HomeMy WebLinkAbout1973 09-26 Planning Commission Meeting Minutes RegularMJ14Y'll"Es (11F THE �Ayl`
TV---- EDINA VLAXN.A4:;
"LLD S1. p Tt�jpll'R "If,
H WIDNESDAY,
A
EDINA VIUAG,: FiAll
Hewa)srs P'z-esent,. WW,, Leais, Chaiman, S, P� H�gl-cs, "4
ani: .0,, T 1, Runyan.,
Staff Present G, Luce, R, Dunn, and. L -4,'e;
I Aper -oval of the August:.99 1073 `ann:Lng coqlwal"l c'a Hil-'Utes"
A motion was made by Mr,, G, Jo-,inson and seconded bY '`'x., Cl, Johns:;r to approve
the Planning Commiss,-`.on minutes dated Augusx: 29, 1973, -z,3 Ul. vo,-ed aye.
Motion carried,
).OT DIVISIONS
LD=,73-12 Ehctrhardit Company3250 ics: 6ftb"Part of IsOt 5, C&--Ssin"
Pr,, L-uce exp.!.a.,.neel Eberhaa'dt company i 'h'7iCi(vJ to allow the
sale of the real` porl'Lon of their lot to t'.rle T-tl„ ilo.(,:&,k.:.",:ik-oii Compan.y. owpir r -f the
tor 41�he t.-,lfice bu�%.lding
P'P0P(l--r-t.v directly ea -1-: so adequate paz,"klla�,� (a!, t
-11 z i, because the
,inder corstruction a,�:' �hat sile( He T Olt ed is �� s
Office huildirg undev c.onstruction is deptrd(n I. t`li�,.ati:a ICY C'V,--S"�irun tO Mtet: its
CD).'S UVIS'3.011 A a 'll
park ing requirement he�tau--'e & hardsl;ip �.'% u � v, , ' " ' ('' � o'T" Ellowee,
discu-sioe: ' Mr, G'j( h be approved as
..,equested, Mr,, Runy�..;� seconded Lhe a,ot t.o,•J%.,J. 'VCA' Pot 3. (-)n carried,
7 3 r S 0 L- t
apz.-..vtmOr.'Z' i'ilding ko'e. 1 3
F-
-d
• J -;i
W,, 74th WA
Aiz;cvsaivns hcdd the�i'are
R- 5
Do r, tels and
,'Clizee" the scilt-ng -'00k
Di-
=---
)ai Thc-"r flna-�
pzlx�-,ing '1 i}
i';kj D
fv SUOV-1-SION
op tha
A�L
a i
Evc Lvice not,,d rezonivg
apz.-..vtmOr.'Z' i'ilding ko'e. 1 3
Of he. --Ue .e'Tl Q
• J -;i
lb '0 1",
Aiz;cvsaivns hcdd the�i'are
Do r, tels and
,'Clizee" the scilt-ng -'00k
ix, rd I
)ai Thc-"r flna-�
pzlx�-,ing '1 i}
'fo% rotlutz:tivn iz 'kJ,
J
huce
agrzvdd LL;"it -4x-, Bedai
ko
Dz ng shc-'IJA e
Zf;- S t 'lif-':
le 9L'.�Zlflev
'�ed lig
encLc s
he
tei?qj -f
6; r I -v LsTniants to
')Ccupy `lie bu.�-ldings,, lth�ah'
l3ecause -:)-,n b-klilding ^).'.o3nrvsd
reca-,=jen ed ti-
d'
Sdiro Yooning C=051011 Sept Nahen 2E, 197,
rezardr, requested be approved Eubject to an Wroved P. 011ded at I"" Ore
paalking st&l per umit is constructed; the riu.ac : Pr..:' k.: may be limiced
to SA "nil such WS as a need for more 6uvface parking is umunstrat ed
Mr, Luce referred to the staff repopt and stated approval A the inquested
subdivision should be contingent on a land. L'vaae beltwee-n Lbea"zer and Kv - Hedberg
(pj,opos,.ad Lot 1, Block 1, Ebenezer Society :_gat Addition --r a t:,,e ioAherg land immediately
adjacen. t3 and northwest of the planned building site) no tho donation of the proposed
norther4y lot to the Village of Edina kora park purposes, A AWRY the proponents
plan to transfer to the building site an the southern to mh the WSPY and trip
generations assigned zo that northern piece of land, reLioning it useless fop develqamcnt
purposen, it should not, _herefore, be allowed to xamain a platted lot becauac potential
developient might eventually be assumed. Mr, Luce noted nn: levelopers should not be
relieved of their 5% parkland dedicatiun ob0gation, evun it he noreleen to is donated
va the village, becauNp that land is not assenJal to Edina but would only bi accepted
in order to insure it would not be deveiope&
RegardAg the inyling requirement, Mr. T, A Thompson (-I1:hec'a"Zeo ro.'ie'-"�Y sti:"ty�d
rhey "We done a amount of WAy on rhis vhfan ndicates that Qven the
"os t a0luent of the.inds of lnstallatic= acr= the c,wn-.nq hays Lcuhera near 50
of tie occupants having automobiles". Fe fl -Z-;
_tY1_t2d 1) cosc.., about
15,0N per stall and "it reems inconcelvabin that wq sAwAl have to orovide 328 stalls
in d have most of them remain vacant". Mr. TlcApson ncled ZSCM SWAM Wdicate also
Am thr average age K the cccupantn 5r Ais type ct pryect is about 45 yearn old,
And the actual numbei of trips taken amcupts to a 4 trips per week par unit. In reply
m Mr, UK, Mr "Ampsan stated they are 111anniry th8A hanic nur)et rs to Aclude
full tanation but hope, A view of recent t,,iplation, j, reenive sono tax abatement
or tax1>ecausa che residents A tha byl,jog viij all A.;.,over 55 years of age:,
W reply to Mr. Hughen . hr, Thompson n0cud 5 0 Uudlo WC square feet?, 48 al"ve
030 650 square fee , 165 arm bedroom CROW 100 PquaOw Y " I and to -1,000 square f0c
and 26.A,203 square inG, two tadnoom 00W DE PWOed, '"Iks "I be AD" 1350 "..'
