HomeMy WebLinkAbout1986 03-25 HPB Meeting Minutes RegularA G E N D A
EDINA HERITAGE PRESERVATION BOARD
REGULAR MEETING
TUESDAY, MARCH 25, 1986 7:30 P.M.
EDINA CITY HALL MANAGER'S CONFERENCE ROOM
I. Approval of the Minutes: November 26, 1985
II. Plan Review 4528 Bruce Avenue
III. Historic Markers
IV. Edina Centennial December 12, 1988
V. Election of Officers
VI. Other Business
VII. Next Meeting Date: April 22, 1986 at 7:30 P.M.
VIII. Adjournment
•
MINUTES OF THE REGULAR MEETING
EDINA HERITAGE PRESERVATION BOARD
HELD MARCH 25, 1986 AT 7:30 P.M.
EDINA CITY HALL MANAGER'S CONFERENCE ROOM
MEMBERS PRESENT: Chairman Gordon Stuart, David Gepner,
Tom Martinson, Cy Stuppy, John Childs and Gary Nyberg
STAFF PRESENT: Harold Sand
I. APPROVAL OF MINUTES;
Mr. Stuppy moved approval of the November 26, 1986
minutes. Mr. Martinson seconded. All voted aye. Motion
carried.
II. PLAN REVIEW; 4528 Bruce Avenue
Mr. Sand stated that this proposal was previously
considered by the Board on May 28, July 23, October 22 and
November 26, 1985. On October 22, the proponent presented
schematic plans for an English Tudor style dwelling. The
Board encouraged refinement of the plans and submission of
revised drawings for review at the November meeting. The
proponent did not submit revised drawings, the lack of plans
was noted at the November 26, 1985 meeting and the request
continued indefinitely.
Mr. Sand noted that today the proponent submitted
revised drawings in addition to the plans submitted with the
staff report. The revised drawings incorporate some of the
suggestions for improving the design. The principal change
is a lowering of the large gable in front 4 feet which
improves the overall' proportions of the front elevation. In
addition the conical roof over the dining room bay window
has been changed to a small gable roof. The plans
concentrate the exterior ornamentation on the front and
sides of the building where it is visible from the street.
The rear of the building is stripped of most stone, brick
and wood trim.
The first plan that was presented had a front facing
double garage which the Board deemed incompatible with the
1920's and 1930's Period Revival character of the
neighborhood. The developer has made significant progress
with plans and the current proposal incorporates a north
facing garage that utilizes a common driveway with the
dwelling at 4526 Bruce Avenue.
Mr. Sand introduced the proponent Mr. Jeff Gustafson
and the designer Mr. John Eckley. Mr. Eckley stated the
front gable was reduced in height to improve the design and
to help comply with sideyard setbacks. The dining room
gable is also more compatible with the design. The exterior
materials are stucco with oak half timbers and fieldstone
trim in a random pattern at the base on the front and sides.
The only brick is on the upper portion of the chimney and
there are two flue caps. The windows are casements and
awning windows with millions to adapt to the style. The
colors include a burnt -red asphalt shingle roof, the stucco
is light buff, the fieldstone will be a light brown, the
timbers a dark natural oak and the windows have a dark vinyl
cover to match the timbers. The maximum height is 26 feet
and the east -west ridge is reduced to 24 feet which takes
out alot of the mass. The brick color will be a dark terra
cotta.
Mr. Martinson said that lowering the gable in front has
helped the plans and reduced the mass. The small gable for
the bathroom also helps break up the mass. This is really
more consistent with the other dwellings in the Fairway
section than the previous designs. He suggested that the
developer use the asphalt shingle with some thickness. Mr.
Gustafson said the roof may be a wood shingle. Mr.
Gustafson asked if the building could be adjusted 2 feet to
the rear to align the garage doors. Mr. Sand indicated it
would be acceptable as long as a 25 foot rear yard is
provided.
Mr. Stuppy agreed that the whole plan was much better
looking.
Mr. Martinson moved approval of the plans as presented.
Mr. Childs seconded the motion. All voted aye. Motion
carried.
Mr. Gustafson indicated he would submit samples of the
materials to staff for approval.
III. Historic Markers
Donna Skagerberg representing the Edina Historical
Society said that she has been working with Foster Dunwiddie
on the historic marker program. They have increased the
list of major signs to 15 and the minor signs to 17. The
major signs are larger and designed to contain text and
photographs. They will have to investigate expenses and
funding. Mr. Martinson volunteered to help write the text.
Mr. Nyberg enters the meeting.
IV. Edina Centennial December 12, 1988
Donna Skagerberg reviewed the status of the Centennial
preparations which are being headed by the Edina Foundation
with the assistance of the Edina Historical Society. They
are considering publishing a historical calendar. They
would also like to, publish a finished version of Paul
Hesterman's report on the History of Edina. Some of the
events will include the 4th of July parade, and a High
School Marching Band reunion. Mr. Gepner suggested that the
school participate to gain a sense of History. Mr. Sand
suggested that the HPB could publish a gold centennial
version of the History and Architecture of Edina, Minnesota,
promote the historic driving tour of Edina and promote the
historic markers program. Mrs. Skagerberg stated that they
are also organizing lectures, bus tours and encouraging
community organizations to research and write their history.
Marilyn Curtis has agreed to attend the HPB Meetings as a
liaison with the Edina Historical Society.
V. Election of Officers
Mr. Stuart opened the floor for nominations for
chairman. Mr. Martinson nominated Mr. Stuart for chairman.
Mr. Childs seconded the motion. All voted aye. Motion
carried. Mr. Stuppy agreed to serve as Vice Chairman. Mr.
Martinson nominated Mr. Stuppy for Vice -Chairman. Mr.
Childs seconded. All voted aye. Motion carried.
VI. Other Business:
A. Preservation Week. Mr. Sand advised that national
preservation week is May 11-17. In View of the preparations
for the Edina Centennial this may be a good time to tart
promotion. Mr. Nyberg suggested a notice in the Edina Sun/
Current.
B. Hennepin -County Historical Society liaison. Mr.
Sand advised that the board is required to have a number of
Hennepin -County Historical represented. Mr. Gepner
volunteered to join and serve as liaison.
C. 4611 Edina Boulevard. Mr. Sand advised the Board
that the variances were approved without any requirement for
review by the cap. The final plans are scaled down with the
existing garage and sun room preserved in their present
condition.
d. 4617 Moorland Avenue. Mr. Sand advised that the
family room addition has been completed according to the
approved plans.
VII. NEXT MEETING DATE;
April 22, 1986 at 7:30 p.m.
VIII. ADJOURNMENT:
Mr. Martinson moved to adjourn at 9:45 p.m. Mr.
Nyberg seconded the motion. All voted aye. Motion carried.
Respectfully submitted,
Harold Sand