMnunvarlynh ZIMME to CIO Uns!'r
Aorc2nQlu nuzhln� -U� wv,w an no w?!a.qrQre b"Kfer & I
V�v M-107Knn &Ve 7qv'a. :1 VArn Owl 0? PICAUCOM!
W Aichvy�:-
3,; Sue!, ruzoning agree�ri Tn-th p-.-oposed Richfield City 1 -1 n -
•,.; ', 'C Xerxes t S
Vhe residential use on thna aest rAde. A rxes m L t be
and A-ii,cnmci"ill Parking District secus
to be as
Nugeat secon.ded the moclo+!. All Voted Aye. -Motion Carried.
MrL DIVISIONS
C'iarles S__%s t. :.at
hlock .4� '"11.11dalc� Addition.
Mr- hoiBing�-mt th:,'t C-ill�i T`-Visioii of, rx lot into two
pazcc;ls 'AxcA11," beent d.'Iiacusne-."' al- tlla M'n", 6" 19Y ) ii*'Laaaing comaiseion Oeetiaz' arid.
.:h'sz chv' '-aj ,.i e'.., it be detii4L-d. He stat, ----.d
Lhe 1L."'Vt's would 'Iil"a tl: �: avll,. tl:eir sSF for the .l at division at this
z'' t h,(--.- v we, --4r -, u, t. -a r e s e i- cEf> isU a' Ia., m e c! and f e they were
ted
mr, U.oyl- atz'ted 'i:h'iL 11'. ;,m-',TWTs ,:he rf�svricOons -Uthe deed on this
8-'te ota-"m-t :Jnat Only one huuse be on each pnrcel Lut feeI t t
cz,�xno-, apply uAnder C'n-10itf.olls, as lie ajns lot 1, rlj�por-
-s r
-;On of 2, �'rld �"" por'u- ttrceL �!-!at Y -jai latcr v;�).catei Lo them
t the
til::- ori�-imal I'Lt 1. He added that it
VOU]
1'). di-'JI.C."A 1h,,-,,z;e v.,; Oie p`x:opaty is fneseatly platted
f�r Iuozber Fe noted that
r
hey ha�'�e b Of afre�.�: the 10L ie� divided,
t"Icy 0-'-!-n :6c' .--tN1ULLVU'wents 1•rr a lot.
11011--e been, bel—It so 61.0se to the
o�:ig-i-,al cajc.,.er had mrned� both
In, t v% "Ktr . dt �"k
13ts and 4 a il'.i�a.ngruld% s;-il L'Ot 2,
R�'?myr-.-Bse'LatJ Oct v-arald be created kwi P. result
o" ts-'J'z bmail:2-r t1wan rill the other lots in this
16-' fl-r.)Pt froutage, 336 foot depth
J'.7?:h ca th-4 z1orth extremity. Mirs
11'1 = p':I4at'-A pi. rcel Ck' laud, She added
a.1.1 side�i, their ent-i�re
th.e fact thut 1 --he
o'-.he:tr rwsid,�ntii in HDA
41
wi3.`1 not also be. div
the res-trictj
1U, i4j.1.1dale, I
Ite
le
ed.
r,
June 3, 19 10
Mr. johnnon agreed .:hat the new let that Pould be creRted =
be cousiderably SUARr than Lhe other lots. wAnh is why the neighbors Q
objected to We divinion. Mrs. Hoyt replied tha, they do not want to dent
the characm of the neighborhood and feel than it will be improved. She
added tkat is different buildery have told her that the new At will be a
buildable W. Mr. Nugent ugreed that the AL is buildable, and Mr. Lew0c
stated that he, too, agrees WAt the lot is adequate but AM that the dc
restxialc= ca:.' act he jgvured.
ld
vGr
ry
Ho. OAS= asked A their WghbvrE agree that the property will.
be Improved, and Mrs. Hoyt answered that all but two do approve. She stated
that she did not know wly thay disapprove, a8 oua iaa a lot of only a 320 foot
frontage and Cho 004'.y AU a lot 0 K65 feezo rei,,.her r. 'W 'Which the back part
Is deqelaped
Hr johnson Wed if the lot dlviaiaa ca= be approved, knWing
about the PautzlWays, Mr. RnAingnon replied rhat the reptrictions do not
uean thot rho Village cannac act an a request, but that if they and the Council
divide L lot Su xectricced, they cvnld become a party to an illegal act should
litlgaclan eusua.