14DO per month, whj. way include azcoss c "to 4101 wpram in the 1herezer
'yStem" , e'1_61ough e,ajc,(t, oil! not Vc ly n Wed in 1 As b WA9, He adled the
-ena"te jjA be as j,dypebdent as possibic, Krever, a yey:va_ lining voom will We
dinn;x a-aiiable to than if Ney desire to cFkj advantago of vo A varber shop area
And a vvil. W-housn vand dispensing unhO ira also P��Onld
Djucussion In,,awad, Mr, Luce ponKnrd out a because
of efficnency "&,, j, A,,es, yVAj0wA1V vje ' disausWon, M, Thompson
ntaten -key would "sayi, une the paYISAAW . jx tha 151
.nereabn the nvmher nV one-Wt.om Win t
tv, Bob Quanw;Ak rated tie EbeDown In Ax, han Y OnA histc& an& a" Ortstand'W"
necoyd Q service to the eiderIN IOWA WOW f rjejnjy vippoj� hLs apWon .hot the
;Onybj.:ty tLe hvjK�vg iv 1g have Yo to cats r it W"tow-1 yem"Lb,
A C Johns." Wzzod Mat "j, j w,;, wyN ..j ycvA vie hinta, U the
Ann,zey Kwe and tn-.- Zhat the roOdurn a U,;Xrge [q is 75 years Ole, i. seems
un,i,jlj o, --a tenants o evany one of 1 Q3 to!' wa Ky �ar. Hs nould So NUNN,
cc go Nov 1W 0 At yad'0&�v 4.... " n �;& jENiag requivemcnt in,
dl. .i a An fact enam WA A alLUSAa 11 yo;Aa2 pai unit an Ae grour-.`
;f avdA-Ianil stalls n�T eyn: recegsan'
W Holland Annozar stat;± irmr�-Z op nu the apan=cnt for
Sigh income o:.. ,n iiin; daesn", mean they
,,,, ,,, : n4, OoF ter the higher incame
Edioa F. 4nnlag CommUslu.-, 1 opt am! e" 2F , BY
aldeviy" He noted qtmiannalrns were sent to tbc-
of ten anew
Luthnrao rangragatior" and the resulw indicar, a wijoP,
,no inverestad is a- Edina
noca.ioa Mr Luce responded that "according to the ce
&W, or highe, Ncome
alder1v Waie here at age 62 for Florida, aw the faden:i
;3vvprrant is not buil ding
any porn low income elderly housing, so the real dieficahr:
in this metropolitar area
is not nop the rich sub:;:rban elderly, Q is for the poo
;:Pal city elJeZQ",'
,rezoning to 11110- 5 versus R-5 was diacussed. Hr 7appy
QUM, the az,chitect,
clan: fiod R-5 was requested because thay had understood KU
-5 vould not 0104 the central
dining invm and other auxillarry uses p�>-oposad; they would
ravd no objection to requesn-
ing PRD --S zcning if those uses can be included in the ppolast.
NP, Luce. staind varianeqa
for setbacks, height, etc., are in effhat granted by
-3,nn.�ng Coc nmisslon ind Council
when re%rming plans aim approved. however, hc will vequea:
the Village Attoriay determine
if this Lame procedure applies with regard xv permitted uw-n.
abeuv.
Mr, Hughes meved consideration of this item be continued
pending a determination
by the Village Attorney as to whether the auMinil uveE p
cTaned would be allowed
under FRP.5 zoning, it was generally agreed 1;2 ernlaa(d
vpit king stall and U3 ex used
stall per unit would appear reasonable since land is avallowe
to provide tba additioraJ.
