HomeMy WebLinkAbout1970 07-01 Planning Commission Meeting Minutes RegularHUUTES OF THE PEOULAR MEETING OF
THE EDINA ?LANNING C.0�-,-AISSTON HELD
WHINann, my 1, 1970
ED&! VILLAGE FALI.,
Hambaro Present: W W. Lawis, Chairman; Robert Hualster, Samuel P. Hughes,
Cliflard johnson, David Runyan, and David Sherman.
Sta2f Present: Fred Hoisington and Lynnae DeJarlais
t -"!<i 'C '
Cc
Minurs2s and apoval Of
PM-
JUM, lunytes.
Mr. Nualsoer moved that the June 3, 1970 Planning Commission
Ainurns ba a?proved no submitted, and that the May 6, 1970 Minutes be
norrened as follovs:
1. Reg a";;; the Pnotcm, inc. rezoning request and the Fire
Siam tinn on page 69 paragraph 2, the Minutes presently read
as failcos: "After conwiiurab> discussion, Mr. Lewis moved that the fire
aminn be lccahcd on the Fewon property and not in the park. Mr. Runyan
seconini the motion." They should ba corrected to read, "After considerable
diocunsion, Mr. Lewis c0le? for a motiot'i --and Mr. Nugeno moved that the fire
naticn bs located n4 themtom property and no; in the park. Mr. Runyan
seconded the moLion.'s
2. RegardLug the request by Charles S. Hoyt for the division
of Lot 1. Block 4, Hilliale Addition on page 7, paragraph 2, the Minutes
presently rend vs Wilaws; "Liter Wrtherdiscussion, Mr. Nugent moved that
the lot divib
sion e .'e ni. Rue
ed. Mr.. 'Rue o
tecanded the motion. All Voted
ANa, Mnien W&W." They should be curvected to read, "After further
discu2sion, Mr, Nugeut mo,, d thar the lot divIsTan be denied. Mr. Hughes
seconded the motion. All Yeted Aye, except It. Auelster who abstained.
matioz carried.'
Mr. johnson seconded the motion. All Voted Aye. Motion
Carried.
QN-y" K" "JUMETS
et and Tracy
Avenue.
Ia. KKsAngton
rep=P0
that Femtum has encountered
some
wnvir2 sQU problems
an the 3:i i_., to
he devaloped and as a result
has
ch.ti npd its concept plan
Kcm fnr� townhoure
clugters totalling 94
units to
YY4 t_wohwynn 2WIn7a
Wvlhipg 71
En indicated that the
Staff
Telo ? "qy ;:Olnin"Yy
4z��Twa v"n 0
v�?�p Qnc� the concept had
changed.
FW � ;jK"SnVA An � n oylcv:
1 U
h"Y n illy Wth at 7:30
P.M. to
znr sy WY, innayina onj
�kL ovz-01 qoK�n;7cnt
yinn at the samn
time.
TQa Tn=ww; Elf saisaiw',_
July 1, 1970
ATZar cvaral questions, Nr Baghes mn7ed that a special
ncwtv�q of tha 4Acting coamiscia" ba held on 30Y US, at which time
cA2 rizounz fr"n 7-1 to FlannU Residential District and the Overall
revalopmont finx will b2 sonaid=ad. Mr. Huclater seconded Che motion.
All Voted Aye. Notlov Carried.
'2-! Residentin! District to R-3 and R-4 Multi
I&. Roisingto" Wervoi thm this req; eot has been discussed
uricinj times jvt it ha Won mo i. recently convidered in regard to density
and the number of units allovcd per nexe. He pointed out that according
to the Warn Winn Plan the area nearev the residential properties ou
Nalret DyKa 20"H have a density Pa ginater than four units per acre and
nyw& in the snea vast sherefrov the density should be no greater than
':+ ..._'1. UNtS P07 WEO, PC ineiLaWd thW, including the land that is to
evAjoLand on &P 7111agn2 there Vould be 20 units Q townhousen nearest
r-otoontiz! youporojes with most of t& remvining land near the townhouses
h1ju7 jefn vaca1z, Ke ned& thpt the= shoold Le 300 uaits west of the 20
n,nyh7jac up0r. He furthnr WdIcaced that P.C.H. feels that there should
VP y1nut 305 UnWo in Wt 7atter luaati=
Y�. Ernin Hartwick of P.C.H. stated that they were under Che
thaz the nuoUr of units, Ps presented in P.C.B.'s Plan 30, wns
01�,o .cd ks :ha: an wAr set forth at tQ Qirch Planning Com.i-aission meeting.