W Wvou, who <..ian acrons tba nwa&t from the lots in qu(Ttion,
szated thaL AD in rat -.),-.'Iy .-I W batisfynng Mr. 6 Hrz. Hoyt, but that
It establiphts u t,vcedvvi-, coiariupit y, und Wels thatthis might lead to,
dividing aooKhen ton lots in the aynwhich are uuitable for subdivisionIf
,
the rearricnoua &re ignorad. He unted that unless an engineering firm mere
CUnaQW, W dA LK feel that the Porob cad ut the RL W quesclon prQdef,
a buildrble Wt Loss d on An coodifinns which were prefent at the time the
Hoyt's houFa wnr unift.
Hr Wg3at asked whi"hei KY oull be , buildable lot and A,
Hoisfngtca 7cpYew that At YaN, a :all chn any drainage problems could be
OUMWLed. MC AnEnvt stotad that he Wc that .:she lot is adegucte, buildable,
in aucurdanev wnmh other At divisiune in oWeT nzeas in the Village which have
alao had dew roUrAzAcua trait: ha bccr r!sulyed. and does meet the minimum
lot He Wood than he ;=A to in favor of Wo lot divisiod.
10. buyvae yv>YA L%vL 0 dcow ocm ?gree nn that Lbe moot recent
anUQns by AL � W Wal C�wv wan A- al be;- not so divide luom where a_. ilk'.
PlatUnh to (hUlsished, 8v Ao c�!d we!r bnWS worEvanted vith other Lot divi--
!Was 10 G-zr nVern W1 wilt not On an WAA as thie one iow appeara to be.
On jnt uc=6 of thi jo, divizion, h"L for lack of s1
A� AnJaL ow-ap W.v v ir_ HAvinnes be OEAed. Mr. Loans=
scce0q" Wo VC 70�. A:i "O.& Y"; %4OPY Mr. tfs-,°Ced :;ty. 1,;
sheyl.n 1W�-Tnv d rZI ohn d0z"Y ;W' "CC an hcricn carvied.
Edina p0nuing cumnivs1n.1 & I junn 3, 1970
2, Stephen title and W. Q Sharpe, -,,Js 2S,gQ29.,
rden Acres.
Mr Doington repuyecd that this division is cne of a double
bongaW IscatEd on Benton Alenue immediately cast of the HN & S rallroae
tracks, nQ recRiled that thn Planning Comminsion had recommended the rezoning
of tA 15 3 1 to about a year ago.
He indicated tuat Mz. Lir, Lisle and MSharpe would such like to
Own bull of the lot In questioa so Kat they can have homestead axemptions on
both holvaz A the house. Hz. Sharpe will . n that part of Lot 28 lying st
of th" zzlircad wight-af-uay aad tva east 24.5 feet of Lot 29. Mr. Lisle ill
can the wesc 98,5 feet of tha mast 125 fact of Lvt 29.
Mr Nugent wav& Chat the lot dAulsion be appravod, and Mr.
KOM swca"Ud thd mutton_, All YKA Ays. Hotiou Carried.
...',..a,.3 s.. T. 'jt%, Auto
dir's Subdisio
lyn No.,161.
_ 2
Mr H0161m9tor puiarK ruz that the parcels in question are the
SOUL410; helf of Lot 22 and Al u! Lot 21, which is 180 feet by 50 feet wide,
HC Enacaw vo.t "h-tc, Cho sauch helf of Lot 22 is by-!,,
ying f,0 t 21, includAnn
the Imnsa, snA noWN like to doom a !Qw 100 fact frca the street, divide that
part OU Oox, 23., adl it oc his backyard. Re indicated that this is
a, situactco. as Mr. Lindberg's present lot is naly 90 fact by
01 font, wh7ah leaves U01" or no huckyald area,
Ar, HHis ington stated that while Lot 21 would be of inadequate
depth, it ,az Z NO late vaild have a bank7wrd; at tho present time, only
Lor Al 030" HI Kded that Q0 KC 0C tS LO SUI the aartherly 100 feet of
Let 71 at n 22wr dnty
Ar Qmynn %qutrad wa La whick d0ection ca houses face, and
it Anx,tan0ci popkind t% Ae hcav� on V42 suath side of Lot 22 faces tl'E whila yh� Oune ou who OeLl anrz & LoL 22 wK an Lot 21 both face West
5treav,
do 0&00;
Odi
atwa Ant no KUM
CMA41,
be Znlil',, on the 2i C3 l
Ad,
of Yva 2! U V
fQ154f
�wn
hncv�hv Get,
AV no etonet
access, and no
bUDAMg
P21MIL WO.16
0 Or
W :or n Van!
