HomeMy WebLinkAbout1974 05-01 Planning Commission Meeting Minutes Regular"PA 2y L .7 m lot n. n
WA
AN, le apprviec as 4winlas 1 ocnox-w num, wd �QLCC n"T
motion "arrim:!,
111 MT DMPQW�
Q 74";
Omni A "wKY
6015 Pcin: m0w �1
WAAM0 ord
MOST—
a 51"Ision -6
n ot 16, B Luck v ��.,WUo
is vcquj�.wl,
jMd PreSOIVO�
S ,-. Vy1001matij Q5
�Q! Qrna�ja AW nAAC,
W4 CK L001 WIMMOU .?`.G
pAinam 'OnDw.l
�M%l An Ax, >Odw!
2 Cabdivimin ardAnsps),
and AM -001immi
10 two hon, 10L�
"twn.;? W.�-
7nnv: 1� nn 'Vwnw
�0 wo oynnoand 10-
novou9s � z0nalyl'
�wklm ""r
v Oro". in, !A-1 lczo,
��! V� KnMs aawoys zpiz''
VaCSIS apc� %CAU
�; in"Z0000 in
�P: lFvwvn yj�uvl nn nw
AnvirAlmont il.
mAlary so -or
'&wm Y&" wsnv"�
�atom. N:N r", �IA �'L ':
�. uuvh �qv MA'
of in
Q16
lue TOP Sanital" Own
or Eater, ..gin:'' .t
vAlialas WmIA bov.
1. hv hPOL117 in -my'dnwwla
61SUICU, me nVoi
Von COAAAUn
02 "Wre fmclaw 0.0
was nn hollwahnn 101A W
AS -ioqux-o At to AS,-,
Ann 250 wqnvl�
YTI:_
coCeSS Lo W a
0- U . 4 F i ai .. y 7c ,l_: l.c:n n le:Y:....,,
Qqe 2
Mr. Hut hes Userved the eYOUng hot is similar in snzc LO Or inis n AW,,
lake Cannelia, aod division of tint tot vouid Slae an apnarent Overnss "! the !W,
Following discussion, he moved the rnqnvs�ed lot division be denied too the ncascrs
listed by the staff. NP, C, johPoon secondud the motion. Ali vatai aye lotion carr;ec,
5-74-4 Hyde Park 2nd Iddition GnnarUly Located soulh at lowev HiR Road xV
UTIS I Kwasly Vol is—
Mr. Luce stated the preliminaig plat proposed is a Sa lot sinle gEmBly subdivisina;
he recalled a six lot plat (S-72-1) of of -'.J-iis land wau rWewed by thn conmissia.:.
about a year agro. 14 noted that although easements ape tor ;torm. wal e-- pucrposes
in the middle of blocks I and 3, contiguais ponding areas on he SnbuqZur farm prtTwrt,•
Wirectly east) are proposed to he dedicated as outlots; Ybe silting basins included Y
the proposed plat should therefore be dedicated as outloiA anther they an ea3cmen..s,
Mr. Luce recommended appzvval of the prsliminavy plat contingent cn dedication oO tQ
silting basins as outlots,,, suhmi.ssion of nn appyoved developer's agreement, and roce>f_
of the required E% parkland dedication fee.
Discussion followed regaNing tha prDposed Ot sizes. :ie varaj PlannOF Ccmmiss:ol--;
members felt the lots plannel aze too nraji and are not in caVormance with the existing
and pronosed lots V adjacent areas,
7ollowia(.I:rthar discussion, Mn. Q Johnson moval consideraticn of the pTeliminar,;
plat pressited be continued to the 11, ay 19, 1974, msating; a t3pagraphic W W a MaP
indleatiag the prop -sed sco,-:i seve-.r,ands, Osprnposod W sizes, and the eyistivg aa
,, -
proposed lot sizes north of Dewey Hill Rond, In Nyde NO lot Addivicn Airectiv west)
and in tie S&,vsl,-er far -!i (Indian Nuadows) projen! waa roqiewtsd so an acauraze co"paricon
and review cap br, made, Pr, Hughes Fewcndel the na,lon
Following additionei Met discusslon, Mr. W Johnson aTanded On moticn to regi ivc
dedication of the sxoxm water silting basins as oucluls tether than as easements, Mr
Hughes seccnded the ame&cd mcLlon. Ail voted aye, Mav�on Gar i.e
S-74-5 Hennepin Count, Registered Land Suatey Gonera3ly laualed scuth Cl --i"
Mr, Luce explained the Unnepin C=nty Vivens Wficr Wad Wnnapin Wuntl to
tile a registered land survey to clarify cnd simpAily the Oval dewcApSons & the paicels
affected by ~ he Cou-inty �Zoad 18 Lond acquisitions,
Following brief disemssion, Mr. Q johnsor mynad W proposed -enistared Ond ayrvy,,
be approved, and Mr, Dean seun&cd cie motion. All vcxed aye. Moticn carried,
1T VZONINGN,
Z 03 0 Ebenezer Sunle�;. n7 Q
QwinraAlv honaV-;,�,
�,rcs',,
ni, Ycc,-�,-
I T- A GOT!!