Ke on7o %w vhauah! Oe PUnnar and Lhe Vivaninn Commission were satisfied
vich nW plau :20) cvan though he him3elf know the W Edina Plan
AwrojAna yarn anoonand by it. He requesond a reading of the March Planning
"GZ72 MKA Mint lzn
Mn, Ansingoes raparted that ::tic Planning Commission minutes
of Vn::Q11, W3, maKe thn "Mr. Nugea; thze znued that Pinn 3G be approved
in jomopt Qhn 0-3, 0-4 concept) and that the final plan ba resubmitted to
4v fj:�Zny Cw�ln�iea Wons goine to Counnil for rezoning.''
to tho tato l amount of land involved
TzhivaLn! thm it una niprcnimately 36 acres,.
rc-o,n-� Z�oT om aviv Ton;nd that thare has not been any
." ±� y7fy of vh, !one onsers in th2 area, as they have
f0k ohn. yh� n"ZIOT Q7 U100 ShouU be in accord with the Westerin
For P.G.U., quystioNed whether the
R -Y, "od 2-4 fesiOrnsial d0tricts
:m vov& approach. Hr. Hoisingtor.
Coin !avian approved only
-:J, n no i Q i e a . Denoicy is
EdIrl Flau nithout Plan
Riia Paaaivg
july 1, 1970
11r-, Huelster observed ghat the March Planning Conmission
minutes state t'lat a iEinal plau be resubmitted to the Planning Commission,
and that they r-rzE;t rise ',:he tainuter, as is gulLde as to what has and has not been
apprcnrcrL lie thien zniovnd that P.C.N. be directed to comply with the Western
Edina Plan denslty within the concept shoi.m in Plan 3G. Mr. Hughes seconded
the motion. All Voted Aye. Motion Carried.
Yli'� LOT DIVISION'S
1. Philip 1. Loken. 3219 Wcs'% 60th SU-eet. Parcel 2915 of Section
Raj�g
,q 24
Fir. Iloisington observed that the lot in question is ':ocated o ' n
the corner of W,,st 60th Street and Zenith Avenue. He stated that although
thc ".Kot 2i -S 98 f-'2et i,7 de o -a W4?st 60-t"iStreet, a dl -Asion of the lot into two
lo -'s >-.Tould rcprcsert a crnsiderabla €Ieparture fi:m. the established platting
ir, tb--t ;.i-rca, &3 the surrvuding lots are oenerally 75 to 80 feet wide. Ile
nated that the �3rweseut hour�p faces Wf-_-3t 60th Street and is located on the
ctaster1v of the Parcel. En indic2zed, tvo, that Substantial variances
WoUld 'b< before as building pa=it could be Issued.
Fi _Loken staled that the lots Directly ancross the street are
all lora g, and Hr. Hughes inquired as to the W-Idth of the lots, and
Mr. L---.vit,, tt'at the _fnterior lots are upproximataly 50 feet wide.
N,,- Hu,--ftas stuted' that thc Plannir,3 Commission has established
a pol-icy of nQt dividing loos were they depart substantially in size from
thoc-'a :In the and watild the,_rsfore mtmre that the lot division
be denia', Nr. Johnson veceadzd tl-ie i-aotioin. All Voted Aye. Motion Carried.
2. lzjtue.nhost Corp. Tract F. La
obser")'cd th&t Statin Farm ovus the south 150 feet
of Tr e',.! 4` but liao n,---.-4 the E:outh 183 feet of: Tract F, making an
a
dd 5, t -1 on of 38 1 --.ore fevt to h,,t '�,.ract. Ile added that this has
act i.% a I y %J.cead,,- occurred, it hkis c—ome -badk, from the County.
N:. thi-has <v i_hsatht,- d.Nrision be approved and Mr.
t i o i i 'Ca r r i ed .
lluelsLei A -,ted. .1
T7
5 U B D'Y T S ".0€dam
_Aedit- ion.
tiv" ii"y', would like to
uran Church on
z' i�' f
y
)c'
�sc(,':,, fin Lci_ 7, B_c,_,k I'D NIUkula-
p, a
I er r; 11 'A llf:v-) Addition.
a July 1, 1970
He SOW& that althangh to ispa2uliarly shaped, it is considerably
li then nasn of the 10 t._ in thah aren, as it has approximately
12,403 vlaare fiat and thn loto on are just over lo,000
squ=" Net. Hn. Heisington nWed that a solvable drainage problem exists,
W at it is n desirahic St to build upon.
