HomeMy WebLinkAbout1974 02-27 Planning Commission Meeting Minutes RegularW
'i.., ;J. OF 0D,*_'
THE EDINA FLANN01 COQIFKjw
TUX WEDNESDAY. )WARUARY 27, 1
EDINA QITV HALL
Members Presents S, P Hughes, Chairmen Pro Tem, C '-_"11 I Ls or,
D T, RuDynn, and F S. Dann,
Staff Frusent: G Luce, 3 Dunn, and 6 Nye,
1, Approval of the January 30, 1974, Edina PlEmniq Commissior Hinaves,
A motion was made by Mv. 'Run -,,,an and seconded h- !a ohnson to epprove
the january 30, 1974, Planning Ccmmissio.-; .,,,inates i".s sci`ii n :ad. AIJ voied aye, Motion
carried.
LOT DIVISIONS:
LD- 4.2 parkwoosl 'i"Tlolls constrk!atiou cown198 and 080 pyroad Q!
RA'_ ' S„_73330000 Addition,
Mr, Luce explained we MAW reqnested would LK CYT 1e an additional
buildfale lot but would adjust the existing lot lres KMOva yard .3 -;7,f -'e
of both pruperties He recommended appravaA K thp af-nsiDn beialuse it would reGive
a hardship and no new iatv will be creareo''
Mr, Runyaa rov'ad th<� lo'� C'Iiviolaz K approve& 0� Y�juwnted, ann Ir Dean
seconded the motiso.-Ali voted aye. Nction warricK
111SUBDIVISIONS,
k]c loc &rad
W to? ST bit A- Qat of Flcn>
to, Lunocxpleiawd cne suuQurly now child OP oytli: A M V johnson's 73'icK31.
Hilis is proposal no be subdivided He bluniQ revisal! n'” dAistilg InA sxpecza'-.
park.'k-and J�dicatiuo accardi"qto the Snuthw"st Edira T.na.: and noycl tho parkland to
he received in coAlunction with this p0t ju a 7c toz, �vrI4 j,jacci aAoDg the eawarr,
-kr 'Ine ia� ',"%ze:i
boundary which wniLd adjom ha py,nnad PaPI vent 01 3ALL".'C" '
will be apprvx1manaly 14,141 squarn fe�t and are gensy!±0 M "70c"aanKl lith t",
established neignorhood avandani nod "Kh a Pyelivitv-1 p1jo ;-asc.n?, whon M. P
johnnon"s 3' ¢r hills -un 00190010 XY701d, nPPO" n" ''Y"ad for th-
ransons stated in nbc savo opurt, nn",Q, %as iwV5% wc"070ance w",
those in adjaccal w0dlwishn-u, tho 100;cwn� 10 in Cn! .;l .1 "ll t4v original it an
submitted, and 00 parklays! "C' he �Idyw&tal in RMI d Q . ��y W! 3 to 11 11 za nn ...11:.3 ;.:1 a; or
proposed park ok Anwlev Zak 20 1"rM App'Oval wou 1 h01mynnt an receipt 0
a dead free and QOP of Q , liens aud OnlD?MCW TO QA- ao,a rKawa as parklWl
and execution of a oatimincury Q�Kwor L aAroe'vyl - TQ 311n P.0v 7pprova-'_
10 Dear vaLed too : �h ho�nl 1, 1i -0 PrintV !,- hvjv� " 1 !n 1 " be " tat"
because it will n0cn W40 v,nuco Y�vh 0C tznl N ow Ao HuK�ns, Mr. Lvm�,
indicated tha, fp� Ole park n�!A KWOW 0:000 X v, an -a.dvus ;or. impr3n sam"M
ErR ppepused in to park r anid sapAtal Mpyo""Myvr ZO l.
fir, �.*'Z'C�. 7-1'.Lz�z._'n, �V; �T ltentn YJ ?Q" n, ? � co V% ; �,Iajaed che aneliminary plat
requested conjarTs to thn n;JAK layout cMOPv thK 1 ivni b;G 4= romo-ed and park
Page
land dunated, he agreed, in reply to Q Dean, to K�i onyers that che
land to the eact will be a developed act_. . w? and v i �_ , , c . env _ i a i umdeveloped
wild area. Hr, Dean thep toved the preliminaiT piai W dyn�nvid �::' o�-n .. ia-_� andersi-andi-ng
and with the following convingencins; i. That a WO W Wa, ;i all liens
and encuribraDees for that area shoNn as parkiand he su'nnnd to W Clay ok Edi--A
prior to final platting; and 2, That a developer's agponim 'to tha C.it*)7
Engineering Department % nWitted prior xa the kinul DA,v appinvol. V C. Johnson
seconded the motion, All 7ated ayn, Motion cnrid&
5-74-2 eplat of (Outlat A Evan sw.nor 2nd WAiWo Unerwiv located
west aTTlake-Rad and
?W. Luce recalled that when Evanswood 2ne AdARIon was ouh0vilad about a year
ago, two lots were platted an Bid& Road and the rear iortion to the .a s''_ was labelIN.