;0 Uc bulls
an a Prime alley.
On! 042 lot
G ;Asinu ba
approvcd subject to
the
on,n0vt Ky
V.
hlnob,ow
ok Lcc 71,
Fr. Ronyse
swconed the motion.
d
±a:
��. lzy�elw
Q qaac:lon ere
jp7all,
I" A Unuc
AGO& split cAistinj
lawl
to
nfa 1" cc thel
b�
Kin
in they
r. ;VYC1% )04
all C2 the late 011
-
be
wn V
r
I . itine 3, 1970
ylr� - .,Sc. j_c , " , t
be approved,
,snd 'Ar -l-r
�'� . , �;. , Zl �J. IN i1_11.�. Jc;.!rd 1',y a Met'lor. Carried.
5 Illnj �:;_ . -n rrvs 1.
l'i• Lct-. 2, Blac"l, I Col,
Mr. iloisington repo-f:tad that t'Of.! Plauning CcTmRission had bee
confron'--el �Atl, lot "Avisiol cibuull yMars Ego' aEell the request:
was to of2 32 f"-, t of Lot 1. Th;2 strect wa,,.i then added to
Lt crear� *r_tz 104, tqa fee- leuo ti -ac tl1 - c=rlgival lot. he notedl khat the
Ito awl ti-_-st e.house nc4,.i occupic,':7
Via? iw 113 foo -l- ij-.Ldc.
indl.�-axe:l Omt Kiiclali is new asking for
Z+`'::. E' of L (, , I i to
_�;ozixn a dl.vicle Yut Y_ �`20 ';`efitt a,,,�,i: f,
ta; 0 d ib I c e I s i, c: � a:$1 V f; tL s c0 r, o -;, I d 1, L 1 3 d e d
be built cz each loL. 1'
all tlic east 76 fe-i; ol
bi 4.,nd of Lctr� -1, _,md 2 UnLj.,I.
-dma
yor
thtc
4OU10, 'Y"irk out
Mr, Yl,Ic�lli was T"- i�ald thc- deed is
E;
wl I Fe stated
will "c_,11 -is to aad ifAIL probeb',VV
Yun our
u, -I_ U Suct" as this
c .- t
L'. 7 t,pi" s cacL� t h -0 rs
to Lim s but in thol
U,t
om. that
j
1, ' "kie d,T,!estj'
c they
7_`
Snan 3, 1970
OCKWA for OnKaj; parjoyan 1=131 YNO paxnal. As a rasult, the plat Is
Vill Cho Undilicalica Eon and approval by
MM"Zon,
that tha yrulUdnery plat be approved, and
IN. dchnocn rccordad Me moNo". AW� Vc—nd-. !Ioticri Carried.
W MsInStcr soated Sat the pAnt Is located at the northwe
COrnOr Of �YWM LA NLU NO Mom and A n previousQ unplatted parcel
He indAnted that the exist - 3 house accopias the corner and that the Into
is to divida off n 100 fact by 200 foot St an the back side.
Hr. ..lvtor iiond that the preliminary plot be approved.
Mayna scacOW As Yukon. All Mad hya. KnUen NOW.
Addition -
St
Ut
I
W Bvisington roycNel that this in a two let plat on Dakota
TeST 1�vt ncrt& A Shaonua Qrem, out tha; the capography is co severe that
L:. nould ho axtrwizly Mficrlt to b-ild a house on beth into. He noted that
Se zoblng 70-1) p=y5to such devaWmant but Lhat extreme caution nuat be
01mycips" az far wA SraWas in conahned.
A. 03nnf AnIUML AW ac M, zwnj satLaQ, and Mr. Evisin'ton
1.
yq-21 .10-0 ANS, it Wapopdo on t�o e�n NAishes wheO, in dhe Would
p1mbably Q 51 QAT no ON q�SR-
Q. UnWinjo. ?"no too. ion U. CSIQ71111 was unable
2V�ZQ -in PSIZ0110f �;U SRI& PC n_SP nree tu too MY
He. lowN evenot Qat n� �Qclnviav ;,06 to WIN until
to
A.
Notan Monty thn: RIO
YAWK!" ic apfroved
subject
E0 pr
annUcas
USA ywolosd
az lot ri YZAIrz
is
connernoc
en" cubject NU
Opp
of Ae IMAKU
lslinl
QrAz&
pl:7F,
Ar. AWnsQa �vcond&
Lha uc=n.
All Voted
Ays.