XV Cardarelle natcd that the County took a 70 foot easement
along the South proparty line for a Frontage road when they built the
intorchenge at Dighnny W and the Wasstown. Be indicated that he would
AiR to cOnge his request from a subdivision to a lot division, He stated
thmt it Q CrOakes a subdivision, hc would have to acknowledge the easement
as * atrcat and cot back accordingly, but that if be lenves it as a lot
divisloo he wcrld then be able to build up to the easement, utilizing the
NO Wer remaiviag in the anoement after the construction of the frontage
VON an n front yard,
070=14 noted that this p0ce of pro arty joins his
agivej with Mv. Kesler to buy the platted lot over th'c_,
next 22 yQnrs, VI&OV which ti?., s U plats to build cn it and perhaps sell,
Q Y; staZal that Wt 2 W nosier's Hillzap Addition is not buildable nrow
WOO- it is zcnbined Nth Lot Y of Hikulay's Adiltion. He added that this
�s thp W:ay way Let 1 could be ani ti
W. Vualstnr MW tnAt the Pinnsing Commission recommend
nrpwn�W GE 1he ict di"jolon and I, jQnson =ondca the motinn. All Vorpd
"Ye. nocirs narrica''
W-har WfIfeys. Throb 644.1 On cf SeC"tJ vnshiv 116f.
Mr. KORSTUPtar recalIN that this is a one lot plat an County
Wn 13 W! novch of Volley Wei tend. He atatod that before Bel -Mar
is can uWal" A brWing parmic, they have Wen requested to plat this
PIL" VOTI lranV nn ail tk! coot of Lh, 1W clong the road is either
rll! 0? v XCAWOCY RAd 001MY an to WON. Mr. Hoisington stated that
001 SWU wvuld IWOKWOA nyPra-& of the one NO pInt, excluding the
COMA!= RMOL rn "hie Wloa
rk" johnsen nc:ed WE the PIU; le apprDved aad Mr. Hughes
r 00 OWFAM2, All Wed A"n, VOUSO warwied.
JnfXj2QQI District to parml
ni- yy'�±W;n-u i � thr� Ey. ldan� his P?mled upon a
ci C1011 Shoppiu; Ceite-.-
5MA?
would lik,-. to havo the
to cc!nters ill R-1 districts,
--qired per employee aid
of '3tructwe WUI be
C e:0 6� p r -a t z, AL~o.ms reported tthan. although lie did
r;.-Tenz Ls ----o I-hL, P-tzc of th!�, structure, the
;v) Id zc in- ?:r. ,;,pec i f i. cat --ons f cr p re -o chool ch 4L ldren
),-s typs,-- of development would to a
Em
S ted that this lwas
not "n
US UsE' "„?'d iat fel- it wns m-ist ccrmp3tible and
-�-s Of
tit ',! daIltirnie activity wou-3, d be
'-f
3-117. t -prpSeTftative replied
U r -
t, r o;3� i o s- r P i r 1 7 1 ot 7 u re
;a 2
:;are zle-nter.,s be added vo the
pperl--zn?, per
0, e, -2, r- GQ -motion. A;- 3.
C,-apel Tab-,rne.,cle Ch).A.rch has
1z:
'by T -!7C Flonriag
alt 11,e work that
V,
of fla,2rts pr,3-perty where the
WC,
--j-,
to rezene the
to Pro,vide added accer's to
tca w-,ated that the
z
bOb
Vlev-t -"2r.d Stz,.�et
e -,f tile grctrjt nmo_t
vp
co 7'i. 7-6 e d
7
of time r—!cnt in
4'17L�7,- 'C a!1,3' Lhe reqvc?st
V
_ra-aniin orwAssion --5 .duly 1, 1970
4� ?fir., .eiir.3esra mc3Yr:::iht the Piarr.i ;;; �€zj:.rni:3 pion hold a speciai meeting to
consi.ver the Pesntom, Inc. revise, ce feral concept plain and Overall develop-
ment plan on July 15, 1970, at _i-30 P.M. at the F?dina Village Hall. Mr.
Aughe:-3 seconded the motion. to.! Voted Aye.
1111. djta=.;,.-nnent at 13:30 P.M.
R -2,s .ectfully subiAtted,
Lynnae EcJarlais, Secretary