an outlot because the Engineering Department was con .& Valbar the Land could be
served with aewer because of the ).(>w ej,evat.ioa aLd piwEL Q"tarc2 Nvol-ed Replattizq,',
of that outlot to include a -..-i ease;ivent, for W exteasiv.: :TL north ;-Tith
a lot an the west side and an autlot on t east in aaz rcquested; a house will &
built on the Ot Sth drive4ay accass iram 1vanswood L no Os it zyistix and the out -
lot will remain undeveloped.
in reply to Mr. Hugnes, Mr Dunn Slicated tALL aNIRh he haA not seen a
final plan, prallninary conversations nhcw Oat th" proposal :}cuss and saler could work,
10 Luce noted thav only one-third of the InKland Aelication iis paid kie-,l
the original plat was aR)Poved. Appr(iyal o? the repla,tv e
id d the
balance ($1200) is paid pp&r to final plat approvai, a Ki no 3ilding
will be issued too either the vatlot or lot should UY hognnear.n; lepunaant not
approve the elevation ol the pioposed house op the qrOp C . tin pvc nasQ sewer; in
effect, appinval K this veplal dons not guavautue AvLnn. er of a b; Uding permit,
hr. jack 00pp, W developer, alavilled th;g ynans an! applicatio,l
for a hUj1dQ7 _j'.
sK the elev atic i W lie to , anqn f 3 nor
H , stated he
understan6s and agrees to On conditions noW hy QU 1mv in Wit resom
hr. Luce clarified the cutiov Lod W (dvpen(dj cy twe pyvpascl house lnoatiun_�
could presumably ae divVed An hall in 4hp vwturL v"c sPOA bu i an&-Yance SO;
recent neighborbcod standanns,
W Funyan moved the subdivislor, including on basn4snl fox thi ascension A`
Evanswood Lane, cne uWaz and enc: lot, he approved, w0jouL to the fallowing
contingencies; A. tbs land on Zhe east UK of lVarsowal We axtondO is Plattec`.
as an Putlot and the land on the wass side it Evanswu0i Leal i� plarnel as one lct:
2. the donatioa oh $1200 !ar parSCOmd, prk)�-, on a Knp1n; and 3, n( -j
building permit Fiould L, isnued f.w withow h.e cu:xt i8 ;-Dqk7ed �;t shou23 Khe
Engineering Department w, nopin-e vao onun D, rv�osna h me in the graiv of
in me Pic, ,I;pnn o,! 6, nn4F;wd 2nd AdUsLian",
to not a0unplably becausa Op InO.0 ON'Jilts,an in "C .)t 1 q 1 q. A . CG i . an altern
title MUNT &:. dhowen. 1W �,K Ocy W's. Notion
2-27-74 Planning
Page 3
Z-74-1 Rack Z. Jones Assoc,,
jenera.
11f
Ins.iGordon
WhWcp Suhunwr
1
:pan
"Eoperty
street7
ZEN wy�v
tlla
-and- lest.