A—
N A.01 n,
AN
do Thld��--,:,
'J'�!L"34E',!k
. ..
COCOA r
A ..
TA
. . ..
US
to the noa& 7sporO, an? anGan—rdno appyovaz n, rho ovcraYl-
aevelvpment plans to bo pzusupret 17 the ATKOPM WiLh M U110105 COn&719eO&WS,'
1, ApFraval of a Suri wthdivigion;
5074 Planning Connission pjnqtns
Page 3
2 Th(� baildings and all related facilities, espeNa3ly inKyaInp cho parking,
should be moved 15 feet to the noxth, reducing the imDact of the pa icing an IEth Stree;
3. The Green Ash on York Aveaue and 76th 3treez sho"11 be increased to 44-511
caliper and be at least 30 feet on center,�
4. The portion of prcperty north of easll'jlwes-_J'o',,--3,,iaw,-i and zhe portion of proiarn
at the northwest end of the development site must he landscaped and as a
non -buildable site until such time as a land traje may occur, neoaels jta< inn an mnendment
Lo the FRD soning for this property,
5, A bus shelter of similar design to the buMings nust he aesigned anc places
on 76th Street and a bus pull-out zone constructed;
V The height of the buildings shock he stagge7nd so !he fouthVin rcgion dee;
not take on a 22 story appearance, '611P'T. the city council approved the ccncept 0 there
was a great deal of discussion whethor t allow tle mix of hoighvs pyaposed on Onther
to require that three 12scory fuildinyt he In is the Ftntfls olirior tha,
the mixed height approach would be mope appropriate T tkin area,
Vr, Walter Baker, an attorney rarres ent-Ing the Khenewer SoVely, noted ihe unusQ.
parcel norTh of eastiwest Parklawn Avente has been labelled an ontict on the liat to parwo-
control by the City of Edina and to alicw a more Unple wnd exchange; West Ond exchang,-,
has not yec occurred but is still being discussed. lr,st:_�'cyd they wou3d agree io
move the entire project 15 feet north, as long as thore are no futurn problems in regavil
co the seTback fran the nonth property Une. He iTree? d to pyovide the bus anelter and
pull.out zone
Mr. Baker indicat"d "in is the leveloper's imp ransArn chai thr Ky conu&L appnivad
She concept of three 12-storT buildings, -rather' thn mixed hoights ori giipl#
pianned". He notad thet- -ina.i plans are to ocuordance wivi that 2mpre3sinn.
Mr. Baker and Mr, Terry SNaink, the
arahiTner. Dresmuted slines of tie ovenill
site plan of
throw
12-stovy els ildinlf, kith
a cormanv
aM"I i'n i)einieoitn'
-_nC:Iu&'Lrp' a
toporraphic
map, elevatiors,
and drainape,
utilitv,
varyrq, typ&Q
floor pDrs, plann,
and planting
Fdans.
The planting plan will
he annaded
in acroraanae
with che stalf''s
contingency,,
Considerable disauEsian IbIlowe i zogardAp the qnv::Vcm & he_ ht and i& prafer2nce
of the Council, staff, and Planning Conrission mtnbeTs. Or, Ne" uOrnfled Vat altho,plil
the building heights are flexible, the eensicy KiL ait Ka changed,
Mr. 2 joboson moved the Viou Q.el onmont Rans an ipprcvK as presentes, nubject
to the cant ingenclas listed hy nr, Luce, C-. .a.,.'. the AddPd noto tPai the Piannin; Ccmmiss,on
generally would not object to the three 12-Aori5uAcirns. but J7,avcr dre 'r,ixed
height apprnach, Riwiyan secondel the motion. 411 vatod aye , Vulor caoried
OTHEA DUSINASN
1 Mud Lake Repon!
P4. TIM :"E r= to vau vanc?t tnlad tor •the Use ant Dayeino-
TICTIt 'PIlld LZ '.ca 5 v the bud Late Taqx Wee d-ved Ki, 4, 1. and reacnmeAR h h -n
appro-ed pnovideV
-
2 . chn tinning lak- �a on� CLWW�v , 0
a 7orvvy 1� nA
"r, U
10.kiloo zoo oav""
uses or cause such an a:aYaCC10L rhaL Un lo2am<!OL
nxo" Wfa
2
.Snnlna w
IncompaWM. ow
3., che swimnlvV >n± josevio. in
3S
.S...i 100 st"01n.
as to its compatib"iRly VIA uy lumalrdel
at �k"'
polo 0,
Lran:01
isho"',
He noted the Park hoard and E2w1rcvrvqW
QW0.