Q. UnWinjo. ?"no too. ion U. CSIQ71111 was unable
2V�ZQ -in PSIZ0110f �;U SRI& PC n_SP nree tu too MY
He. lowN evenot Qat n� �Qclnviav ;,06 to WIN until
to
Wins . in- :01 WAA_""1311
june 3, 1970
M. HUNLEM Vdlvatae Wt this property is located aast 4
AWOMM want of Highway MU. saj corth of Leon Avenue. He statod that il
10 a MU c_ al! trian36!.lnr piecz of land zhat remains after a taking by 0
HT9110Y DaPY12mant fuum tun wrWo of an all Registered Land Survey, and I
the rmnals of tha parcel in quawlen are rcquesting a proper legal dascrQ
Vvn of Wo &W
W. MWOL navzd 1-yrovY of W aevLa-.d S-jrvay
3n.cads, too action M 7=1 Qt. PP,, Carried•.
UTEM
Hr, hYSMUKUn iscallse Me 10 han been naaFly a year since
plinning Wylssjun a?Provad Cho PZSMMBI'Izy ^t, 1i for tha Oscar Roberts M
Mah is luca:& Vandislely zoand W Qn! Inset ane ucat of France Aveni,
MC AP&COW ShYW 040 WISP11 WnMalla QUIM ZLW MAW to approach the
Fjornin 00�,Wcfov =6 a now Zan rannesafri Rhic qrsparty, and would
La 00116 0 OL17CL 171111LV CS On yootcr& r�3; 17 ocres oE the Roberts
qcc;yrry'
Z'
the
Q. EntuAnyton Gov Lno;Juuzd
Hr- 109M naved mr,azi
�Y. nM Nygaard, the
suhhvt
to
the ludication of land I
ZVOWay ruiltace
nud subject to
an agZalwaso
fabala&o ,,.'.FT
Mat
the Village will not be
requizad Cc
weirtain this roadway
wnV1
such
time
ra the road is builM,
to. VMS=
UCCOWUL the motion. All
Voted
Aye.
Mocian Carried.
M. HUNLEM Vdlvatae Wt this property is located aast 4
AWOMM want of Highway MU. saj corth of Leon Avenue. He statod that il
10 a MU c_ al! trian36!.lnr piecz of land zhat remains after a taking by 0
HT9110Y DaPY12mant fuum tun wrWo of an all Registered Land Survey, and I
the rmnals of tha parcel in quawlen are rcquesting a proper legal dascrQ
Vvn of Wo &W
W. MWOL navzd 1-yrovY of W aevLa-.d S-jrvay
3n.cads, too action M 7=1 Qt. PP,, Carried•.
UTEM
Hr, hYSMUKUn iscallse Me 10 han been naaFly a year since
plinning Wylssjun a?Provad Cho PZSMMBI'Izy ^t, 1i for tha Oscar Roberts M
Mah is luca:& Vandislely zoand W Qn! Inset ane ucat of France Aveni,
MC AP&COW ShYW 040 WISP11 WnMalla QUIM ZLW MAW to approach the
Fjornin 00�,Wcfov =6 a now Zan rannesafri Rhic qrsparty, and would
La 00116 0 OL17CL 171111LV CS On yootcr& r�3; 17 ocres oE the Roberts
qcc;yrry'
Z'
the
Q. EntuAnyton Gov Lno;Juuzd
�Y. nM Nygaard, the
attorney
fabala&o ,,.'.FT
..A;
n;! nr 0, -
An OWF-0 Planning QnQuan,
On nNykelu the intent
ofthe
WWI
to On YA-U-Mg W 42010U. -
AT. PQ110 sWul ",� W ch, : 2K his nQued papers fan We
Z!�. pool ilty wl: 1 K a 7n.J &I . W aw plans x sell their
-r a too V; a 1��w a W0 C zo �04 � ski "tv� ]� a W yelazan, in Edina. h,
heon P�h duen on PC,
n�w. Ez neind Tat the waD_,.
1 f a C A is L:
10 4W.
r,
vv
ny. WA5.A 010"Yal to to Ma Volnut luning In this locatil
'T.2 4C. WINEM raphlod zhat it Q prer"I.iY v0ped H-1 with the exceprJ
11 �a� NE 101=0. WAY21 in 17nad C-1 ne 'Una Chao Kba planting and rez:
N�o Via holy Yn eua cc nAr wornIsHum on Q,zrtmaut nevoninge, which is I
a 1 100W ' Q I , 1570,
0
18,
Hr, Vicno wkef Nj F... nu an OWNWes U11 he in uan, an.
than Avocb offnea and various chura".1
n7FrVnM"WS Q�w M•AVOW -Ovid on 7MUS! eva7yeay by the fall time Secle-
w . y Q, rf aye W all day wundrT 4 y wo Acqs membein of the congrega-
Mov. i
& Wy�Oryvnd Enruld RuhVICS, an"
oil. W v -vtog Slav won PX&AML; ary
toonow dZw lot
ca':-
W
Yix=w Mquirod
thn Planning Committee is
whoWnr
ahnreh
�WASQWV.
a C'nIZOU
VA WISQ1,
Id W.