of
Sh i T
R
J1llie T x711 'r
T,-_7s_idKtve
D_.s
5tKc-� to
FP� Ti
2i'llanr.;d
as,ow-al
(coN,r_iJjED
if:, Luce noted the a�,,chitect ha
to the Planning Commission's comments a
and detached garages. Both Schemes "A"
three story units, relocation of the do
and a reduction of the number of encloE
the enclosed parking reqtLire331eyt hn red
because the 1971 Apartment Survey resul
a reasonable requirement), The single
Mr. Luce necalled he recommende
several e.`antingencies, inciuditg dodicz
cash or parkland dedication requirement
of $52,150 in lieu of part land should
reasons tar approval and contingencies
and stated appioval is again recommende
noted, The Envir,-)nmental Quality Commi
designed two alrnOW schomes in response
the 1-30.74 maivin; regaraing the unit sizes
and "B" includa :;Ci t'.: atha2had sir ages and
ached garage E njvto the dwilling units,
d parking sta3ds We Oak! hai Pecaumen ded
ced for apariment zjpa bullAinga in PRD zones
s indicate 1 25 enclosed space3 per unit is
amily and avunchanged,
concept appirv;a,_ -Cnt-, l- ONO meeting with
ion of the pcwjjn,-the 5'00'
The Park EveW, sAnce thce, indicated a fee
Wo be requil"! go. Was Yeviewed the
oted at the 1 -TO -V Plenninj Conmission meating,
wich madifiretior at the parkland requirsnant
Sion a1sc reCxYWnnt1!d Oynceot Opproval,
Mr, Roger Fraebavg. .ho architect, presented034es at SchEwes "A" and "B",
indicating they pref or SchwnA, .,raich as nine -'-! �;M of three,,
He clarified t1he ?'aree rz-tory units axe genewally entvvaA o3 tie s2cond ievel; none,
would be below grade, but ,Cu it base full a"posura. to notnC On, the total
parking providnd A well ovac two pacs.,i PY be c.... is
available in froi:o of the gimayca. Hr Frn,iLic3 ,g his iane B" adds three
additional buildings.. ard he pratens "ScAovo A" lt `nvolves lass
ground coverage and the con-aomics Exo :f 'i buildi", ;We oyuwtaias -ather than 12,
In reply to Mr.
Dean, 14. Dunn
AdVated tF cr 010 Sao
Y lode Park has dcae
some filling in a relatiuek,-.7 -,maJa
tlla
0 will ho 1 ;d,
Tiond. .jg, f1r,
added the deveiapap of
Hyco Yark io unoW
on
der New i,n 0) ve
UO WO Watershad
Diot-rict to remoc,a all
W! Uncking anN
as,ow-al
WWFo .y;,
DOZO �11.
Mr. Dean aLataet revione! the -'Zi, ", -,`sc 'x_ i,�,,,e anti
approved of a cas! donaOn't., _n ord zr tc deviiop c0my0. nN m loin i � they were
not ill lINH to tht-,. 'x ,. ° �,..? r raav for park bew7m:, t. t is cc: p ; n of the park
system,
S-_ Hughf.:. AIE! vrU A
comments were MaQ at ton A -0c.74 �Iann
indicated vVy rc;lewed no prnposnd u;
luxury typ(-� znd Cgocd 01"n IN. Hugh
thai Oe p)wjmuaee suit sAys are mWmr
de-Wopmenks in ill arev, WA S plulaot
higher poised .SE ITorhail" 10 Onys
the qualiny of W ! building ind em milt!
roved Schnae A be graptra unno(Vt pprw
1-30-74 and 2-27-70 stafn wanorbs. on t
the Aming of ohs favalopn� i4, and no n
or the two story Wtipla poijects s
too
:Toe rat 11;n
jV waw vea
nViyugh Several
01
wTKAc�
.n 1, An
Ma T Jonet,
it snow
hm qill�
, tat Oy
�W:n willbe
e S a
Id Vr Y j
_.._.0 ; OVt it
1W 1 LhSir f eel ing-3
V 4-.
DOZO �11.
� ! C �, cc
lwlson with
Kunio
0 to Q
2 !C, ir POIC
A ; "Oject in tht�
SLOUld
031 1 0:
: :
an
A Y-07idcy
1. 1" n t Alyo�as
Too, Hr Dawk
011ars;
1 11
1 M�.V so 1
nia" Vication 0:&
ro
ybin Fv� ?
!Qip ne
yni szwry =ApW.
be
UVOWN tL
an V.nwaa�ad
100il at least
`P; �, jl�% " � 1
k S i.. C W" C, C
Pa.i7e 4
50t of J`&,.-Ifldly , Dv, o,
constnzctlon; 2, the en:-ipe Droiact --nu�,
cle-meni of the pi,)ject, -a -�-U aveas sit
storage iiaxLst be cadicated ic, 'zhe City o
an easement along
, that a-rea which Ails sh
tion fee of $52,150 musi. 6e received pr
that approval is recotameivTed with ,-Ih,a -n
to the xmit Mr, C., johnson seco
Ille stip-oLation? alloN Ing cD-,n3tr
project until at least 500 of the sing-','
was discussed, Sea't's lcdlne of !Ala.,
be allowed to develop those sl'�ngle faini
cul-de-sac near the zast boizidary, r
the west boundary prior to dnreiop-ment
will include Mr. SejiW,Lk1x- '--i existing ho
writter, I.o assiunc., a
single fariLLY lo`- woald b,-- zw�cspL:A).-.e
pmject would be. a
a for
d
6e su b d J', - v
n as pord, �-,a
Z7-dinay 4, ;.o(:, ':,A,- ci 11.uSl Lie
J,' il; Lail,d a parklard c"e-6ica-
r co fiT.,aJ p3.r. Ig.r,, Dean added
ation oz -exP-1eSgSd in, recrard,
ed the
�� .LIL I
,Ctioxl of I -,o nor-, �,I.ir) :;1).1b 1:1�.0 either, multiple
'' J
-�ox, construction
f:-Urily io-�-s 1r;z E,3 i"'-ff
Z� dones C'ons t,- i, '-c-a Clai:,aay vequiL%sted tey
,y lots at. tlhta"-A oDoive, along the
1oag, the sou. -ch of 'Dew -Y, 11.11. Road neaz-
f the 25 10-1-c Oa tha 1,w.-,ges-c C!V-!.,..,de-sac, wh-Lch
Lu(.1.(! afq)la-�neei Was
and initial 'I ot. Ane 44
e -r V
Mr,, Dean to Tic"Vt t.ha, lei:) -,Silent: of' 19
Y.