%xvisAjLo.
vain
rcvtcLj.le 7"N:
repcirt ".ind,
Mr. Dgan reported cue Farm bnard has
de5..iq0
nui
a
vj.h
dans tcr
jawenew
developmankot a seemid �,w&WR
pact at
Tnis
4von,
canVaeta"N discusshin n 7-1, TLC
7110pirg
measures be undevtaken to wenn thn arw� anj
onli
Qv u_
mXmg on;
euroj,X
that noVi
cccvrs'
Av 0whes vmved No AN Lake Rqro-c proserm;'
con rinpanc len,
I Wo L0, pachs and fAnce vW11 Nv voonvoViVid
2 inn voncrpt of � QU in 0�.aolaolo hW Y � ' ? >41 0 � W Ovi :v 150" .4 K-
pilmjnanvn nuanvoR rhe omwrvjKoWnSIMN It 0 ny 'v;o v"..- i"? �i sopy"Wain in 00
area�
nia
VIA Li -`e pact WA a swilmsvp pa:.L na- S01004 50 0. 0, %KZv vy-210 shoaW act me
eUmNated, an''
4. ine WC&C !Stav shculd On vWmAnel to A ocry.iqo almost n%! nu�a Ktewv-�
antivi"7''
M,-' tin ;0201, All VoW cue �.Ov aovn6�'
2. Discussion let rexall Sn.cv in I'lanrea Sh0cloWl WL-io�
W, Lane Waveralneu the 000f, rQsDot �nd nekween WNPS�Le KnWn'
Co,mpaniy ait(i .,',,e City managtr Wroln qhoienaln raquenas a coaditionQ
ose permit to allow retail sales in Yho KnnaW fadd nto'hl 0134rint (P14) CnnditionW,
toe Der,K ale noalloneo Wilvin 00 QYZV Or Nina V,nns;� N a parlinuiar use is a
vaasmable vsey it shovad Pc included hr K zoning o-A.ni,p;s, K A v AN a rnasopa))t.
-
USE, A shovil vuc be ailuv"Q Q ani zowmvi�i Ho Y.zK�� no aaw� oopnnQ avv orAfnav�--'
anendren7 allowl, wondiAcnal wo ponmics wi nwovi, a:v� in ao ��? min aod
tnat this ar'-71 J"
4�-Ipnp� q 1001 A, to r,
permissnon W =nvvy a LNO ;1�� in; f v 7 nn i -, v � -, A 1" Q� 7 7CA1 Awn ni 7415 was 12 myvcv
A1Lx- or 0rnwid cY ui ir �uc
cxvialnul n ncuY bc nxxrom; K KNnaA 1 : r - anAll a �L� Kf ngul 1� �C--
ODA the access, Lraffic not WWWK -0 A"? �WY7. on! in a PY zone
in SUPIWIA ecomern;Q nativ.
„r
Distvict be NOW, as
OV V�u
SYMY - 006 qo�=Voy
a"
precedent
MOSId he OPLawlia1V ,
KP NO,
wSC iqey,
No noiOn, V!
vwoy
Ons K"t
WO VaIVIOA,
3 Ar, huca PUPOVInd
FV
&M:Uran
S rv6c's' 0,
anyone ino
MOP!
hill vile Aas'
WIN b 7 the Coun0l;
hr WoU
naE jodicaced w, f ii -yonord
alto
viv
ingle fmyl-�
develywnenx pxWously
discussed
,
4. W LUCe WrOGWOO
ir
GirJur
Kaphew ywom.i?
lived
an Envirannental
Man�sl
to serve as STM
fOV tht
W- WO Usli�,
viny on
.?l C. nnoivownntal
actinivi'-,
nrevia.Fs# performed hy
the HeaKa,
Park,
aw Mynnirmg
Dnarwnww,
VII Adjournment ,
Rispo.4wiv soNvIned..
Q=O C, NVP Socne.ar';