Dy"aSUB MCKId Wt MMLSO they
0
3.,r ..,.7,..& M
W.
1 .1 ;W calls Orly for zhe Church
yon'
�,n anwaY ir 7tWidir-
to am
oncenalan to rex7v an TvQ11Ljv,;
W A ;,WZ Y3. TIC
Al z! a
: evW10111 QUIStive
L
vlv� qoz
P:Aryczad
51.
OWKS 4"d Inqaenned zut
I nUnj
yt �W�!I:ICW77
+-
t_ ,. III ,
Cn7 Urpli
like to UUbStertielly is /.,
7
Mv7M wcv1d n -r
UK to
aea thn crea which U09 to hy
10MI6
-:1
-0%& 7110 "M
x nhty�
ANWOM access cc WUq; 7206''
xx�
NOW
7cy Nw. Univingn
a VM,4-d
that In eSnenae, W Plu
rin'g
�:o IV .000130W "10
;ire
��n jW toe 1clation nk C04t
ni
V7
wrn,v7nol 0orl:10
yz.
of the rIMMInnow PW
;Ing
7a�
z A �, � - : n 1. :
;I iry
7 viVnz Wt _e, Wo tM thark
W;
ps
�47V; :40 hu�a,;
ij rc
Z. -O who people in too vaighbCTISM
z
0 ;. Any nv ON
ink%
W, Planning C.InAgnsaa awarl
&W
01 0
U
Solp
of yln
'rsion b"Icz, any noo .a
i.
& Wy�Oryvnd Enruld RuhVICS, an"
oil. W v -vtog Slav won PX&AML; ary
toonow dZw lot
ca':-
W -S Nlaw:v �" Kne �, 1570
AT. 8"Um 5010a 01 "30 "010% . A enuo, wtaW that the ghwor,
!an! sure ;:Nt the WrO wav3d be Ywy bwir!07. but that the men from W:
Alraj2poij, Qayv� Tconnnacw oust jkwu unjoisLacd Sat the prownt prelinjuar;
plaa xproyints R Izest anal of time and afNTr on Lho pnrt of a great MOVY
POUP10 HD "OdUaW LW V, KOCZ4W janvnr to zicar to :.ho poopk W the
naighbOVOW, Los than to NOW that whary de
4�tl be a grcar al of Objuction
from Sew it Lhn plan !a Owped. Ua zW& Mat 11`we Ug,0.r-,,zt t�w
churG, but Quo rhe Qlanaing wosidez the Lraffic NOW lhe
11-1, 11 A KnsUy ckvarAnu, So fact that Mr. nVerra did nG, appear to We
AN WitiV requW, =C thr W tiot W f. ,h. ii. sl
COMW to pturnot to the Rapaing cvamisoion-
Mr, Dean j111jaws *E 712; 1 lon7inettr Orrue, t
sateu at ma
th�,w
PWOON 07 Orhn& aun: yeann to ccv,!wr too Y101w, rrellYnary p1w, w; Ow
it !!are ,O W- ZA; Zoo ; 0 �Flh SLOO S WAKq W 0 �nQrZ Py"COE� UVCr QIJI.
Ar. 7-: or 1�nts- tAnt On Ono 11�� CwU!wSL ln wx W- Q SKAInA W fnel!k y "0'
th, Onvy w,O& have to men jw; wlm� W &06 plc&Lvi YeAlwa UK 001" M"�
W. w -W -4ca Soloo t Ot till -or; gu=A. 05
na : an Ap C 1 w I ; V a y " en n . 1" W. r7berw
V 'Carl za 0it Se Knanly PPLI:�n,v. vm� be PRO aw�ly •of Wi
ENO n lot L: levacsw �01 U! -k _. a — HMO. 4L
LOU 17 0 to 1 AV w sz, bul-in1cw 30
-OWW Lin P�
aw. Owz 41 Wwef 110 1
ww,v ou� NAnZ Lo w -"VOW V'. 1
phn
-!A :SYS
•
1 1 1 �v � , -,. i . L6