;�arking required if r"oessary. Vr, G. johrA(n seccrided W
motion. All vatad aye,;
Aotion carried
ya uwxed tle GWIN
Mr, Hughes WNW own5iderallon ot Zn; 'i i. v
division also he 2ontinued
rend n; a determinarlin on tne zoning queaticn discussed
Ar. G Jchnson secanced the
Aotion. All voted ay". Motion carried
11 ov cs it,
7. OTHER BUSINZ03
Redevs!"pment by Tax Irievomens T."uncing,
Ir, Luce no no Wbropoi '0� 1".v L - k0) P;V y inuc, hdine Plea and had
-Tie Ca-fl'ae a"'
i"Cai and Qbvn
AINIP, )oowt :A
Liod '?ax Waraueot Financing
-
.or
Camnuis
ewsWnel
ha✓are
e"o N.cs
fa
,Ureg tils infor�
qaLlwn
u possible 7000VelapMeW
Of nhS
Sltn I Zd F3 anCa
OW ::WISS diStriCt fan beautiti-
aavicn
and to proviit.
anc PWSL�can
apeas,
to Luce exoniAred
he has ta.kne
MY x Purber o
snue=en an! laidowners
abeuv.
pCP"SW13T:Y
& indeveloprer'
ct W xasvQ
a�nnA"rwani financiig and whw
:his
could potential--
ancompJUL; Qn
PePe Wen "he
bookler refe,enced and
isrs
in no way miulaW
ya uwxed tle GWIN
Etc IT,( , b,m,L,"s
Iona eosocinUin ivaently
iassod
e rascAution ywdcariu
the, so,
11 ov cs it,
a& sa"eral letteir from the
tocV
landavners apj
usinusawaa wore
pjesEp,e vich
.ycd i Wivey 50th and Wanck-,
sualress
area is desn"ad
and urged Tho
ol
, authority be
aura
ed, Mr. Luce ayglaWd
tha she 1a
00r:L : affseven,,sant
Any pailicular
jU51(ing
but 'Yy
tyc neipybpi
juie qsn i uie,l r
o N !U be inc,', easeW The
tax
narement is W
difieverid. e be,woon
tit 0v'r to .0%,g
-Ind he 1: JA
L�1-ri' ta,
50 is 1100% in
U101, 00 K bn
_" E16 W, Runyan agreed. hr,
lunnn
added "this ini
t he aryThlw V.,
1 10 , 1 1 1 he .
L 1 i., ard aovcd the
llan
ial
0 le Ccoo
1 1 1 , a )1>1 a
_ all,zePw authorin Wr the
WeQa
., purpose a?
adovelopment Cy
30 0 1: & F. Li :e
uy
iA ma;ior All qnval
�Y- C401
la2riwd'
V� South 1,
1. N, 1 No i �n
a 1 Z 1; WIC 0
Ir, Luce no no Wbropoi '0� 1".v L - k0) P;V y inuc, hdine Plea and had
Edina Karning Comminsion Aptembe, 26, 190
five amonents in ,.a it, zoo of nhich oene eiiwann�, - v0sr Edina spoks A
opponWar to them. Their wemaiping Wee icanents warc a, Wiuvs,
1. The Village of Edina is to be aingratulited on its leadership in implement-
ing Ae razommendatio"s of the "494110i Souchdale CurwicsA..Inspom'-ation StIdj1%
2. The South Edina Land Use PAan should be more c :Nalated �o compre-
hensive plan amd planning process for the eniti,.re , Vasioui aspects of the South
Edine Plan could be planed in an overa"I Village contexi, !uch an the data base, trans-
portation plans, environv.,ental guidei!DeS, *.,iousing goals, iud priorities
and vecAlques,
S< Background analyses and statements of goals, okjawAyes and implementation
guidelines far achieNing the houArg goals sfioi)ld he �Xr-kWee A the plan, The depth
of analysis of housirg needs and plan propcsols ought tc b, move sped fIcaAly tx*ated
and broajened to include the objective of frcvidirg housing with a range ok costs,
particelarly for low-and-moderate-Inoune families,
in response to Mr, Lewis, W Luse alated the WwnAng CcImmission, parsvant tc
statc staines, shoula npw approve the plan uIch &r; col oivgnacles Ac y migK have.
Following MR discussion of the Ralropolican Crac"A"s remal*s, Mr. Hughes
moved the final drat r of the South Edina Plau ne arproved as aubmitted. Mr. G. Johnson
seconded tne motion, All voted aye, Motion airrie&
Chanze A Next meeting Date,
---I.-
it was genena.11 agreed the noic req inrly zchednjod AaWng ComaisZon meeting
should be postponed 1,.-, �973, levaury of A coWliat with Halloween.
School Ward Representatile to Xyvri"g CownWSIOU,
W Luce explainud he ano Gevy%e A i , recenOy pnQnne(.-,, btki..:,d repre-
SenYWO W GO PlanOLng COMASSAM, have airned his pon! ion ou the Commismon is no
longer Decassery, as any communication hecve�n th(, haaad and Village an be done
an a Waif level. He nw-ed Mr. Fite K3 I &A apas 'i..__,. L . e-eS;Yy "t a -he schi o,L board.
"'he ComirICS