of the total 44 !�Invle 'J,c,ts iroulbe �i�'he stiplUatlor.
discussed, and Mb -, C, J&1';,nscn secoided,:h-- as ai*E,,-4,!n( o'.i, All aye. Mction
carried, I
vlOTHER BUSVN`ES^,
:sa
Mr., Luce stated 1-25 t�
type buildings in avitlhar "'PRI)II or "
on the rasults ok Jte 197-t. Aparl,ziieat Fkt
a 1.971 sTirvey Ax--.
Valid as c.ar -aut
He clarL°Ied the f-0,
from 1 to 1,25 e7,-.-cJ-ose-d s,-I-accs par unit
District zo-aes I)e
for n,.yp C
�,econdied the mot.L,3-o A11 ayi,
in -.ha, Plannee,
r-s!-qu`rement La:Eled
t3iorj-,. th" -faiidity cf
O-)i-:1,on 3, V_y IS S."
1P ATISi.7-.oider,311 ip is lmproViD,�.;,,
w(,-,,-.,lcl )ji inereasr-d
,aad "Ch') Ti'..:Resident-1-al.
Sa---IC4--Z Per U.T.1it.
Zhe Vh3 an Uosed
D.011nZ,s zlyl,,�,%-'-:)T. 1, aiOhnson
2" x,w.ok
V, nt-
Run- At-," Mr, Deiia
-On
oe- zlded the C 2x -11 to apy"
-Y
�.3 1�,x,cm 1 L:�? i c t
�.o app�
bE
P anring Qtynint-`
0
i amen �1,-,dirznce)
for,
I S.I. V
2,11-7k OWN, COWS"On winuoo,
pag2 5
f'ollowing briet disonsclon, AP
be Wooned as w -j i'-,'.ze,.. Thn, t. Town
carried,
leo An ord.t.vancz amending
Naw moved vhv n- or7 jnazno gmendme,,
Mr, Luce explaKed the
proposed
&,03dm,,t
j, 1, ��Piiy
hit the required jC0
foot dedication c? Long natural water bodleg
is frOm YK ;AKuPiKe
ck a stream and
high watex of a lake MW
Q johnson
moved tic Fa7vzrt
he oppraved, and Mr,
Dean seconded the motion, Ail
voted aye,
H,tj,,
5, An oz-din'.,ace
011 and 05 providinz
anc�7j bv L n
Mr. Luce clarified Se exiatinr ordivanne raqc OPOUR, or alteration
of a building or structura xo be "WAvanvially ccuplexa. MAS one inar after jani
iS rczcncd av a raWanCe is grantal. Thin wan %und 1a, I, �tjtv,jay, and the propvsw
amandmant would chauge i;oRyleivd" to pj z , 1 acyl wcn&y,
Mr. Q Wason UMWOE the plopone amenla0n% 070 aa cr! t Lon, and W
Dean secondad Ac rotion, a 1 v w. 40001'.,
61
Mr. Luce capapted the Council hp,
Commission. Follo"ing discussion, tie p
member COMMANO-Y, woWd an6
also, its preew Me is a gand, "MAS
members will not J!'a CCIAZU
tho Council of the Planning OunnisSan's
"I, KOJOURRONT,
F "ded I
aa fxG to A a PLO snAT.;
-2 n n, L gizoLum y njoino a yj,:1
OR&noopMUOL Ord Wacusejvnv�
in DWI aW . - cjw�a 1WO additioral
W A WI 0 1 ocan ASQUctad to irfcl�-
op In xan'